Temptalia Logo
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • Coloured RaineUp to 60% off, plus extra 10% off with code TEMPTALIA, ends 11/26.
  • Muse Beauty20% off sitewide, ends 11/29.
  • SephoraBenefit They're Real mascara for $12.50, ends 11/20.
  • UltaBlack Friday deals available for preview here, live 11/22 at 5PM CST, ends 11/23.

Sephora Fairytale Dupes

Sephora Fairytale Contour Eye Pencil (DCDiscontinued. $10.00/0.04 oz.) dupes are shown below with comparison swatches (when available). Refine by price to find cheaper dupes or by brand and availability for a product more accessible for you.

How similar is Junkie to Fairytale?

92%
Similar

$11.00
More

3 Votes | Dupe is Cooler (1), Lighter (1), Less Pigmented (1) 3 Votes | Dupe is Cooler (1), Lighter (1), Less Pigmented (1)

92%
Similar

$11.00
More

Junkie is...

  • Cooler (1)
  • Lighter (1)
  • Less Pigmented (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Junkie to Fairytale?

90%
Similar

$5.00
More

Undercurrent is...

  • Cooler (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Undercurrent to Fairytale?

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

How similar is Ocean to Fairytale?

90%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Lighter (1) 1 Vote | Dupe is Lighter (1)

90%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

Ocean is...

  • Lighter (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Ocean to Fairytale?

How similar is #52L to Fairytale?

90%
Similar

$9.00
More

1 Vote | Dupe is Lighter (1), Brighter (1) 1 Vote | Dupe is Lighter (1), Brighter (1)

90%
Similar

$9.00
More

#52L is...

  • Lighter (1)
  • Brighter (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is #52L to Fairytale?

How similar is Waterfall to Fairytale?

90%
Similar

$0.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Warmer (1) 1 Vote | Dupe is Warmer (1)

90%
Similar

$0.00
Savings

Waterfall is...

  • Warmer (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Waterfall to Fairytale?

How similar is Gemstoned to Fairytale?

88%
Similar

$14.00
More

2 Votes | Dupe is More shimmery (1), Brighter (1) 2 Votes | Dupe is More shimmery (1), Brighter (1)

88%
Similar

$14.00
More

Gemstoned is...

  • More shimmery (1)
  • Brighter (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Gemstoned to Fairytale?

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

85%
Similar

$11.00
More

Overdrive is...

  • Warmer (2)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Overdrive to Fairytale?

How similar is Good Karma to Fairytale?

85%
Similar

$2.50
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Cooler (1) 1 Vote | Dupe is Cooler (1)

85%
Similar

$2.50
Savings

Good Karma is...

  • Cooler (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Good Karma to Fairytale?

How similar is Ody(sea) (62) to Fairytale?

80%
Similar

$15.00
More

2 Votes | Dupe is Lighter (1), Warmer (1) 2 Votes | Dupe is Lighter (1), Warmer (1)

80%
Similar

$15.00
More

Ody(sea) (62) is...

  • Lighter (1)
  • Warmer (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Ody(sea) (62) to Fairytale?

80%
Similar

$13.00
More

Paradis is...

  • More shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
View Dupe Details

How similar is Paradis to Fairytale?

Showing Possible Dupes For:

Sephora Fairytale