Skip to content
Temptalia Logo

MAC Mystery Dupes

Here are our dupes for MAC Mystery, which is a neutral-toned, medium-dark taupe with a matte finish. It is a discontinued eyeshadow that retails for $17.00 and contains 0.05 oz.

Review
= Verified
Gallery Options
Products
Swatches
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
C+
Mystery
MAC
$17.00, Discontinued
Review
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Laura Mercier Earth Matte Eye Colour
Earth Laura Mercier
Limited Edition
B
$23.00
98%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$6.00
More
Earth is... cooler (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Laura Mercier Earth Matte Eye Colour
98%
Earth
Laura Mercier
$23.00, Limited Edition
  • Cooler (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Anastasia Volatile Eyeshadow
Volatile Anastasia
Limited Edition
A-
$12.00
96%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$5.00
Savings
Volatile is... lighter (1), cooler (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Anastasia Volatile Eyeshadow
96%
Volatile
Anastasia
$12.00, Limited Edition
  • Lighter (1)
  • Cooler (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Tom Ford Beauty Solar Exposure #4 Eye Color
Solar Exposure #4 Tom Ford Beauty
Limited Edition
C-
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Solar Exposure #4 is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Tom Ford Beauty Solar Exposure #4 Eye Color
95%
Solar Exposure #4
Tom Ford Beauty
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
C-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
MAC Concrete Eyeshadow
Concrete MAC
Permanent
B+
$17.00
95%
Similar
$0.00
Savings
Concrete is... less shimmery (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Concrete Eyeshadow
95%
Concrete
MAC
$17.00, Permanent
  • Less shimmery (1)
Full Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
MAC Drama in the Snow Eyeshadow
Drama in the Snow MAC
Limited Edition
B
$17.00
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Drama in the Snow is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Drama in the Snow Eyeshadow
95%
Drama in the Snow
MAC
$17.00, Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Clinique French Roast All About Shadow
French Roast Clinique
Permanent in Palette
C+
$15.00
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$2.00
Savings
French Roast is... darker (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Clinique French Roast All About Shadow
95%
French Roast
Clinique
$15.00, Permanent in Palette
  • Darker (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
C+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Persona Maverick Eyeshadow
Maverick Persona
Permanent in Palette
A-
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Maverick is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Persona Maverick Eyeshadow
95%
Maverick
Persona
%%COMMA%% Permanent in Palette
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
bareMinerals Tide Pool READY Eyeshadow
Tide Pool bareMinerals
Limited Edition
A-
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Tide Pool is... lighter (1), cooler (1), less pigmented (1)
View Detailed Comparison
bareMinerals Tide Pool READY Eyeshadow
95%
Tide Pool
bareMinerals
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Lighter (1)
  • Cooler (1)
  • Less pigmented (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
NARS Belladonna Eyeshadow
Belladonna NARS
Discontinued
B
$25.00
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$8.00
More
Belladonna is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
NARS Belladonna Eyeshadow
95%
Belladonna
NARS
$25.00, Discontinued
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Too Faced Dolly Eyeshadow
Dolly Too Faced
Permanent in Palette
A-
$16.00
94%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$1.00
Savings
Dolly is... less shimmery (1), lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Too Faced Dolly Eyeshadow
94%
Dolly
Too Faced
$16.00, Permanent in Palette
  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Tarte Eiffel for You Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow
Eiffel for You Tarte
Limited Edition
B+
93%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Eiffel for You is... darker (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Tarte Eiffel for You Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow
93%
Eiffel for You
Tarte
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Sephora Roasted Chestnuts Colorful Eyeshadow (Discontinued)
Roasted Chestnuts Sephora
Discontinued
B
$10.00
93%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$7.00
Savings
Roasted Chestnuts is... darker (2), less shimmery (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sephora Roasted Chestnuts Colorful Eyeshadow (Discontinued)
93%
Roasted Chestnuts
Sephora
$10.00, Discontinued
  • Darker (2)
  • Less shimmery (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Anastasia Mercury Eyeshadow
Mercury Anastasia
Discontinued
B
$12.00
93%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$5.00
Savings
Mercury is... lighter (1), less shimmery (1), more pigmented (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Anastasia Mercury Eyeshadow
93%
Mercury
Anastasia
$12.00, Discontinued
  • Lighter (1)
  • Less shimmery (1)
  • More pigmented (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Too Faced Chocolate Cake Eyeshadow
Chocolate Cake Too Faced
Limited Edition
B-
$16.00
93%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$1.00
Savings
Chocolate Cake is... darker (2), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Too Faced Chocolate Cake Eyeshadow
93%
Chocolate Cake
Too Faced
$16.00, Limited Edition
  • Darker (2)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
B-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Sydney Grace Enjoy the Ride Matte Shadow
Enjoy the Ride Sydney Grace
Permanent
A
$5.25
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$11.75
Savings
Enjoy the Ride is... more shimmery (1), darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sydney Grace Enjoy the Ride Matte Shadow
90%
Enjoy the Ride
Sydney Grace
$5.25, Permanent
  • More shimmery (1)
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Wet 'n' Wild Sweet as Candy #1 Color Icon Eyeshadow (2018)
Sweet as Candy #1 Wet 'n' Wild
Permanent in Palette
B+
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Sweet as Candy #1 is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Wet 'n' Wild Sweet as Candy #1 Color Icon Eyeshadow (2018)
90%
Sweet as Candy #1
Wet 'n' Wild
%%COMMA%% Permanent in Palette
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Back to Top