Skip to content
Temptalia Logo

MAC Mystery Dupes

Here are our dupes for MAC Mystery, which is a neutral-toned, medium-dark taupe with a matte finish. It is a discontinued eyeshadow that retails for $17.00 and contains 0.05 oz.

Review
= Verified
Gallery Options
Products
Swatches
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
C+
Mystery
MAC
$17.00, Discontinued
Review
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Guerlain Les Cendres #3 Eyeshadow
Les Cendres #3 Guerlain
Limited Edition
C
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Les Cendres #3 is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Guerlain Les Cendres #3 Eyeshadow
90%
Les Cendres #3
Guerlain
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
C
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
ColourPop The Virgo Pressed Powder Shadow
The Virgo ColourPop
Permanent
B+
$4.50
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$12.50
Savings
The Virgo is... cooler (1)
View Detailed Comparison
ColourPop The Virgo Pressed Powder Shadow
90%
The Virgo
ColourPop
$4.50, Permanent
  • Cooler (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
theBalm Woodie Shadow/Liner
Woodie theBalm
Limited Edition
C
$16.00
90%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$1.00
Savings
Woodie is... less shimmery (2), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
theBalm Woodie Shadow/Liner
90%
Woodie
theBalm
$16.00, Limited Edition
  • Less shimmery (2)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
C
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Divergent Bold Espresso High Pigment Eyeshadow
Bold Espresso Divergent
Limited Edition
88%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$17.00
Savings
Bold Espresso is... warmer (2)
View Detailed Comparison
Divergent Bold Espresso High Pigment Eyeshadow
88%
Bold Espresso
Divergent
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Warmer (2)
Editor's Comparison
-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Too Faced Dark Chocolate Eyeshadow
Dark Chocolate Too Faced
Limited Edition
C+
$16.00
88%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$1.00
Savings
Dark Chocolate is... warmer (2), darker (1), glossier (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Too Faced Dark Chocolate Eyeshadow
88%
Dark Chocolate
Too Faced
$16.00, Limited Edition
  • Warmer (2)
  • Darker (1)
  • Glossier (1)
Editor's Comparison
C+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Too Faced Knockout Eyeshadow
Knockout Too Faced
Limited Edition
B+
$16.00
88%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$1.00
Savings
Knockout is... darker (2)
View Detailed Comparison
Too Faced Knockout Eyeshadow
88%
Knockout
Too Faced
$16.00, Limited Edition
  • Darker (2)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
MAC Cocktail Black Eyeshadow
Cocktail Black MAC
Limited Edition
C+
$17.00
88%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Cocktail Black is... darker (1), less pigmented (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Cocktail Black Eyeshadow
88%
Cocktail Black
MAC
$17.00, Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
  • Less pigmented (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
C+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
MAC Cocktail Black Eyeshadow
Cocktail Black MAC
Limited Edition
C+
$17.00
88%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Cocktail Black is... darker (1), less pigmented (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Cocktail Black Eyeshadow
88%
Cocktail Black
MAC
$17.00, Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
  • Less pigmented (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
C+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Rouge Bunny Rouge Umber Fire Finch Long-Lasting Eyeshadow
Umber Fire Finch Rouge Bunny Rouge
Permanent
D+
$19.00
88%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$2.00
More
Umber Fire Finch is... cooler (2), darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Rouge Bunny Rouge Umber Fire Finch Long-Lasting Eyeshadow
88%
Umber Fire Finch
Rouge Bunny Rouge
$19.00, Permanent
  • Cooler (2)
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
D+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
MAC Brun Eyeshadow
Brun MAC
Permanent
B
$17.00
88%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Brun is... darker (1), lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Brun Eyeshadow
88%
Brun
MAC
$17.00, Permanent
  • Darker (1)
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Sydney Grace Robert (Deep) Matte Shadow
Robert (Deep) Sydney Grace
Permanent in Palette
A
$5.25
85%
Similar
85%
By Editor
$11.75
Savings
Robert (Deep) is... darker (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sydney Grace Robert (Deep) Matte Shadow
85%
Robert (Deep)
Sydney Grace
$5.25, Permanent in Palette
  • Darker (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
MAC Bowl Out Eyeshadow
Bowl Out MAC
Limited Edition
B+
$17.00
85%
Similar
85%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Bowl Out is... cooler (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Bowl Out Eyeshadow
85%
Bowl Out
MAC
$17.00, Limited Edition
  • Cooler (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Make Up For Ever M626 Neutral Brown Artist Shadow (Discontinued)
M626 Neutral Brown Make Up For Ever
Discontinued
$21.00
85%
Similar
85%
By Editor
$4.00
More
M626 Neutral Brown is... darker (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Make Up For Ever M626 Neutral Brown Artist Shadow (Discontinued)
85%
M626 Neutral Brown
Make Up For Ever
$21.00, Discontinued
  • Darker (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
LORAC Espresso Eyeshadow
Espresso LORAC
Permanent in Palette
A-
$19.00
85%
Similar
85%
By Editor
$2.00
More
Espresso is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
LORAC Espresso Eyeshadow
85%
Espresso
LORAC
$19.00, Permanent in Palette
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Anastasia Horizon Eyeshadow
Horizon Anastasia
Limited Edition
B
$12.00
85%
Similar
85%
By Editor
$5.00
Savings
Horizon is... more shimmery (1), darker (1), cooler (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Anastasia Horizon Eyeshadow
85%
Horizon
Anastasia
$12.00, Limited Edition
  • More shimmery (1)
  • Darker (1)
  • Cooler (1)
Editor's Comparison
B
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
MAC Mystery Eyeshadow
Mystery MAC
Discontinued
C+
$17.00
Too Faced Sexspresso Eyeshadow
Sexspresso Too Faced
Permanent in Palette
B+
$16.00
85%
Similar
85%
By Editor
$1.00
Savings
Sexspresso is... darker (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Too Faced Sexspresso Eyeshadow
85%
Sexspresso
Too Faced
$16.00, Permanent in Palette
  • Darker (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Back to Top