Temptalia Logo
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • SaksEarn a gift card up to $700 (includes beauty) with code SEPT2018, ends 9/28.

Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette

01/07

Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette
Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette

Sugar Peach

Too Faced Sugar Peach Wet/Dry Face & Eye Palette ($42.00 for 0.68 oz.) just released and contains a light beige, orange-coral, peachy-brown, and pop of pink with all of the shades containing shimmer. Three of the shades were high-shine to metallic and one shade was sparkly. The shades could be used with a wet brush or sponge to intensify the shine/shimmer in the respective shade, but the pigmentation, blendability, and luminosity were all easy to achieve with a dry brush so wet application wasn’t necessary–it made the palette very versatile as it was truly wet/dry.

9
Product
10
Pigmentation
9
Texture
8.5
Longevity
5
Application
92%
Total

Also In This Review

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

NARS Atomic Blonde Eye & Cheek Palette

01/07

NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette
NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette

Atomic Blonde

NARS Atomic Blonde Fall 2018 Eye & Cheek Palette ($59.00 for 0.66 oz.) is a new, limited edition palette exclusive to Sephora. It includes four eyeshadows, a highlighter, and a bronzer. They’re all very warm-toned in hues of peach and copper, though the bronzer was the last warm-toned with its rosier tone. Two products in the palette were total misses in my experience, and since there were only six products, that had a huge impact.

Also In This Review

A-

Icon

Discontinued
Read Review
A

Isolde #2

Discontinued
Read Review
F

Kink

Discontinued
Read Review
B+

Galapagos

Discontinued
Read Review
A

Last Call

Limited Edition
Read Review
D+

Unleashed

Limited Edition
Read Review

MAC x Nicopanda Stay Cute Full Face Kit

01/07

MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit

Stay Cute

MAC Stay Cute Nicopanda Full Face Kit ($40.00 for 0.40 oz.) rounds out the collection’s Face Kits as the final disappointment in the trilogy. The eyeshadows were dismal, and the blush was workable but was barely decent.

Stay Cute
Stay Cute
4
Product
6.5
Pigmentation
5.5
Texture
5
Longevity
2.5
Application
52%
Total

Also In This Review

B

Cheeky Chic

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Snow Panda

Limited Edition
Read Review
D+

Misfit

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Cyber Goth

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Supah-Pink

Limited Edition
Read Review
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

MAC x Nicopanda Primapanda Full Face Kit

01/07

MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit

Primapanda

MAC Primapanda Nicopanda Full Face Kit ($40.00 for 0.40 oz.) makes one wonder if brands even bother to test their own products prior to releasing them to consumers. Every single product in the palette fell below what one would look for in a mid-end product with two shades being absolutely atrocious. Eyeshadow primer did not alleviate the overall application issues and only improved wear by a few hours but by no means long enough to make it through even an eight-hour day.

Primapanda
Primapanda
3
Product
6
Pigmentation
5.5
Texture
3.5
Longevity
2
Application
44%
Total

Also In This Review

C

Plum Sparkle

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Midas

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Freakshow

Limited Edition
Read Review
B

BLK

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Pout

Limited Edition
Read Review

MAC x Nicopanda Preppy Panda Full Face Kit

01/09

MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC x Nicopanda | Look Details
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC x Nicopanda | Look Details
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit
MAC x Nicopanda | <a href=Look Details">
MAC x Nicopanda | <a href=Look Details">

Preppy Panda

MAC Preppy Panda Nicopanda Full Face Kit ($40.00 for 0.40 oz.) is just another example of MAC’s emphasis on packaging without putting much effort into ensuring the quality of the actual product inside that “cool” packaging of theirs. It performed poorly on its own, and it wasn’t salvaged by primer. One shade was a complete miss–one of the brand’s worst eyeshadows ever–and two of the three remaining shades were merely disappointing rather than devastating.

Also In This Review

B+

Unicorn Dust

Limited Edition
Read Review
B-

Otaku

Limited Edition
Read Review
C-

Harajuku Blu

Limited Edition
Read Review
C+

Panda Riot

Limited Edition
Read Review
F

Atomic Blush

Limited Edition
Read Review

Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette

01/13

Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Palette | Look Details
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Palette | Look Details
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette
Urban Decay Backtalk Palette | <a href=Look Details">
Urban Decay Backtalk Palette | <a href=Look Details">

Backtalk

Urban Decay Backtalk Eye & Face Palette ($46.00 for 0.88 oz.) is a new, limited edition palette exclusive to Sephora. It’s a warm-toned palette with a pinker-leaning, but I don’t think that it resulted in quite the berry/mauve (read: cooler-toned) palette that readers expected when it was initially launched. I think that the palette may suffer from a lack of versatility, as I felt like a lot of potential looks looked rather similar, but for someone who is after a certain type of look, the color scheme might work just fine.

The eyeshadow quality was below the brand’s typical one (though I liked the two mattes in the palette quite a bit) from my experience, particularly for shimmery shades like Shade and Attitude (I find the brand shines with these types of finishes, usually), though I didn’t experience as bad of a palette as others, including some readers, have had. I didn’t have any trouble with the cheek colors, though Urban Decay markets their Afterglow blushes/highlighters as buildable in pigmentation and having eight-hour wear.

Reviews seem to be either “worst palette ever” or “it’s decent” (I’m not seeing tons of “best palette ever” kind of remarks). I try to avoid reading too many reviews about products before testing and reviewing them myself (when I know that I plan to review) to avoid any potential to be influenced. Even my best blogging friend, Muse, and I had very different experiences (and we tend to agree most of the time), where hers was one of the worst palettes she had ever used. I saw several customer reviews mention that there was “no pigmentation” even when used over primer or after three layers of product, which was definitely far worse (and different) than my experience – I also compared the press sample I received to one I purchased from Sephora (online) the day it launched but didn’t find any significant differences.