Temptalia Logo
Temptalia Logo
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Sephora Beautylish Ulta Nordstrom More
  • Bite Beauty — 4-piece set (mini sizes of Maple Lip Mask, Brioche Multistick, Liquorice Lipstick, plus pouch) with $50+ purchase with code XOCANADA, ends 10/14.
  • Pat McGrath Labs — 10% off holiday collection with code OBSESSED here, ends 10/16.
  • Tatcha — 20% off with code FRIENDS19, ends 10/20.
  • Ulta — Gorgeous Hair Event on now, 50% off daily beauty steals (view here), ends 10/26.
  • Ulta — 20% off coupon (plus one for your BFF), includes prestige (sent via email), ends 10/27.

MAC Vanilla Dupes

MAC Vanilla Eyeshadow (Permanent. $17.00/0.05 oz.) dupes are shown below with comparison swatches (when available). Refine by price to find cheaper dupes or by brand and availability for a product more accessible for you.

Product Details
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B+
Permanent in Palette PiP

Vanilla

Smashbox
Photo Op Eyeshadow
How similar is Vanilla to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is More muted (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Vanilla is...

  • More muted (1)
How similar is Vanilla to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B
Limited Edition LE

Dream On

Too Faced
Eyeshadow
How similar is Dream On to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Darker (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Dream On is...

  • Darker (1)
How similar is Dream On to Vanilla?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Sephora Beautylish Ulta Nordstrom More
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
A-
Permanent in Palette PiP

Rockabilly

Too Faced
Eyeshadow
How similar is Rockabilly to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Brighter (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Rockabilly is...

  • Brighter (1)
How similar is Rockabilly to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
A-
Permanent in Palette PiP

Glow

Colour Pop
Super Shock Shadow
How similar is Glow to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$12.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is More muted (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$12.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Glow is...

  • More muted (1)
How similar is Glow to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B-
Limited Edition LE

Full Moon

Tarte
Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow
How similar is Full Moon to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Cooler (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Full Moon is...

  • Cooler (1)
How similar is Full Moon to Vanilla?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Sephora Beautylish Ulta Nordstrom More
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B
Limited Edition LE

The Night's Quad #2

Wet 'n' Wild
Color Icon Eyeshadow (2018)
How similar is The Night's Quad #2 to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

2 Votes | Dupe is More muted (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

The Night's Quad #2 is...

  • More muted (1)
How similar is The Night's Quad #2 to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
A
Discontinued DC

Lifelike

Kat Von D
Eyeshadow
How similar is Lifelike to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Lighter (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Lifelike is...

  • Lighter (1)
How similar is Lifelike to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
C+
Limited Edition LE

Compassionate

Tarte
Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow
How similar is Compassionate to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is More muted (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Compassionate is...

  • More muted (1)
How similar is Compassionate to Vanilla?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Sephora Beautylish Ulta Nordstrom More
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
A-
Limited Edition LE

Center Stage

Colour Pop
Pressed Powder Shadow
How similar is Center Stage to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$12.50
Savings

2 Votes | Dupe is Cooler (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$12.50
Savings

View Dupe Details

Center Stage is...

  • Cooler (1)
How similar is Center Stage to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
A-
Permanent in Palette PiP

Buttercream

Laura Mercier
Matte Eye Colour
How similar is Buttercream to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$6.00
More

1 Vote | Dupe is Less shimmery (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$6.00
More

View Dupe Details

Buttercream is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
How similar is Buttercream to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B
Permanent in Palette PiP

Nude Awakening #5

Wet 'n' Wild
Color Icon Eyeshadow (2018)
How similar is Nude Awakening #5 to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Darker (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Nude Awakening #5 is...

  • Darker (1)
How similar is Nude Awakening #5 to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B+
Permanent in Palette PiP

Bone

Bobbi Brown
Eye Shadow
How similar is Bone to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$5.00
More

1 Vote | Dupe is Warmer (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$5.00
More

View Dupe Details

Bone is...

  • Warmer (1)
How similar is Bone to Vanilla?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Sephora Beautylish Ulta Nordstrom More
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
A-
Limited Edition LE

Purr

Too Faced
Eyeshadow
How similar is Purr to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

1 Vote
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$1.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Purr is...

How similar is Purr to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B
Limited Edition LE

Righteous

Urban Decay
Eyeshadow
How similar is Righteous to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$2.00
More

1 Vote | Dupe is More muted (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$2.00
More

View Dupe Details

Righteous is...

  • More muted (1)
How similar is Righteous to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
C
Limited Edition LE

Newport Nights #1

Wet 'n' Wild
Photo Op Eyeshadow
How similar is Newport Nights #1 to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

2 Votes | Dupe is Darker (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Newport Nights #1 is...

  • Darker (1)
How similar is Newport Nights #1 to Vanilla?
B
Permanent P

Vanilla

MAC
Eyeshadow
B+
Permanent in Palette PiP

Rust (Highlight)

Kat Von D
Eyeshadow
How similar is Rust (Highlight) to Vanilla?

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

1 Vote | Dupe is Warmer (1)
View Dupe Details

95%
Similar

$17.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Rust (Highlight) is...

  • Warmer (1)
How similar is Rust (Highlight) to Vanilla?