MAC Mystery vs. MAC Cocktail Black Comparison

Editor's Comparison

MAC Mystery is a neutral taupe with a matte finish that is discontinued and retails for $17.00. In comparison, MAC Cocktail Black is a cool taupe with a satin finish that is limited edition and retails for $17.00.

MAC Cocktail Black is 95% similar — it is darker.

Community Comparison

• Cocktail Black is Less pigmented (1)
• Cocktail Black is Warmer (1)
• Cocktail Black is Lower quality (1)