MAC By Request – Lipsticks Review, Photos, Swatches

MAC 3N Lipstick
MAC 3N Lipstick

MAC By Request – Lipsticks Review, Photos, Swatches

MAC By Request is a collection that’s voted on by the fans–there are 18 shades of lipstick, lipglass, and eyeshadow that MAC has listed for grabs, and your votes will determine the top three from each product type that will go on to be launched in an online exclusive, limited edition collection in August. Voting is open and closes on March 30th and users can vote once per product category per day. Not sure where to cast your vote? I’ve got the goods on the six lipsticks up for a comeback! ๐Ÿ™‚

The formula on these was typical MAC–I didn’t have any unexpected issues with these. ย Generally, I find lustre lipsticks to be drying and wear only two hours or so. ย The more matte-like finishes (Candy Yum Yum, Moxie, Rocker) felt creamy and opaque, so no trouble there. ย Glaze finishes (Shitaki) are less drying than lustres though still a touch drying over time and tend to wear for a similar short time. ย MAC lipsticks are vanilla scented.

Continuing with the fun, here are some shades I think could have been good choices: Ahoy, There! (Naughty Nauticals ’08), Angeldish (Aquadisiac ’03), Big Bow (Hello Kitty ’09), Blue Eve (Eden Rocks ’01), Blueberry Fizz (Cocktails, ’01), Brave New Bronze (Style Warrior ’09), Curtsy (Dance ’06), Fashionably Fuchsia (Classic Coordinates ’06), Flash-n-Dash (Fafi ’08), Gladiola (Dame Edna ’08), High Top (Fafi ’08), Isabella Blow (MAC for Isabella BLow ’05), Jazzed (In the Groove ’10), Legendary Femme (Raquel Welch ’07), Lollipop Loving (Heatherette ’08), Marisheeno (Lustreful ’04), Mellow Mood (Electroflash ’08), Merry Mistress (Black Tied ’01), Pink Maribu (Lingerie ’05), Port Red (Naughty Nauticals ’08), Queen’s Sin (Antiquitease ’07), Rebelrose (Rebel Rock ’05), Red No. 5 (MACouture ’06), Rococo (Rococo ’04), Strawberry Blonde (Catherine Deneuve ’06), Tiger Tiger (Raquel Welch ’07), Wild ‘Bout You (Rockocco ’06).

I was confused when I saw both Eden Rocks and Shitaki being promoted–I thought they were both permanent, but I guess they were discontinued in the past two years or so. (If they were such bestsellers, why were they ever discontinued?!) With a collection concept like this one, I think the older the better–and certainly not shades that were permanent for years! If we’re going to go so recent, might as well repromote the Iris Apfel lipsticks, since those sold out so quickly. It’s just such a great concept and one that fans have been asking to see forever, and I’m left wondering, “What data did you use to come up with these lists?” Because I can’t seriously believe that there was no top selling coral lipstick–historically, MAC corals sell out quickly!

I am however pleased to see Moxie and Rocker make the list — those are two I’ve heard about, and they’re both oldies (but goodies). I don’t think I have most of these in the original forms; I should have 3N and Candy Yum Yum, but I’m not so sure about Eden Rocks. I know I owned Shitaki once upon a time, but I don’t think I kept it.

MAC By Request – Lipsticks Review, Photos, Swatches

A-
9
Product
10
Pigmentation
9
Texture
9
Longevity
4.5
Application
92%
Total
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

MAC 3N Lipstick
MAC 3N Lipstick

MAC 3N Lipstick
MAC 3N Lipstick (Diffused/Bounced Flash)

MAC 3N Lipstick
MAC 3N Lipstick (Studio “Natural” Lighting)

MAC 3N Lipstick
MAC 3N Lipstick

MAC 3N Lipstick
MAC 3N Lipstick

MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick
MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick

MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick
MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick (Diffused/Bounced Flash)

MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick
MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick (Studio “Natural” Lighting)

MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick
MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick

MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick
MAC Candy Yum Yum Lipstick

MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick
MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick

MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick
MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick (Diffused/Bounced Flash)

MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick
MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick (Studio “Natural” Lighting)

MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick
MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick)

MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick
MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick

MAC Moxie Lipstick
MAC Moxie Lipstick

MAC Moxie Lipstick
MAC Moxie Lipstick (Diffused/Bounced Flash)

MAC Moxie Lipstick
MAC Moxie Lipstick (Studio “Natural” Lighting)

MAC Moxie Lipstick
MAC Moxie Lipstick

MAC Moxie Lipstick
MAC Moxie Lipstick

MAC Rocker Lipstick
MAC Rocker Lipstick

MAC Rocker Lipstick
MAC Rocker Lipstick (Diffused/Bounced Flash)

MAC Rocker Lipstick
MAC Rocker Lipstick (Studio “Natural” Lighting)

MAC Rocker Lipstick
MAC Rocker Lipstick

MAC Rocker Lipstick
MAC Rocker Lipstick

MAC Shitaki Lipstick
MAC Shitaki Lipstick

MAC Shitaki Lipstick
MAC Shitaki Lipstick (Diffused/Bounced Flash)

MAC Shitaki Lipstick
MAC Shitaki Lipstick (Studio “Natural” Lighting)

MAC Shitaki Lipstick
MAC Shitaki Lipstick

MAC Shitaki Lipstick
MAC Shitaki Lipstick

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

About the Reviewer

Reviewer

Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). For more matches, please read our full Foundation FAQ. For more information on our review process, please read our Review FAQ.

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

148 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

I hope so too! I actually have it but use it sparingly since it had been discontinued. It’s such a gorgeous colour! I’d love to be able to buy another tube!

I’ve been voting daily for it but it seems to be stuck in fourth place right now (Candy YY, 3N, Rocker) so it might not make it unless it gets more votes. ๐Ÿ™

Christine says in her post that she is sure that moxie and rocker made th list, and I’m thinking the other one will be candy yum yum. I’m looking forward to moxie coming out. Christine do you know If it will be available At counters if so when internationally?

Moxie looks awesome, I hope it makes the final cut. Yes! Queen’s SIn should’ve been offered, I’ve waited years to try it. And Big Bow, I’m wearing it today over Pink Pigeon and I’m halfway down the tube, I’d love to get a back-up one day.

Thank you for the pictures Christine, but the pictures look different. Especially the ones of just the lips. I like the older way in which you took pictures better.

Christine, this diffused flash/ bounced flash thing is confusing me. Can you explain why the swatches look so different in these lightings and which is more true to life?

Flash is a bright pop of light that you’re probably familiar with – diffused means that the flash is softened in some way. I use an actual diffuser cap for my flash, but the idea is like holding a tissue over the flash itself so the light is softer, less harsh. Bouncing means you angle the flash of light so it reflects off something else (ceiling, wall, reflective surface) rather than directly on the subject. Here’s a Wikipedia article on Flash – http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flash_(photography)

Both, for different reasons. Flash undoubtedly is more light than you will find yourself in most of the time, but flash enables textures and nuances to really come through, while “natural” light tends to make things appear softer, almost washed out. Overall, I find flash more accurate as long as it is softened, whether it’s just turned down, diffused, bounced, etc.

I have Lazy Day, but I wish I had voted for 3N ….I voted for “Moxie,” before I saw the swatches. While “Moxie” is so me! I have similar colors… And I probably do of 3N, but 3N looks so nice…

Candy Yum Yum is winning right now, which is cool… I happen to have 2 of them and love it… But I mean I don’t need it to come around so quickly again.

I voted for Moth Brown e/s and Bait L/G .

Moxie looks redder and warmer than the original. (Original is comparable on me to Revlon Cherries in the Snow– CITS is a touch brighter and redder, Moxie is pinker and darker. But very, very similar after you blot CITS.)

The pics for shitaki seem mixed up, some are the bright pink of moxie, some the red of rocker and some the brown which I think is the correct shitaki ๐Ÿ™

The pictures are not mixed up – I just double checked! I’m not sure what you’re seeing – Shitaki is brown in all the photos, definitely no bright pink or red!

I was reading the blog on my iPad andthe pics still appear in the wrong order there, but reading on my phone they all look right. It must be my iPad being naughty, sorry! I might have to use this as my excuse to buy the new one ๐Ÿ˜‰

I really hate that they did Candy Yum Yum with this.. Not because I don’t like CYY, but because it came out so recently it was almost guaranteed to be repromoted, especially since it did so well. I think that they should’ve stuck with the older stuff that you can’t find anymore. Moxie and Rocker have my vote for this one.

thank you for taking the time to swatch all those, it leaves us who are voting with more of an idea what we really want to see back especially if we weren’t familiar with the color! THanks so much!

Hi Christine,

I wish they would have brought into the mix “Packed Pink” lipstick… I know it was discontinued quite a few years ago… And I know there is the drug store dupe… But I want this color.

Rose McGowan was such a fan of this color she bought 21 tubes, before they discontinued it… I really love it on her and think it would suit me well.. I think it’s a pink-coral or yellow midtone/brightish pink… Pretty.

I think at any rate they should have brought that back and “Made with love” was another great LE Pink coral lustre lipstick… I have a back up new one still, but like you said MAC has great corals, this imo being one of them.

These are all gorgeous on you!!! I can’t decided between 3n, candy yum yum, moxie and rocker! they are all so pretty!! especially on you!

No way these are their most requested colours. I think some of them are in-line with Fall trends and don’t have current MAC dupes though.

I like your new photo style and that mascara looks really good on you.

i loove your eye makeup in this one ๐Ÿ™‚ i’m liking 3N but i already have something like that (kinda-too faced totally nude) and i like shitaki. i think i will vote for them.

I’m soooo happy with these new changes u’ve made to the blog ๐Ÿ™‚ thank u so much! Dear, could u please tell me the different types of finishes of mac lipsticks available…or if u have done an article before, could u please link me to it? Thanks..

Hi Christine! thank you for always being so amazing with reviews and swatches. I have been a fan for about 4 years now and i appreciate your hard work. To be quite honest, and please dont take this a complaint because it is not :), but i like the previous way you did swatches on lips and eyeshadows. Because they looked like they do in real life. This is way i find harder to tell what the colours actually look like. I am sure people will have different opinions and of course i understand u cant satisfy them all. Thank you in advanced ๐Ÿ™‚

I (and I think a LOT of people) totally agree that most of these are odd choices to be in this collections. Yeah, where’s Lollipop Loving or Queen’s Sin. I’m also a little surprised to see you mention Ahoy, There! This is one of my MAC faves – it’s the only lipstick that I’ve ever had a backup of, and now I’m on my backup. I didn’t realize anyone else out there felt the same ๐Ÿ™‚

Moxie, Yum Yum, and Rocker. I WOULD WEAR THEM ALL.

I also like this new lighting setup, though I imagine it’s added quite a bit of work to putting these posts together. Thank you so much for all the work you put into these!

We have comments closed on really, really old posts in order to help us answer questions on the newer ones ๐Ÿ™‚

When I heard that Shitaki was being discontinued I snapped up the MAC counter’s last three and I’m soooo glad I did. It’s one of my faves from them, however, on my skin tone (NC50) it reads more like a beautiful mauvey taupe. I absolutely LOVE this.

So, with that being said, I would vote for Rocker (wow!) and/or Eden Rocks. Funny enough, the lipstick photo of Eden Rocks looks more like the Shitaki I own and love! :0)

I love the new photo system! FYI, since I’ve been with Mac long enough to remember the original, Rocker was a velvet finish lipstick, which they don’t have any more. It was a matte base with flecks of glitter in it, sort of a matte/ frost hybrid. I was curious to see how the new one compared to the old, although it doesn’t look like I’ll get to find out, since it was well behind in the voting last time I checked ๐Ÿ™

Glad to see that you were able to get these to review and swatch, to let everyone see what they’re all about.

Good to know! These had no finishes on them (all marked sample), and the press release didn’t use finishes either! I had to go by the information I compiled years ago for past MAC collections, which is mostly accurate, but for some of the older products and launches, less so! Thanks, Kate!

MAC can release 20 lip products in a single collection multiple times during the year, but have something like this, and they can only muster six (three lipglasses/three lipsticks)? Pfft.

3N looks surprisingly nice and non-clingy! Moxie looks nice too!

On a side note, loving your new ‘full face’ pics Christine, you look stunning! Tech Guy is a lucky man!

Rocker and Shitaki are both quite pretty. However, with MAC doing animal testing now our already shaky relationship is pretty much kaput. Love the idea of bringing back old favorites – wish more companies would – but I’m not down with a company who puts out products with decreasing quality while picking up unnecessary animal testing.

Agreed. I’m so saddened and appalled that Estee Lauder would regress to animal testing after not doing it for so long. I won’t be buying anything else from MAC unless they stop.

Christine, do you know if Moxie is a retro matte like Ruby Woo b/c I could had sworn that was the finish of the lipstick, unless they changed the formula?

Because they aren’t Cruelty Free, I don’t buy them anymore! I prefer
The same shades in Lime Crime, Wet n Wild and Jordana ๐Ÿ™‚
They are only lipsticks…

Pretty excited for Moxie! But I really wanted to see Big Bow from the HK collection- I never could think of a dupe. Do you have any, Christine?

Interested in 3N and Eden Rocks!!
Also, I wanted to say that I love the new style of pictures you’re doing, Christine. The color is really sharp, but I also noticed that the lighting seems to flatten the finishes so that they all look kind of matte. Other than that I LOVE the full face pictures…really cute!

Oh I would have LOVED for lollipop lovin’, big bow, or roccoco to come back! Darnit, MAC! I do really hope to see Moxie make a comeback, though.

The lipsticks are cool and everything but I’m LOVING your new swatch system! As a photographer lady I appreciate that you have both flash and more natural lighting and so we get to see the product in both situations, especially since I feel like the natural lighting swatch is a lot closer to how the product would typically *look* to the naked eye ๐Ÿ™‚ cheers!

It’s ridiculous that they’re only bringing back a couple from each category instead of all of them–obviously they’re all in demand so why tease people? Considering the way people are pooping themsleves over candy yum yum, it’s likely going to be candy yum yum and 3n coming back, and people who wanted moxie are still never going to get a chance to try it. Cmon, MAC. Get it right.

posts like these is why i love your blog, christine – sometimes when i’m in a mac store, i get so overwhelmed by the selection of lipsticks that i get a little intimidated, and i like coming here to learn more about particular shades. without temptalia, i would have never known about a color like eden rocks, which is a color i’m just in love with – a nude-brown with just enough pink and shimmer to keep it soft and pretty. i hope eden rocks; much more so, though, thank you for this post!

Christine, your eye makeup is absolutely gorgeous in these! I really like the idea of this collection, and thanks for putting together such a thorough post. I’ve got my eye on Candy Candy Yum Yum and Moxie.

One thing, did you mean to say ‘lipsticks’ instead of ‘lipglasses up for a comeback’ in the intro paragraph?

Christine, may I please have your tube of Moxie? MAC should have never discontinued that colour. That was my first strong pink matte lipstick. I have very nice memories of it. I wish Delish was one of the lipsick options. That’s another gorgeous shade that was dc’d about two years ago. I still have a tube and I wear it sparingly. Shhh was another amazingly gorgeous red shade that was also dc’d. Rocker is great, although the tube you swatched is different from the original Rocker shade. The original had a bit of glitter in it and I don’t remember it being so warm. I wore that shade back in the day. Anyways, enough reminiscing. I look forward to August.

I agree with you Christine. They should have added the lipsticks from the iris apfel collection particularly the pink pigeon and party parrot. They were sold out in a matter of minutes when it was launched!

Top 3
Lips-CYY, Moxie, Rocker
Lipglass-Bait, Cult of Cherry, Flash of Flesh
Eyes-Guacamole, Moth Brown, Jete

Could not be more thrilled with these choices, will for sure be getting bu’s of everything!

Wow! It looks great. I am looking for lipsticks online but i still have to assure what will be it looks. Thanks for the pictures.

PS: You too, is very pretty. All lipsticks you used fitted to your whole appearance.

Wow! It looks great. I am looking for Online shops who sell lipsticks, but i still have to assure what will be it looks when i use it. Thanks for the pictures. It helps me a lot.

PS: You are also pretty. All lipsticks you used fitted to your whole appearance. Very sweet smile. ๐Ÿ™‚

THANKS!

Hi pretty Christine, how different do you think Moxie is from Gesina from the 2010 Marcel Wanders collection? (I don’t want to use up my Gesina without a back-up!) ;p
ย 
Also, you mentioned here it would have been nice if they had Wild ‘Bout You as a contender, I totally agree! I still have a stick and a half and I’m holding on to its dear life! Any recommendations to what’s close to Wild “Bout You?
ย 
Also, I could not thank you enough for all you do and the time you put in.ย  In a way, thanks for holding our (my) hands through all these beautiful options!

ย @AbigailODย Gesina doesn’t look anything like Moxie – did you mean another shade?ย http://www.temptalia.com/mac-marcel-wanders-lipstick-review-photos-swatches
ย 
Gesina is very red!
ย 
Thank you so much! ๐Ÿ™‚

ย @Christine (Temptalia) Thanks! It must be my eyes deceiving me. Looking at it again, Gesina is much, much redder. I miss the original MW lipstick formula. So creamy but different from Amplified and Cremesheen.
ย 
Any thoughts on Wild “Bout You look-alikes?

ย @Christine (Temptalia) I’ve never tried that brand but I’m excited to check it out! Thanks much! More power to you! =)

Voting for Candy yum yum, Rocker and 3N.. ( fingers crossed) I missed candy yum yum last year and gotta have it this year.. Rocker is a perfect color for this fall. 3n doesn’t look soon nude I could pair ir up with emancipation lipglass and have that perfect pink toned nude lip.. I spoke to a Mac represenative who informed me that the collection is due to be released early August. YAY!!!

So funny, Moxie was the first lipstick I ever bought from MAC….and I still have it (the tube is square on top, not bullet shaped, thats how “old” that lipstick is). Iwould love if they brought back the iris apfel collection of lipsticks and the Raquel welsh collection too.

Ordered 2 tubes of candy yum yum yesterday, got an email today notifying me that the order had shipped, went back to MAC this morning and it’s currently sold old! you divas don’t play! lol glad i got my order in, i missed out the first time it was released ๐Ÿ™‚

MAC Eden Rocks Lipstick and MAC Shitaki Lipstick are my favorite!! My lips are soooo dry all the times..I need the lipsticks really really hydrated.

Christine – is this lipstick very hydrated?

Hi Christine, Tina from Malaysia here. I really want some of the products badly and have written to Mac cosmetics Malaysia to see if they are launching it here in Malaysia but there has been no news from them. I’ve written to them twice in the past month. Will you know if it is going to be launched in Asia. I really want Candy YY, Rocker and Moxie! I’m obsessed with it.

I don’t have any more information on By Request’s launch for international other than that it’s September 2012!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! ๐Ÿ™‚ If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!