Friday, March 30th, 2012

MAC Eye Kohl
MAC Eye Kohls

MAC Reel Sexy Eye Kohls

There are four MAC Eye Kohls ($15.00 for 0.048 oz.) in the upcoming Reel Sexy collection debuting on April 5th in-stores. They are: Heirloom (highly metallicized greyed lavender), Hyacinth (mid-tone blue), and Resort (deep amethyst plum), and Smolder (intense black). Smolder is not included, because it’s a permanent shade that’s been long-standing.

  • Heirloom is a lilac-tinted light gray with a silvery sheen. It doesn’t deliver the greatest color payoff, and it doesn’t seem to layer as well as I’d like. I can’t think of a similar shade to this.
  • Hyacinth is a medium-dark muted blue. It’s not a full-on medium blue, but it’s not a navy blue–it’s right in-between–and there’s a softened quality to the color. The color payoff is so-so in a single pass. It doesn’t skip so much as it just doesn’t deposit an even, opaque layer of color. MAC Marine Ultra is more intense. Make Up For Ever #15L is a bit lighter. YSL #03 is a bit darker.
  • Resort is an eggplant purple with red undertones. It has decent pigmentation in a single go, but again, it’s not fully opaque, and it doesn’t seem to get there even with layering. Make Up For Ever #4L is a bit darker, more burgundy. CoverGirl Violet Voltage is a bit darker.

With the amount of eyeliner formulas out there, MAC’s Eye Kohls are not on my list of favorites.  They’re soft but not creamy, so they don’t glide on effortlessly.  Luckily, they’re not dry, so they don’t tug and drag painfully across the lash line, but I can never get a really great, opaque line of color.  Even after going back and forth one or two times, it just doesn’t look right.  It seems to fold over itself and bunch up in places, so it does look nice and even.   What is applied, though, does wear well.  I was able to wear Heirloom for eight hours without any problems–it looked a little faded after ten hours.  Some of the shades in the range are creamier than others, but these just didn’t have enough give.

The Glossover

product

MAC Reel Sexy Eye Kohls Reviews, Photos, Swatches

B-
There are too many better eyeliner formulas on the market (even with MAC's own line) that make these seem like under-performers--especially when it comes to delivering rich color payoff.

Product

8.5/10

Pigmentation

7/10

Texture

8/10

Longevity

9.5/10

Application

3.5/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!

See more photos & swatches!

MAC Eye Kohl
MAC Eye Kohls

MAC Eye Kohl
MAC Eye Kohls: Heirloom, Hyacinth, Resort

MAC Eye Kohl
MAC Heirloom Eye Kohl

MAC Eye Kohl
MAC Hyacinth Eye Kohl

MAC Eye Kohl
MAC Resort Eye Kohl

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase it? How much is it?

MAC, $15 each (launches April 5th in-stores).

Is it limited edition?

Yes.

Any dupes?

See individual shade review! :)

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

9 thoughts on “MAC Reel Sexy Eye Kohls Reviews, Photos, Swatches

  1. Melody

    Hmmm…not really digging these. Good for my wallet!

  2. Avatar of Amy amy

    Resort is so pretty, but I can see the “flaking” in your swatches. Too bad, because otherwise it is such a perfect color. I think I’m going to pass on these.

  3. Allie

    Meh, my list is getting smaller by the minute!

  4. Anne

    Heirloom was a shade stick in Mac me Over wasn’t it!?!?!

  5. “fold over itself and bunch up in places” is a GREAT description of what they do. You can even see it in these swatches. You’re exactly right – I’ve never been a fan of their kohl pencils. They have their good points, but I feel like for the money, there’s better out there.

  6. Margarett

    Going to pass on all three. Nothing that I don’t already have something similar to or better.

  7. Julie Berry

    Thank you so much for reviewing another huge Mac Release. You’re the best!!

  8. kisha

    i got the RESORT liner and it does everything u said :( such a disappointment YET becuz its such a pretty color i use it to line my lips n pair with the Heroine lipstick from the same collection and its a WINNER :)