Friday, February 24th, 2012

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2: Lipglosses

There are four limited edition MAC Lipglosses ($22.50 for 0.15 oz.) in the new Marcel Wanders 2 Collection: Jana (creamy beige with gold pearl), Julia (light blue-pink with pearl), Karin (pink-mauve with pearl), and Kim (dirty plum with pearl). These lipglosses are designed to be “super sheer.”

  • Jana is a sheer pale, golden beige shimmered gloss that yields very little color (possibly, a touch of warmth) and mostly a healthy dose of shimmer. There are a lot of possible dupes. Honestly–the sheer lipgloss gallery is full of them. MAC Mary (from Marcel Wanders 1) is more golden.
  • Julia is a barely-there pink with pink and pale beige-gold shimmer. I have no idea how MAC got “blue-pink” out of this at all, because it’s not really cool-toned and there’s no blue undertones that I can spy. This shade has less shimmer compared to Jana. It looks a bit like MAC Beatrix on (from Marcel Wanders 1).
  • Karin is a plum-mauve with plum and pale pink shimmer. It has a healthy dose of shimmer, but I had some issues getting the shimmer to spread out evenly. MAC Comfort & Joy is rather similar but has more shimmer (less sparkle).
  • Kim is a softened red-berry with soft pink shimmer. It settles a bit into lip lines. The color coverage is semi-sheer here–this is the most pigmented of the four. Bobbi Brown Naked Plum is redder. Dior Mauve Accent is less shimmered. MAC Spanking Rich is similar with less shimmer.

The formula is cushion-y and thick without being goopy. They feel non-sticky when you apply them, so they do move a bit, but it doesn’t seem to gather or crease. Like other MAC lip products, these are vanilla-scented but don’t have any discernible taste. The formula is most comparable to the existing Cremesheen Glass but thicker (not in a bad way). Each tube has a “chrome” cap and a brush-type applicator. On me, these only wear about two hours and definitely need a reapplication after three. I don’t have any issues with my lips feeling dry post-wear, though.

The amount you get in these glosses is comparable to both Dazzleglass and Cremesheen Glass (and the overall style of the tube is also similar to these two glosses), which come in at $19 at present, so the price difference isn’t as startling as it is on the lipsticks.

The Glossover

product

MAC Marcel Wanders 2: Lipglosses Review, Photos, Swatches

B
It's a decent to good gloss overall, though the shorter wear time was frustrating. The sheerer color is expected, though Kim is actually too pigmented given that MAC used the term "super sheer" to describe the color opacity of these!

Product

9/10

Pigmentation

9/10

Texture

9.5/10

Longevity

7/10

Application

4/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!

See more photos & swatches!

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Jana Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Jana Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Jana Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Julia Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Julia Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Julia Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Karin Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Karin Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Karin Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Kim Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Kim Lipgloss

MAC Marcel Wanders 2 Lipgloss
MAC Kim Lipgloss

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase it? How much is it?

MAC Cosmetics, $22.50 each (March 1st).

Is it limited edition?

Yes.

Any dupes?

See individual shade review! :)

What makeup are you wearing?

On eyes: MAC Sweet & Sour Mineralize Eyeshadow Duo (has fall out issues), Burberry Trency Eyeshadow, Tarina Tarantino Spark of Envy Hyper Dream Liner, Hourglass Film Noir Mascara. On cheeks: Tom Ford Love Lust Blush. On lips: varies based on product swatched, so see the label beneath the photo.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

27 thoughts on “MAC Marcel Wanders 2: Lipglosses Review, Photos, Swatches

  1. hannah

    gorgeous colors, but the font used for “marcel wanders” is so ugly! #fontsnob

  2. Ooh Jana is really quite interesting to me! How do you capture the shimmer so well? :)

  3. Dana

    I need another sheer shimmery gloss like a hole in the head. Why do companies keep making new versions of this?

  4. Miss J

    These are so easily passable… It’s nice they don’t look like they’re settling into the lips, but frosty, overpriced gloss…PASS! Thanks for swatches, Christine! Hope you are feeling even better today! Hope the hubby-to-be’s mom enjoys her bday!

    Mellan searching for treats in that box is too cute. Reminds me of my dog getting in people’s purse or lunch bag, lol. If he smells something good, he goes for it!

    Happy Friday, everyone! Have a great weekend!

    • Miss J

      Hahaha, sooo, I know I’m tired when I mesh comments that I meant to put in the post for FFH Friday with this post. Wow, lol. I totally somehow forgot what post I was even on, and then once I posted was like, “WAIT! When did I get on a post about lip gloss?! Why am I still thinking I’m on FFH Friday?!”

      OY.

    • LOL! One time I left food in my purse and Mellan got to it… not a good time!

      • Miss J

        Haha, during the holidays my sister-in-law and brother were over, and she left her purse open on the floor. Once the excitement of people he doesn’t see often wore off, he decided to quietly go rummaging through SIL’s purse. He found something and we started to hear rustles of candy wrappers, we finally noticed him off in the corner with his head buried in the purse. Once we acknowledged what he was doing, he just looked up from inside the purse like “What? I got bored and hungry! I’m not sorry!”

        Funniest thing he’s ate that we found out about…strawberry gloss! He got trapped in my room once somehow, and we were looking everywhere for him. I find him under my bed, and I’m like what the crap, so I pull him out and he had this pink, jelly like substance all over his face. Once I picked him up to see what he got into, I noticed some sparkles then I smelled strawberry. LOL. Dog chewed up a tube of glittery, strawberry gloss! Weirdo.

        Love our little doggy babies. They are so cute and entertaining!

        • I can’t imagine the clean-up involved in getting gloss off of him!! One time, Mellan bumped his head against my face and I had red lipstick on, and he looked like he was bleeding! Thankfully, he’s never eaten anything makeup-related.

    • I feel the same way about these.

  5. Avatar of Mariella Mariella

    I have Spanking Rich and the only thing I dislike about it is the glitter so if this gloss has more shimmer, I’m sure it’s not for me.

  6. Avatar of Jana Jana

    my name is Jana, but Jana lipgloss is so not me…what a shame

  7. Angie

    These colors are pretty, but I’m not sure if they’re worth the price.

  8. Amanda

    They’re all so similar except the last one. I don’t like Kim. Of the other 3, if I bought just one, which one do you recommend to be the best? I don’t need 3 glosses that are all similar. Thank you so much Christine for the swatches!

  9. valerie

    nothing special

  10. soniya

    they all look the same:((

  11. Melody

    I’m a little meh on the glosses. I mean, they’re all solid everyday colors and I think the shimmer is sophisticated, but they aren’t super special. I am liking Karin, but I’m afraid it will just be grey on me because my lips have zero pigment.

  12. Avatar of Naemi Meerschweinchen

    Will there be a review on the Beauty Powders?

    • They’re not beauty powders – they’re just finishing powders that are flesh-colored. I’ve already reviewed Mystery Powders on the blog multiple times :)

  13. Carla25

    Hi christine, whats the green eyeliner called that your wearing? Its lovely :)