The average rating based on all reviewed shade(s) in this formula is shown below.
Our bestselling Smudge Sticks are available in an array of matte and shimmer formulas that stay—not stray—for reliable color payoff that’s second to none. With a range of gorgeous shades to choose from, they feature a cocktail of moisturizing ingredients that ensures color glides on smooth (no tugging or pulling) and the waterproof formula won’t budge or fade. What’s more, our Smudge Sticks can be used as a classic pencil liner or a smudgy eye shadow - simply smudge with your fingers or a brush. The color sets after you’ve had time to get your desired effect, and then stays put all day.
Based on 4 Reviews, 4 Quick Reviews
The Good: Easy To Apply (4), Creamy (3), Smooth (3), Long-wearing (3), Great For Beginners (3), Easy To Sharpen (1)
The In-Between: Highly Pigmented (4), Smudgeable (3)
The Bad: Migrates (2), Too Little Product (2), Smudges (1)
4 Written Reviews
By K. 2 years ago.
I wish I could give this five stars, because it is a wonderfully opaque liner and I haven't been able to dupe the color in almost a year that I've had it. Some of the dupes on this site are close, but not enough.Here is why I can't: the 'smudge' part of 'smudge' stick also means that on my (admittedly deep-set and oily) eyelids, I have an involuntary cut crease on at least one eye by the end of a work day. Also, these are a royal pain in the ass to twist up and you go through them quickly as the product is quite soft. You'll never do a precise wing with it because you can't really sharpen it (or maybe just I can't). You also don't get a TON of product - I snapped mine up during an annual ULTA sale and will probably repurchase at a sale price but am not sure I'd repurchase for full price.That said, it literally is opaque in a swipe. I love red/purple/berry eyeliners but they are frequently lacking in intensity or true color once it's on the lid, and this product does not lack in those areas at all. It still looks great at the end of the day where I put it - it is just also looking great in places I did not want it.
By Elizabeth 2 years ago.
I have oily, hooded lids that cause eyelienr to migrate, so I've tried every eyeliner to find The One. This is it, folks. It's super creamy, blackest black, and long-wearing without migrating. Many people on the blogger circuit state that it's their favorite. It's smudgeable but it doesn't smear. I also like that it's auto-sharpen because pencils tend to break their points. Just a gem!
By Melissa 3 years ago.
absolutely beautiful product. The colour is so unique (seriously no other brand can do this colour right!). I put this on my lids over black liquid liner, and it looks so fantastic in the spring. Lasts on my lids for over 6 hours too! You have to layer it on a tiny bit though (maybe 2-3 swipes). The price is also reasonable...high end but not tom ford priced! haha
By Stephanie 5 years ago.
I saw this in ulta and heard great reviews about it so I picked it up and I'm glad I did. It is very creamy and just a perfect mint green eyeliner. Definitely a summer staple in my makeup collection and it is great if you are a person who likes to do nude eyeshadow looks, you can really add a pop of color to your look.