The average rating based on all reviewed shade(s) in this formula is shown below.
Creamy application makes blending super easy, and the formula dries down for long-lasting wear! Because the liner is so creamy, do not over advance your liner to prevent breakage. For blending and smoky looks, use a pencil brush. Smooth glide for easy and comfortable waterline application.
Look Featuring This Product
Based on 9 Reviews, 19 Quick Reviews
The Good: Great Value (21), Long-wearing (15), Easy To Sharpen (14), Easy To Apply (10), Great For Beginners (9), Creamy (8), Smooth (4)
The In-Between: Highly Pigmented (12), Smudgeable (7), Buildable (2)
The Bad: Hard To Apply (3), Smudges (3), Dry (2), Tugs/pulls (2), Migrates (2), Flakes (1), Bulky (1), Too Little Product (1)
9 Written Reviews
By Hagar 2 years ago.
Probably the makeup item I use most often. Subtle, complementing, and goes with anything. You can smudge it if you want and make an eyeshadow of it that way, but it won't smudge on its own. Ridiculously pigmented - full, opaque cover in one pass. Colour is a rich, warm, medium gold.
By Hagar 2 years ago.
Makes green eyes pop like nothing else - this is a rich, warm, not-quite-matte not-quite-glittery purple. Can be lightly smudged with fingers immediately after application, but after about 5 seconds will stay nice and put even through +30C, ~65% humidity summers. The one problem is the texture, or rather, the consistency. It's smooth enough in application - not as much as the properly metallic shades, but smooth still; it breaks entirely too easily, though, and requires a lighter hand than even my liquid liners! That's a fair bit of a problem; it's the perfect shade for green eyes, but I can't wholly recommend it to anyone who doesn't have serious trust in their hands.
By Leah 3 years ago.
I love how creamy and easy to apply this pencil is, I can use it on my upper lash line without pulling which is amazing! The packaging is a little tinny but for the price and the quality of the product you can't complain. Super black and once it sets I had no transferring or smudging.
By Briana 3 years ago.
I agree what the other person said. I think they made a bad batch of punch because i got the same results. It was crumbly, had to go over alot, not a good consistently, and just bad. I was so excited to get it and was pissed disappointed when i played with it. I already have best o and puppy love and i like them. Punch is a beautiful color but overall its just bad.
By Lindsay 3 years ago.
I purchased Piggy Bank and Prance in my most recent CP haul, and had to try this color out as I love purples. What I was particularly looking for was a purple that was a vegan formula, as most purple shades have carmine in them, and cause my eyes to have an allergic reaction. This color is SUPER pigmented - it reminds me of the lighter purple shade in the Urban Decay Electric palette - it's a bright fuschia-y purple, very creamy, smudgeable and extremely long lasting. This did not migrate from my waterline all day long. When it did come time to remove my eye makeup, this did stain my waterline and upper lash line and the stain was still there the next day - so that's why I am knocking this down one star. Otherwise, great formula - I will definitely be purchasing in the black and brown varieties - and you can't beat the price for this staying power and the fact that you don't have to sharpen the pencils!
By Bea 3 years ago.
I recently purchased two of the colour pop creme gel liners and I am definitely pleased! I have "prance" and "cry baby". Both are highly pigmented and "prance" is much brighter than the picture and the packaging on the website shows. It is a cornflower blue that lasts soooo long. Honestly I should have bought it in a black or a brown too, because the staying power is insane and I would use it in place of my classic eyeliner.