Skip to content
Temptalia Logo

Featured Deals

View All

We earn commission on sales tracked from our links and codes. Thank you for your support! We earn commission from affiliate links/codes. Thank you!

  • Klorane — 25% off w/code STOCKUP, ends 2/06.
  • MAC Cosmetics — 30% off lip products, ends 2/14.
  • Paula's Choice — Up to 27% off customer favorites, ends 2/05.
  • Saks — 15% off next purchase via app w/code APP23SF, ends 2/06.
  • Urban Decay — 30% off favorites, ends 2/14.

Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Dupes

Here are our dupes for Melt Cosmetics Over Critical, which is a moderately warm-toned, medium-dark gold with a metallic finish. It is a limited edition eyeshadow.

Review
= Verified
Gallery Options
Products
Swatches
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
A-
Over Critical
Melt Cosmetics
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
Review
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Fyrinnae Luxury Pressed Eyeshadow
Luxury Fyrinnae
Permanent
A
$7.00
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$7.00
More
Luxury is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Fyrinnae Luxury Pressed Eyeshadow
95%
Luxury
Fyrinnae
$7.00, Permanent
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Charlotte Tilbury The Rebel (2020) #1 Eyeshadow
The Rebel (2020) #1 Charlotte Tilbury
Permanent in Palette
A
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
The Rebel (2020) #1 is... less shimmery (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Charlotte Tilbury The Rebel (2020) #1 Eyeshadow
95%
The Rebel (2020) #1
Charlotte Tilbury
%%COMMA%% Permanent in Palette
  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Makeup by Mario Gold Metal Eyeshadow
Gold Makeup by Mario
Permanent in Palette
A+
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Gold is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Makeup by Mario Gold Metal Eyeshadow
95%
Gold
Makeup by Mario
%%COMMA%% Permanent in Palette
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
A+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Sydney Grace Be the Sunshine Pressed Pigment Shadow
Be the Sunshine Sydney Grace
Permanent in Palette
A
$6.25
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$6.25
More
Be the Sunshine is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sydney Grace Be the Sunshine Pressed Pigment Shadow
95%
Be the Sunshine
Sydney Grace
$6.25, Permanent in Palette
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Natasha Denona Imperia (265M) Metallic Eye Shadow
Imperia (265M) Natasha Denona
Limited Edition
A+
$29.00
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$29.00
More
Imperia (265M) is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Natasha Denona Imperia (265M) Metallic Eye Shadow
95%
Imperia (265M)
Natasha Denona
$29.00, Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
A+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Natasha Denona Gold (137CP) Cream-Powder Eye Shadow
Gold (137CP) Natasha Denona
Limited Edition
B+
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Gold (137CP) is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Natasha Denona Gold (137CP) Cream-Powder Eye Shadow
95%
Gold (137CP)
Natasha Denona
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
ColourPop Karat Cake Pressed Powder Shadow
Karat Cake ColourPop
Permanent
A
$4.50
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$4.50
More
Karat Cake is... less shimmery (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
ColourPop Karat Cake Pressed Powder Shadow
95%
Karat Cake
ColourPop
$4.50, Permanent
  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Givenchy Palette Ors Audacieux #1 Palette Ors Audacieux Eye Shadow
Palette Ors Audacieux #1 Givenchy
Limited Edition
B+
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Palette Ors Audacieux #1 is... less shimmery (1), lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Givenchy Palette Ors Audacieux #1 Palette Ors Audacieux Eye Shadow
95%
Palette Ors Audacieux #1
Givenchy
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
B+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
ColourPop Come Clean Super Shock Shadow
Come Clean ColourPop
Permanent in Palette
A
$6.00
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$6.00
More
Come Clean is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
ColourPop Come Clean Super Shock Shadow
95%
Come Clean
ColourPop
$6.00, Permanent in Palette
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Sydney Grace Fool's Gold Pressed Pigment Shadow
Fool's Gold Sydney Grace
Permanent
A
$6.25
95%
Similar
95%
By Editor
$6.25
More
Fool's Gold is... lighter (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sydney Grace Fool's Gold Pressed Pigment Shadow
95%
Fool's Gold
Sydney Grace
$6.25, Permanent
  • Lighter (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Rare Beauty Gutsy Eyeshadow
Gutsy Rare Beauty
Limited Edition
A
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Gutsy is... lighter (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Rare Beauty Gutsy Eyeshadow
90%
Gutsy
Rare Beauty
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Lighter (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
MAC Very Frisky MAC Girls Eyeshadow
Very Frisky MAC
Limited Edition
A-
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Very Frisky is... lighter (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
MAC Very Frisky MAC Girls Eyeshadow
90%
Very Frisky
MAC
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Lighter (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Sephora Bronze PRO Eyeshadow
Bronze Sephora
Limited Edition
A-
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$0.00
Savings
Bronze is... darker (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sephora Bronze PRO Eyeshadow
90%
Bronze
Sephora
%%COMMA%% Limited Edition
  • Darker (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A-
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Sydney Grace Toffee Crunch Cream Shadow
Toffee Crunch Sydney Grace
Discontinued
A+
$8.00
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$8.00
More
Toffee Crunch is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sydney Grace Toffee Crunch Cream Shadow
90%
Toffee Crunch
Sydney Grace
$8.00, Discontinued
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
A+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
Sydney Grace Worth the Wait Cream Shadow
Worth the Wait Sydney Grace
Discontinued
A+
$8.00
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$8.00
More
Worth the Wait is... darker (1)
View Detailed Comparison
Sydney Grace Worth the Wait Cream Shadow
90%
Worth the Wait
Sydney Grace
$8.00, Discontinued
  • Darker (1)
Editor's Comparison
A+
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Melt Cosmetics Over Critical Eyeshadow
Over Critical Melt Cosmetics
Limited Edition
A-
ColourPop Origami Jelly Much Eyeshadow
Origami ColourPop
Permanent
A
$8.00
90%
Similar
90%
By Editor
$8.00
More
Origami is... lighter (1), warmer (1)
View Detailed Comparison
ColourPop Origami Jelly Much Eyeshadow
90%
Origami
ColourPop
$8.00, Permanent
  • Lighter (1)
  • Warmer (1)
Editor's Comparison
A
Review
Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe
Back to Top