MAC Stylishly Yours: Cream Colour Bases Review, Photos, Swatches

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Cream Colour Bases: Madly Magenta, Movie Star Red, Tickle Me Pink, Virgin Isle

MAC Stylishly Yours: Cream Colour Bases

MAC Cream Colour Bases ($16.50 for 0.12 oz.) are multi-purpose cream-based colors. Stylishly Yours includes two permanent (but PRO) shades: Madly Magenta (vivid pinkish purple) and Virgin Isle (vivid bright coral); and two limited edition shades: Movie Star Red (medium toned blue-red) and Tickle Me Pink (poppy creamy bright pink).

THESE ARE NOT SAFE FOR USE ON THE EYES. Each of these came with a safety insert, and I’m going to retype it in full, because it’s a good reference for other Cream Colour Base shades, too.  (I italicized the four shades from this launch.)

The following shades are not for use in the eye area: Bamboo, Cooled Pink, Devilish Orange, Fabulush, Flaming Fuchsia, Flighty, Fuchsia Perfect, Full Fuchsia, Improper Copper, Madly Magenta, Movie Star Red, Orange Alarm, Pink Shock, Plumed Violet, Premeditated, Reel Red, Rich Coral, Rich Spice, Soft Rose, Tickle Me Pink, Vintage Rose, and Virgin Isle.

The following shades are not for use in the lip area: Brown, Dusk, Fawntastic, Greensmoke, Mid-tone Sepia, Pink, Plumed Violet, Slick, Vintage Rose, and White.

  • Madly Magenta is a cool-toned fuchsia purple with a glossy sheen and nearly opaque color coverage.  This is a permanent shade at PRO stores.  It is similar to Love Forever and Dolce & Gabbana’s Violet.
  • Movie Star Red is a medium-dark pinky-red with opaque color coverage.  This is a limited edition shade.  It is a darker version of Gesina.
  • Tickle Me Pink is a pale pink with opaque color.  It’s a little milky, but it’s not too pale, though it is a rather light pink (and I don’t love it on me personally).  This is a limited edition shade.  It is a cooler, pinker version of Unlimited.  It’s a warmer, pinker version of Viva Glam Gaga and Snob.
  • Virgin Isle is a softened orange with a hint of coral, and it has opaque color coverage.  This is a permanent shade at PRO stores.  It is a lighter version of Vegas Volt.

The good news is that all of these are lip safe, because they all make for lovely lip colors as well as blushers.  Even though they are not safe for the eyes, I will address general Cream Colour Base wear on the eyes:  they will crease if worn alone, but if worn over a good eyeshadow primer or set with powder eyeshadows, they hold up quite well.  CCBs have an emollient texture that’s more gel-like than cream-like.  All four of these are insanely pigmented; you will have no trouble getting good pay off whether you use it as a blusher (go easy!) or as a lip color.

For blush application, I liked the 130 or the 188 for blush.  Just one push of the brush against the product yields plenty of product, so tread softly when applying any of these four as a blusher.  You can always go back for more, but you should not need much!  I like to use a stippling brush to pick up the color then lightly stipple on the apple of the cheek once and move a centimeter or so outwards and stipple again–then blend with small, firm circles.  I like to use my foundation brush (which still has some foundation on it, as I use liquid) to buff gently around the edges of the blush for a finished look.

For lips, I prefer to take a clean metal spatula (MAC recently launched one) to take out some product and then pat on with my finger or you could use a lip brush for more precision.  These shades were surprisingly emollient and comfortable to wear; they didn’t feel dry or tight at all, and they will stain if left on for longer than a few minutes!  You can also pat a little on and then finish with clear gloss or balm for more of a stained lip look.

P.S. — In the full face photo, on eyes, I wore Chilled on Ice as a base, Retrospeck and Caviar Dreams on top with Dark Diversion to line (upper lash line) and I Get No Kick (lower lash line), and then New Hue on lashes.  Cheeks and lips are indicated below the photo (it is the CCB worn both on cheeks and lips).

MAC Stylishly Yours Collection is a limited edition launch (official information and photos here) that is set to launch in-stores on December 26th in North America, January 2011 for international MAC locations. The approximate launch date for online is December 24th.

If you want to know more about how products are evaluated, read out Rating System FAQ! 🙂

  • Product: 28/30
  • Value: 8/10
  • Ease of Use: 4/5
  • Packaging: 4/5

RECOMMENDATION: They work well whether you wear them as a cream blush or on the lips, so if you see yourself using them in those capacities, I definitely think they are worth checking out.

AVAILABILITY: MAC Cosmetics on December 26th (U.S. stores), January 2011 (International)

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Cream Colour Bases: Madly Magenta, Movie Star Red, Tickle Me Pink, Virgin Isle

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Cream Colour Bases: Madly Magenta, Movie Star Red, Tickle Me Pink, Virgin Isle

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Cream Colour Bases: Madly Magenta, Movie Star Red

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Cream Colour Bases: Tickle Me Pink, Virgin Isle

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base (On Cheeks & Lips)

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Madly Magenta Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base (On Cheeks & Lips)

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Movie Star Red Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Tickle Me Pink Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Tickle Me Pink Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Tickle Me Pink Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Tickle Me Pink Cream Colour Base (On Cheeks & Lips)

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Tickle Me Pink Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Tickle Me Pink Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

MAC Cream Colour Bases
MAC Virgin Isle Cream Colour Base

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

About the Reviewer

Reviewer

Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). For more matches, please read our full Foundation FAQ. For more information on our review process, please read our Review FAQ.

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

147 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.

Virgin Isle isn’t as crazy as I thought it would be on the cheeks or lips.

Movie Star red is lovely, but I do have Gesina so…

Christine,
I am interested in getting “Tickle me pink” and using it as a blusher. I find I don’t have any baby pinks or blue based pink blushes in my collection. I’m NC20…Do you think this would be good for that? Or is there some other blush by mac that would be better for a “Baby pink” or “slight blue pink” blush in their permanent line that would be better?

BTW Thanks for all your hard work, getting these brilliant swatches and opinions on the products out to us!

OMG tickle me pink looks AMAZING on you! Im not even kidding. I always thought cool toned pinks looked amazing on you… so you must have a distorted image of yourself becuase they look fabulous on you. Seriously go out with the pink on your cheeks and lips just like that and you will get complimented.

awesome! thanks for the lip swatches! 🙂 my favorite use for ccb’s is altering lip colors. because the texture is so “not there” – they just impart color – they are great for adding to a lipstick (straight onto your lips) to deepen, brighten, lighten or just change the color 🙂 woohoo! 🙂

Christine. I just wanted to thank you so much for all the hard work and effort you put into this. Especially during the releases of these collection. You never let down and your work is absolutely fantastic. Thanks so much again! 😀
~C

These are really pretty on the lips. I love Virgin Isle and Madly Magenta. I dunno if they’re worth it seeing as I’d only use them on my lips, and not very often.

Just a wild guess here but I think it might have to do with the amount of red dye in the product. A lot of people have allergies to even a small amount of it. Most rich dark shades have red dyes I think.

Tickle Me Pink is so pretty, but I already have Viva Glam Gaga so I’m not sure if it’s worth getting it. Magenta is pretty too . It’s a bit disapointing that they are not eye safe!;-(

I like Madly Magenta and Virgin Isle. I could skip them though as we have a Pro store in London. Movie Star Red looks lovely on the lips, I’m a bit unsure about it on my cheeks though, maybe if I went REALLY light with it.

Virgin Isle makes you look so fresh, Christine! It’s great to see how all of these shades suit you in a different way.

These lovelies might be the highlight of this collection! First I was so disappointed these aren’t eye safe but they look so gorgeous on lips and cheeks that I’m about to forgive Mac 😀

IDK.. how bad can they be to your eyes if you can use them on your lips?? We know for a fact we end up eating some of the lip products we use every day so I guess these shouldn’t be too dangerous.

Yup it might be red dye, it would make sense looking at the shades that aren’t eye safe. If you have the package of that cream colour base, could you check if it has FD&C red dye 40 ir C.I. 16035 listed?

I’m glad Mac includes the safety instructions. There’re tons of eyeshadows with red dyes in them with no warnings.

Btw Christine, thank you so much for all the swatches and reviews!

These are pretty! Do they dry down on the cheeks? How many hours of wear did you get? I have oily skin so the staining part is good, but I’m thinking they will migrate on my face.

They aren’t wet or anything on the cheeks once blended out – I get all day wear when I layer over foundation and set with powder (always set my makeup/foundation with powder).

Hey Christine, I went to a MAC Store and inquired about the new collections coming out the day after Christmas. The lady said they they were coming out with a product similar to the CCB’s, but they were supposed to be sheer, almost like a tint? Were they from this collection, or another? I am confused because the swatches of the CCB’s look similar, but they don’t look like the product that she swatched for me. She mentioned that they were a brand-new product that was being launched…any help would be appreciated!

Stylishly Yours and Cham-Pale are the only ones coming out on the 26th. They could be from one of the spring collections, but I don’t know without seeing it.

I think I need them all!!I wasnt interested in tickle me pink until i saw swatches. love them all though! if im buying the powders from the cham-pale collection, do you think i need the ones in this one!?!? thankyou! x

is tickle me pink a repromoted limited edition product? when i searched it on google images, it comes up on looks people did many months ago. also, how would you compared tickle me pink to so sweet, so easy cremeblend blush?

How do you think Virgin Isle compares to Joie-de-Vivre from the Lillyland collection? Do you think they’re different enough that it would be worth owning both?

I didn’t think I would love this launch better than Cham Pale, but I’m obsessing over all everything in this collection. I want to haul all four!!

I’m NC42 in winter, and tickle me pink looked like a natural flush on me. Very pretty :). So I think it depends on the base color on your skin and how it’ll take the pink color (hope this part isn’t too confusing LOL)

thanks for the reviews christine! (for both collections)
love how great everything looks on you…! especially the ccb’s and highlighters. i might try out some of the ccb’s and maybe the fluid line based on your reviews/swatches….oh and maybe a couple of lipsticks too…

Just got Madly Magenta! Can’t wait to try and figure how to use it! P.S.

Christine, how do I use these CCB as a Blush? I have no idea how to put on a cream blush… TIA! 😀

No – it is just a result of temperature changes. Once you wipe it off, they’re gone, and I’ve never seen them reappear as I store my makeup in a room with no humidity or sunlight.

Hi Christine! I was wondering how the finish of ccbs are compared to other cream blushes? I have nars cream blushes and I love that they dry down to a powdery finish…I can’t stand the texture of tarte cheek stains or the nars tints. Are CCBs more powdery, dry finish or kinda wet?=)

WOWZAH!! How hot do ALL of those colours look on you, Christine….just insane!! <3 I particularly like the "Virgin Isle" colour on you and I think that's the colour I'm also sold on getting (my all time fave colours are coral/peaches!!) In your lip photo's they look really comfortable and moisturising, would you say that's the case? Do they tend to start feeling a little dry after a few hours of wear? I don't have a 130 brush but would you say it's a good investment? I have the 188 and I use that for applying foundation, I didn't really want to mix the two of them up!! Can a 130 also be used to apply powder blushers?

Thanks in advance, Christine, you've taken such time and care with your reviews for this collection (and all collections for that matter!!) I hope you manage to have a relaxing Christmas with your family, boy and of course, Mellan!! 🙂 Regards, Michelle xXx

i have the 130 brush and it is amazing for cream colour bases or pot rouges, really dense and sturdy, i think it blends out amazingly, and so multi purpose! you can use it for foundation, cream blush, liquid blush, liquid hihglighter, but as christine said this isnt really one for powder products =(. i also find cream colour bases to be a little drying on the lips if left on but great on the cheeks =D

GORGEOUS! Thanks for doing this!! I was just wondering, how does Virgin Isle compare to Strange Potion lipglass and Bite Of An Apple blush? Also, do you think it would be too intense for my NW20 skintone?

Hey Christine 🙂 thanks so much for these swatches. i was wondering if you could think of any lipstick dupes for tickle me pink or virgin isle? thankyou x

Madly Magenta is far more wearable than I expected it to be, its beautiful. That and Tickle Me Pink are mine! I am NW15/20 and so cool toned that I look like I have frostbite 🙂 so I love me some pinks and purples!

How does Tickle Me Pink cream colour base compare to So Sweet So Easy cremeblend blush (MAC in Lillyland collection)? Are they similar enough that owning one merits skipping the other? Which one do you prefer?

All of these look SO beautiful on you! I can’t wait to pick up both Virgin Isle and Movie Star Red. Thanks for always having the new MAC collections up, swatched, and reviewed. I brought up your website at the MAC counter today – all of them check it out. You’re the greatest and most informative make up blog – especially when it comes to MAC!

Hi Temptalia. I’ve come across your page before and I absolutely love your reviews and up-close swatches. I have a question though…how are you able to get a hold of products before they’ve come out in stores or online?? Just curious…

PRO stores launch collections at least a week early so I buy from there so I can hopefully get swatches up for all of you before it launches nationally.

hi christine, thanks for all these swatches these are amazing!!! im so glad mac have come out with more colours of cream colour bases because i love these things!!!!!! im thinking of picking up tickle me pink and madly magenta but i have a really yellow undertone to my skin (nc37) would the blue undertones of tickle me pink and madly magenta clash against my skin and not look so great???

hi christine,

do you ever use a powder blush over the top of your cream blushes/CCBs to ‘set’ them? if so which colours would you recommend for these?

also want to say that i really love your site – your recommendations are always spot on and have helped me to build up an excellent makeup collection!!

Honestly, with these? They’re SO SO pigmented that I wouldn’t use another blush on top. You could use a little highlight if you wanted to add shimmer, though. 🙂

Thank you!

I was thinking, how long does the cream color bases stay on the lips? Would you say about the same time than an average lipstick?

For a long time, a MAC collection that actually gets me excited 🙂 Love the strong lip -look! And also cheeks are the ones to concentrate for me, so I’m hoping this collection will come to Finland at some point.

Hi, Christine . I was just wondering, I have very pale skin and pink undertones, but I love the Virgin Isle CCB, could I wear it without looking weird for lack of a better word ?

You pull off Madly Magenta SOOOO well! I think you look fabulous in the very BOLD colors. I’m much paler so I picked up Tickle Me Pink… though honestly I don’t know how much use I’ll get out of it cos I’m typically too lazy to deal with cream blushes! I just love blue-pinks though

I went to my MAC store today and the makeup artist checked all of their product information books and resources for these and she said all of the information says “due to the high level of pigmentation, none of the stylishly yours cream color bases are lip or eye safe.” You can only use them on the cheeks. How do we know what information is correct? Have you heard conflict over this?

Thanks!

Hey K,

The information I have listed is typed exactly as it appears on the safety information sheet that came included with each of the Cream Colour Bases.

Just FYI guys, I have NYX cream blush in ‘red cheek’ and while I haven’t seen Movie Star Red in person yet, from pictures it looks like a *perfect* dupe!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!