We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
40 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our
comment policy may be
removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to
participate respectfully.
Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an
off-topic question, or need technical support, please
contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above
for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't
answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but
will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when
a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set
expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up
being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
I do like that winter palette but price=pass. I caved and bought creme conque lipstick. I love it. The colour is perfect and not too foily so it doesn’t add 10 years to my complexion.
YES! Thanks for this! I couldn’t decide between the warm and the cool bc that purple in the cool looked so much more purple to me. I will however wait on your review!
I ordered all of this I’m definitely keeping all the Lip Foils.They are really beautiful but I wish they were more opaque.The Cool 01 Eye and Cheek palette was slightly disappointing to me especially for the price. I personally think the packaging is prettier than what’s inside.I have a Lime Crime Superfoil (Tutu/En Point)that is almost the same exact colors as the pink and purple metallic shades in this palette so I’m returning the Cool 01 for sure.I bought this at Nordstrom and they have a great return policy.I keep going back and forth with the Warm 02 Eye and Cheek palette.Im not sure if I will keep it.The shades are beautiful but the price is extravagant for what the palette contains.As of right now I’m undecided.
Jamie
I ordered the warm palette first and loved it. I went back and ordered the cool. The quality on these is so good! I honestly don’t know which one I like better.
Joannie
Ditto. I ordered both because I couldn’t decide between the two….I’m keeping both.
I passed on the lip colors; I don’t love the look for me personally. I did buy the cool palette and it’s so pretty; I’m interested in the warm, but not going to rush out and get it. I may wait for the next point event at Nordstrom or after the New Year if it’s still available. I’m trying to stay on my no-buy for a while since I truly don’t need anything new.
MichelleChefNYC
Curls up in the corner rocking “I do not need both of those palettes, I do not need both of those palettes, I do not need both of those palettes………”
Squeeze!!! The Lip Foils have some very glam, OTT shimmer! I may *finally* take a dip into the deep end. Aperture and Spanish Flame have my rapt attention for their reviews!
maria
I own and love the Winter Soleil Warm Palette & wasn’t too sure about purchasing the Cool Palette the pink and purple eyeshadow’s appear too shimmery and the blush too bright so I passed. All the lipsticks were an easy pass I don’t like any of them.
Not the biggest fan of the lipsticks at all but let’s see those cheek colours!!
LaMaitresse
I am in love with these two palettes, the quality is superb, packaging beautiful, everything applies and blends like a dream. Great staying power too!
Deborah S.
I really love Sea dragon so will be getting that for sure. I like the cool palette but it is a steep price. If anyone has the cool palette are the glittery shades just glitter bombs?
Heather
Actually no! No fall out what so ever …..I apply with my finger and they look stunning I even wear during the day to pick up kids etc lol ….can’t stop wearing everything blends like a dream…. And lasts all day and I have had some tom ford things I haven’t loved entirely.
Very, very pretty – love that Apeture lipstick. A gorgeous shade and the palettes are beautiful too.
Erika
I like some of the lips, but not the metallic finish. Can’t wait for the dupes!
J
I caved and got both palettes – I got the warm one at Holt’s because I had a gift card and the cool at Sephora with the VIBR discount. I haven’t touched either yet, though somewhat surprisingly I think I like the cool palette better. I am interested to see if you think the colours have significant dupes within the TF line.
I’m loving all of it but Seadragon is really special!
Krissy Mc
Omg Christine…What color is that lipstick you are wearing in the pics???? I LOVE IT!!! I ordered Venus Rising during the Sephora sale and waiting for it to arrive but I also need that lippie you are wearing too!!!!!!
M
Damn, I want all the lipsticks. But I’m a cheap-o, so hopefully there are some affordable dupes 🙂
Oh thanks for the swatches! Have been so curious about this collection. Curious to see how those metallic lipsticks fare, some look on dry side. And the shadows in the warm palette swatch better than in the cool palette, no surprise. Prices are ouchie
Ana Samuel
This is the utterly beautiful, chique and wearable!! Help!!!!
I ordered the Warm palette off Sephora – but UPS has delivered my parcel to someone else!! It’s the first time something like this has happened to me. I’m so distraught. Don’t know what to do. Sephora isn’t replying to my emails.
Has anyone here experienced something like this? Any info on way forward??
Tracey E.
Hi, I had the contents of a package stolen from outside my apt building despite having signature required on all shipments. 1 call to UPS and 2 calls to Bobbi Brown and a second package was sent out.
UPS will have delivery info, which Sephora should have/can access. Recommend you call Sephora customer service for more immediate action (refencing your e-mails). Good luck!!!
Thanks so much for your suggestion – i will do that.
roselyn
call the 1-800 number on sephora and speak to a representative. Or try calling customer service at UPS. Usually they are pretty helpful. That has happened to me a couple of times before but with my local post office – USPS.
Thanks Roselyn. I did fill out a UPS form to initiate investigation, which they have registered but the form had a disclaimer to the effect that they will take it seriously only if the sender – Sephora – initiates the investigation. I guess i need to push Sephora for that! Thanks so much for the suggestion – i will follow up with Sephora!
roselyn
No prob. I think you should try to call your local UPS too to see if they can help – because they can get in touch with the driver who did that route in your area that day. A few weeks back a friend mentioned that in some places UPS is requesting for people to sign for Sephora packages because of theft/misplaced packages… I don’t know how true that is since I’ve never had to sign for my packages. Hopefully the person who they delivered it to returns the package since I think it is illegal to open up someone else’s mail. Take care.
I do hope so too! However, its been 4 days since the delivery took place – i doubt if anyone is coming back with my parcel.
Tracey E.
I absolute adore the TF warm palette and Seadragon lip foil, aided, thankfully, by Sephora’s VIB Rouge sale and eBates. My next purchase will be the Aperture lip foil, hopefully with Sephora’s $25 off $50 discount. The collection is indulgent, make no mistake. If I had only the palette and lipstick under the Christmas tree, I would be over the moon.
Thanks for the swatches across this collection, Christine.
I have been over splurging on products this fall! I love these palettes, but the price– ouch! I am debating trying one of the foil lipsticks, but still feel cheated by the poor performance of TF moisture core lipsticks (summer 2016).
Also, I purchased a similar metal finish lipstick from Dior’s fall collection, and it turned out to be not the most flattering on me. FYI, I am currently hopelessly hooked on Charlotte Tilbury lipsticks!
I had preordered the cool palette and it’s really pretty- but I feel like there’s nothing new in it that I don’t already have from him. And super pinky pink blush- I dunno- not feeling it at all for the dead of winter!
Venus Rising is beautiful, but again- not a shade I do in winter.
I think I just talked myself out of the warm palette and will wait to see if any of the new Lips and Boys interest me. I never like buying new makeup and then feeling like I should wait to wear it.
I like the lipsticks, not so keen on the palettes. Spanish Flame looks gorgeous. I will however try any TF lipstick on before buying as my, so far, only one hardly seem to show up on my lips.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get
behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback,
product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please
contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
I do like that winter palette but price=pass. I caved and bought creme conque lipstick. I love it. The colour is perfect and not too foily so it doesn’t add 10 years to my complexion.
YES! Thanks for this! I couldn’t decide between the warm and the cool bc that purple in the cool looked so much more purple to me. I will however wait on your review!
Spanish Flame caught my attention!
Mine too!!
Me too!
And me!
I ordered all of this I’m definitely keeping all the Lip Foils.They are really beautiful but I wish they were more opaque.The Cool 01 Eye and Cheek palette was slightly disappointing to me especially for the price. I personally think the packaging is prettier than what’s inside.I have a Lime Crime Superfoil (Tutu/En Point)that is almost the same exact colors as the pink and purple metallic shades in this palette so I’m returning the Cool 01 for sure.I bought this at Nordstrom and they have a great return policy.I keep going back and forth with the Warm 02 Eye and Cheek palette.Im not sure if I will keep it.The shades are beautiful but the price is extravagant for what the palette contains.As of right now I’m undecided.
I ordered the warm palette first and loved it. I went back and ordered the cool. The quality on these is so good! I honestly don’t know which one I like better.
Ditto. I ordered both because I couldn’t decide between the two….I’m keeping both.
The colors for both the lips and in the palette are gorgeous! The swatches also look very promising.
I passed on the lip colors; I don’t love the look for me personally. I did buy the cool palette and it’s so pretty; I’m interested in the warm, but not going to rush out and get it. I may wait for the next point event at Nordstrom or after the New Year if it’s still available. I’m trying to stay on my no-buy for a while since I truly don’t need anything new.
Curls up in the corner rocking “I do not need both of those palettes, I do not need both of those palettes, I do not need both of those palettes………”
Squeeze!!! The Lip Foils have some very glam, OTT shimmer! I may *finally* take a dip into the deep end. Aperture and Spanish Flame have my rapt attention for their reviews!
I own and love the Winter Soleil Warm Palette & wasn’t too sure about purchasing the Cool Palette the pink and purple eyeshadow’s appear too shimmery and the blush too bright so I passed. All the lipsticks were an easy pass I don’t like any of them.
Not the biggest fan of the lipsticks at all but let’s see those cheek colours!!
I am in love with these two palettes, the quality is superb, packaging beautiful, everything applies and blends like a dream. Great staying power too!
I really love Sea dragon so will be getting that for sure. I like the cool palette but it is a steep price. If anyone has the cool palette are the glittery shades just glitter bombs?
Actually no! No fall out what so ever …..I apply with my finger and they look stunning I even wear during the day to pick up kids etc lol ….can’t stop wearing everything blends like a dream…. And lasts all day and I have had some tom ford things I haven’t loved entirely.
Very, very pretty – love that Apeture lipstick. A gorgeous shade and the palettes are beautiful too.
I like some of the lips, but not the metallic finish. Can’t wait for the dupes!
I caved and got both palettes – I got the warm one at Holt’s because I had a gift card and the cool at Sephora with the VIBR discount. I haven’t touched either yet, though somewhat surprisingly I think I like the cool palette better. I am interested to see if you think the colours have significant dupes within the TF line.
I’m loving all of it but Seadragon is really special!
Omg Christine…What color is that lipstick you are wearing in the pics???? I LOVE IT!!! I ordered Venus Rising during the Sephora sale and waiting for it to arrive but I also need that lippie you are wearing too!!!!!!
Damn, I want all the lipsticks. But I’m a cheap-o, so hopefully there are some affordable dupes 🙂
A beautiful collection, but the lipsticks, I want every. single. one. Do you hear me Santa?
The lipsticks are so pretty!
Oh thanks for the swatches! Have been so curious about this collection. Curious to see how those metallic lipsticks fare, some look on dry side. And the shadows in the warm palette swatch better than in the cool palette, no surprise. Prices are ouchie
This is the utterly beautiful, chique and wearable!! Help!!!!
That metallic finish on the lipstick really isn’t my cup of tea. I look forward to hearing more about the eyeshadow though.
I ordered the Warm palette off Sephora – but UPS has delivered my parcel to someone else!! It’s the first time something like this has happened to me. I’m so distraught. Don’t know what to do. Sephora isn’t replying to my emails.
Has anyone here experienced something like this? Any info on way forward??
Hi, I had the contents of a package stolen from outside my apt building despite having signature required on all shipments. 1 call to UPS and 2 calls to Bobbi Brown and a second package was sent out.
UPS will have delivery info, which Sephora should have/can access. Recommend you call Sephora customer service for more immediate action (refencing your e-mails). Good luck!!!
Thanks so much for your suggestion – i will do that.
call the 1-800 number on sephora and speak to a representative. Or try calling customer service at UPS. Usually they are pretty helpful. That has happened to me a couple of times before but with my local post office – USPS.
Thanks Roselyn. I did fill out a UPS form to initiate investigation, which they have registered but the form had a disclaimer to the effect that they will take it seriously only if the sender – Sephora – initiates the investigation. I guess i need to push Sephora for that! Thanks so much for the suggestion – i will follow up with Sephora!
No prob. I think you should try to call your local UPS too to see if they can help – because they can get in touch with the driver who did that route in your area that day. A few weeks back a friend mentioned that in some places UPS is requesting for people to sign for Sephora packages because of theft/misplaced packages… I don’t know how true that is since I’ve never had to sign for my packages. Hopefully the person who they delivered it to returns the package since I think it is illegal to open up someone else’s mail. Take care.
I do hope so too! However, its been 4 days since the delivery took place – i doubt if anyone is coming back with my parcel.
I absolute adore the TF warm palette and Seadragon lip foil, aided, thankfully, by Sephora’s VIB Rouge sale and eBates. My next purchase will be the Aperture lip foil, hopefully with Sephora’s $25 off $50 discount. The collection is indulgent, make no mistake. If I had only the palette and lipstick under the Christmas tree, I would be over the moon.
Thanks for the swatches across this collection, Christine.
I have been over splurging on products this fall! I love these palettes, but the price– ouch! I am debating trying one of the foil lipsticks, but still feel cheated by the poor performance of TF moisture core lipsticks (summer 2016).
Also, I purchased a similar metal finish lipstick from Dior’s fall collection, and it turned out to be not the most flattering on me. FYI, I am currently hopelessly hooked on Charlotte Tilbury lipsticks!
I had preordered the cool palette and it’s really pretty- but I feel like there’s nothing new in it that I don’t already have from him. And super pinky pink blush- I dunno- not feeling it at all for the dead of winter!
Venus Rising is beautiful, but again- not a shade I do in winter.
I think I just talked myself out of the warm palette and will wait to see if any of the new Lips and Boys interest me. I never like buying new makeup and then feeling like I should wait to wear it.
I like the lipsticks, not so keen on the palettes. Spanish Flame looks gorgeous. I will however try any TF lipstick on before buying as my, so far, only one hardly seem to show up on my lips.