The average rating based on all reviewed shade(s) in this formula is shown below.
Based on 1 Review, 15 Quick Reviews
The Good: Long-wearing (5), Easy To Apply (2), Creamy (1), Smooth (1), Blendable (1)
The In-Between: Highly Pigmented (8), Buildable (2), Non-sticky (1), Scented (1)
The Bad: Dry (5), Drying (4), Tugs/pulls (3), Hard To Apply (1)
1 Written Reviews
By Holly 5 years ago.
Melt seems to be struggling with color consistency in their lipsticks. My bullet of By Starlight is WAY darker than pictured, deeper than MAC Punk Couture and more blue toned. I was hoping that it would be closer to OCC Rollergirl, my favorite purple lip color.The consistency of this product takes some getting used to. The super matte texture makes for an extremely drying wear, and application is finicky, streaky, and tugs like no other. I also find that though the lipstick is very pigmented it is not opaque on the first swipe, which is disappointing. However, application improves significantly is the lipstick is slightly warmer than room temperature.Overall, this lipstick is ok. It isn't what I though I was buying and it isn't a breeze to apply, but if you like the color you get and are willing to go to the trouble to apply it, it is a good long wearing lipstick.