• NordstromUp to 40% off on new markdowns during the winter sale (shop here), ends 2/23.
  • SaksEarn a Saks gift card up to $700 (including beauty) with code FEBGCSF, ends 2/21.
  • Sephora50% off Benefit Roller Lash mascara (now $12.50), ends 2/19.
  • UltaUp to 50% off select lashes and mascara for National Lash Day (shop here), ends 2/19.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Anastasia Papaya Dupes

Anastasia Papaya Eyeshadow (Limited Edition. $12.00/0.06 oz.) dupes are shown below with comparison swatches (when available). Refine by price to find cheaper dupes or by brand and availability for a product more accessible for you.

95%
Similar

$7.50
Savings

View Dupe Details

In Frequency is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
How similar is In Frequency to Papaya?

95%
Similar

$6.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Peaches is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Cooler (1)
How similar is Peaches to Papaya?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

95%
Similar

$7.50
Savings

View Dupe Details

Sorbet is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
How similar is Sorbet to Papaya?

95%
Similar

$17.00
More

View Dupe Details

Sand Storm (90V) is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Darker (1)
How similar is Sand Storm (90V) to Papaya?

93%
Similar

$7.50
Savings

View Dupe Details

Lola is...

  • Darker (2)
  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Brighter (1)
  • Warmer (1)
How similar is Lola to Papaya?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

90%
Similar

$12.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Tone (223CP) is...

  • More shimmery (1)
  • Cooler (1)
How similar is Tone (223CP) to Papaya?

90%
Similar

$12.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Neon Orange #7 is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
How similar is Neon Orange #7 to Papaya?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

90%
Similar

$12.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Pumpkin Spice is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
How similar is Pumpkin Spice to Papaya?

90%
Similar

$12.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Major Mandarin is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Brighter (1)
  • Warmer (1)
How similar is Major Mandarin to Papaya?

90%
Similar

$5.00
More

View Dupe Details

M720 Apricot is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
  • Cooler (1)
How similar is M720 Apricot to Papaya?

90%
Similar

$7.00
Savings

View Dupe Details

Peach Crush is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Lighter (1)
How similar is Peach Crush to Papaya?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

90%
Similar

$7.50
Savings

View Dupe Details

Thic is...

  • Less shimmery (1)
  • Darker (1)
  • Cooler (1)
How similar is Thic to Papaya?