MAC To the Beach Collection - Eye Kohls & Lip Pencils Review, Photos, Swatches

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Eye & Lip Pencils

MAC To the Beach Collection — Eye Kohls & Lip Pencils Review, Photos, Swatches

To the Beach also sees the introduction of two limited edition lip pencils and one limited edition eye kohl (plus a repromote of a permanent shade).  I liked both of the Eye Kohls, but I found the Lip Pencils to have a bit of a rough texture, even after heavily swatching them to smooth down the point.

  • Rosemary & Thyme is a gilded olive-green with an antique gold sheen. This is a permanent shade, but a gorgeous color to own if you love wearing neutrals, metallics, or greens.
  • Float on By is an aqua sea-blue with a silverish-metallic blue sheen. I love the color, but I feel like if you own the majority of UD’s 24/7 liners, you probably have this already.
  • Life’s a Breeze is a soft medium pink with yellow undertones. It can be difficult to find really awesome lip pencils that suit your natural tone, and I have to say finding a great warmer pink can be more challenging as well.
  • Temperature Rising is a bright, neon orange. This is totally construction cone orange to me.

Edited:  Review for wear added, now that I’ve had several hours to wear these…

The Eye Kohls wear okay, but they’re not immovable.  I don’t, generally, have major issues with eyeliners fading or smudging on me, but I find these fade a bit by hour three.  I think those more prone to smudged eyeliner will find the kohls a little more difficult to work with–unless you set with sealer or powder, then they stay put.  As far as the Lip Pencils go, those were just fine.  They stayed in place, did their job (helping lipstick adhere to your lips, defining lips, etc.).

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Eye & Lip Pencils

MAC To the Beach Collection
Rosemary & Thyme, Float on By, Life’s a Breeze, Temperature Rising

MAC To the Beach Collection
Rosemary & Thyme, Float on By, Life’s a Breeze, Temperature Rising

MAC To the Beach Collection
Rosemary & Thyme, Float on By

MAC To the Beach Collection
Life’s a Breeze, Temperature Rising


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Rawrzellers Avatar

I wonder if I can use the pink and orange as an eyeliner O: Those would be some really nice bright colors to play with around my eyes.

Jen Avatar

i was wondering the same thing, since one of the models in the promo picture seems to be wearing turquoise AND orange eyeliner.. hmm…

rissy Avatar

How’s the lasting power on Float on by? I heard it’s not very good.(uk youtube review)
And… what color from UD would be closest to Float on by?
🙂 also nice work on catching the iridescence on the pencils.

GretalovesMAC Avatar

Christine I was wondering if you could possibly say which products you think will sell out like the first day.. I am trying to gage if I need to make one HUGE purchase or if I can spread them out so I won’t be broke all at once! LOL!

Carrie Avatar

It’s too bad that Temperature Rising is such a neon orange. I thought it would be a pretty, sheer orange and I was planning to get that lip pencil rather than the pink one, which is easier to dupe.

Alannah Avatar

I agree–Float On By looks like every other teal liner already released! I own & love Rosemary & Thyme though… it’s one I use all the time!

Jennifer Avatar

I love Rosemary & Thyme and Float on By, but since my other kohl pencils from MAC smudge way too easily and don’t last very long on my waterline, I’ll probably pass on them :/ It’s too bad, since their gorgeous colors!

starr Avatar

even if the consistency is rough i might have to buy my first mac liner just for the packaging (lol the color is pretty too though).

sass Avatar

I didn’t vote because I only like Rosemary & Time. I will be getting that one. The other pencil is nice, but I have something like that already. The lip pencils I don’t like for me, but I don’t hate this group of products so I’m in the middle.

Christine, I hope you’re still working on that ‘maybe’ button or that ‘it’s ok’ button. *crossin’ fingers*

Lady Betty Avatar

I agree! Float on By is just amazing! The lip pencils are just awesome! Life’s a Breeze pencil would pair nicely with Viva Glam Gaga and Temperature Rising would look gorgeous with MAC’s lipstick in Morange!

baby in a corner Avatar

do you get the brand gosh in the US? they do eyeliners that are very similar to the UD ones and these ones in bright colours! great if you can’t afford MAC! they do slip a little during the day though! i love rosemary and thyme!

baby in a corner Avatar

thanks for your reply, i don’t know how you reply to everyone! its a Danish brand, very colourful, available in europe in pharmacies/drugstores. they do like 20 colours of eyeliners very soft creamy consistency. i use them as eyeshadow too.

Lauren Avatar

Gosh sells in Canada @ Shoppers Drug Mart as well. Float on By is a dupe for one of my Gosh retractable pencils- the name constantly escapes me, but it’s beautiful. I think it might be Blue Lagoon. I digress, but it lasts all day on my waterline. Mink is my other Gosh favourite. They retail for $15.00 Cdn.

Roxanne Avatar

Would Life’s A Breeze fit Viva Glam Gaga well? I’m looking for a lip pencil to use it with but don’t know which one 🙁 (I’d rather have a perm option.) Help!

SB_sweetie Avatar

The eye kohls are beautiful, but MAC’s eye kohls smear all over for me. I am liking the orange lip pencil, though! Very different.

Angela Avatar

I’m all over those eye kohls. I have no self control when it comes to eyeliner. I don’t think the lip pencils do anything for me though. They usually don’t.

Erin Avatar

I LOVE the packaging for this collection’s pencils!! I’ve been trying to figure out which one I should purchase (because I love the detailed design of these pencils), and I think I’m getting Rosemary & Thyme–I’m a neutrals & golds girl through-and-through. I’m so excited to see these pencils in person!

ellie Avatar

I just ordered in synch lip liner from the too fabulous collection. I heard its great with lady gaga. Do you think i should still get life’s a breeze? Also, sorry i’m not quite an eyeliner person just wondering what’s the difference between kohl and ordinary eyeliner. Thanks.

JoElla Avatar

Love the eyeliners! I am forever looking for the most perfect olivey color for my eyes! And Float would really make brown eyes pop!

Beth Avatar

How does Float on By compare to Urban Decay’s pencil in Flipside? Also, if UD pencils tend to slide on me (mostly at the inner corner), should I skip the MAC eye kohls?

Beth Avatar

Thanks, Christine!
I have both Flipside and Deviant, so I’ll probably just stick with those. (I know some people can’t hardly get UD liners off, but I’m constantly cleaning up smudge from my inner corner and, later in the day, at the outer corner. I put up with it because the colors are beautiful.) That just means more money for other items from this line!

Misha Avatar

ok never mind,, i read a comment saying that the lip pencils might not be safe for eyes? so yeah ill just pass on that. but float on by im getting tomorrow!!!
Question tho— the Rosemary & Thyme looks very similar to ‘Black Line’, the Pearlglide Intense Eye Liner. How similar would u say it is? Do they have the same staying and non-smudge power? Cuz my ‘Black Line’ is pretty much the only thing i can use on my bottom that doesnt smudge. Are these kohl pencils similar to the Smolder liners. Bcuz the smolders for me are disastrous! Smudge-wise.
Thanks Christine! =)

Sarah Avatar

Do you think Float on by looks like Makeup forever 12L? I have two pictures next to each other and they look almost identical. What do you think?

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!