Temptalia Logo
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • Bite BeautyEarly access -- 20% off exclusive sets & sale with code TEMPTALIA20BB, ends 12/14.
  • Macy's15% off all beauty purchases with code FRIEND, ends 12/10.
  • Pat McGrath LabsEarly access -- 25% off sitewide with code VIP25, ends 12/11.
  • SephoraRouges, get $25 off $75+ purchases, VIBs get $20 off $75+, BIs get $15 off $75+ with code 2018HOORAY, ends 12/12.

MAC Plumful Lipstick Review, Photos, Swatches

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

Maybe Not Sultry, But Still Pretty

MAC Plumful Lipstick ($14.50 for 0.10 oz.) is a muted medium pink with a touch of plum, which gives it a slightly darker overall appearance. It has a lustre finish, but it delivers a surprising amount of color pay off (semi-opaque). I originally bought this to use in the Sultry Season, but it’s just not vampy and dark and sultry enough for that purpose! However, it is a gorgeous shade of pink without being milky, candy, or bright. I think it’s very wearable for both cooler and warmer skin tones, though it leans slightly cool. I don’t know how I went this long without Plumful in my stash!

Lustre finishes are supposed to be more moisturizing but can be somewhat drying (but Plumful wasn’t), but they’re often on the sheerer side; I’m happy that Plumful isn’t, just because some of the lustre shades barely show up at all. All MAC lipsticks are vanilla-scented but have no discernible taste. I typically get four hours of wear out of MAC lipsticks, with some of the darker shades going as long as five.

See more photos & swatches!

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

MAC Plumful Lipstick
MAC Plumful Lipstick

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

106 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic.

Please do not ask if/when a review will be posted as we cannot review everything and often change priorities from day-to-day. If you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us. Thank you!

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

Hi Christine,

I am a beauty blogger from India. In India beauty blogging has become a rage since 5- 6 months only and I must tell you that we here look up to you a lot..
πŸ™‚

Love this color! It has been on my list forever to check out — but I’m so glad you did it for me! I will definitely be purchasing it πŸ™‚

That was my first thought, too. I pulled out my tube and it is definitely darker. It isn’t just a lip pigmentation thing — the bullet and hand swatch look very different.

I checked three times now to ensure everything looks the way it does in real life, and this is how it looks on me πŸ™ I even remember checking after I took the photos and even when I applied, because I thought it’d be darker.

How interesting! I’m going to check out a fresh tube at MAC and see if they have changed the color because I really like both versions.

hi girls, do you guys have lighter skin tone than Christine? Coz I have some of the lipsticks that Christine has but those colors that look light on her actually look not as light or sometimes even dark on me.

I went to the MAC store today with my tube of Plumful and these pictures on my phone. The MUA thought these pictures looked like Lovelorn. The Plumful was definitely the same as my tube — darker in the tube and in swatches on several of the ladies behind the counter. Plumful fit colorwise between Sweetie and Capricious.

The good news is that it made me try Lovelorn and I loved it.

I’m surprised at how pink this looks on you! However, my lips are very pigmented and when I put this on, I get a lovely plum shade. This is a good lipstick.

Me too! Definitely the closest I’ve yet to come to My Lips But Better… πŸ™‚ I’m super pale, and playing up, and evening out, my quite pigmented lips make it look way more intentional – Snow White pre-apple instead of post. A good thing indeed πŸ˜‰

This is so funny. I’m wearing Plumful today – a new favorite of mine. On me, it’s *definitely* a Sultry Season color. It’s about three shades darker on me than it appears on you in these pictures – I’d definitely call it plum on me, not pink. In fact, even though we have the same hair and skin color, lip colors pretty much always look more intense on me than they do on you (which has its good and bad sides!). It’s really wild how lip colors vary so much from person to person, isn’t it?

Anyway, different or not it’s definitely still one of my favorite lip colors. I never even paid attention to it until I had some empties and, as I usually do with B2M, asked the MUA for a recommendation last month and came home with this. Using it *very* frequently lately!

Do you have lighter or more pigmented lips? Or what’s your natural lip color?

It is definitely amazing (and frustrating!) how lip colors can vary from person to person so much!

The thing is, I really don’t think I do. I think that the “bare lips” shot you use maybe has a little foundation on the lips? Am I crazy? My natural lip color is…about a shade lighter than MAC’s Lightly Ripe lipstick, LOL! That’s the color that comes closest to disappearing on me πŸ˜‰ So they are pretty pink! I don’t know how it works…

Don’t say that! I think your natural lip color is gorgeous! I love naturally pale lips!

But I agree with people over her saying that lipsticks look very different on you. I’ve not been able to figure out what it is, because I have about the same amount of pigmentation to my lips, and I’m about as dark as you (not as warm/yellow toned, though). But all the colors that looks amazing on you, look dark and crazy bright on my lips. So weird.

I’m really jealous of you, though. Seems like you can pull off almost any lipcolor. I really want to wear lipstick, but I have such a hard time finding colors that look good on me.

Hmmm how could I have missed this?! I love it and it looks beautiful on you! I have this obsession with pink lipsticks and lustre is my favorite finish. I’ll have to pick this up next time I’m at a counter. Thanks!

I was going to get this lipstick at the MAC store last weekend but hesitated. I was wondering what you thought about it and here it shows up on your post today! Meant to be. I think this will be a perfect fall color for me that’s not too dark, since my lips are a lot darker than yours. πŸ™‚

I got this color pretty recently and I love it. It is a very pretty lipstick and lustre finishes are great. They don’t make my lips feel dry like mattes and frosts tend to.

Christine, how similar is this to Way To Love lipstick from A Rose Romance collection? That is my HG of lipsticks. I never wear the same lipstick more than two days in a row and I can’t leave Way To Love alone. It’s the perfect MLBB color. I’m almost at tube’s end and need a dupe. Is this similar at all?

It reminds me a bit of Laugh a Lot on you, which was way darker looking on me, so I guess that will be true of this one as well. πŸ™ It looks gorgeous on you though!

Thats so weird, my Plumful doesnt look this pink at all in the tube or swatched on my hand.I cn understand on my lips it being different but woah,this is crazy!

My plumful is darker and less pink in the tube as well. Weird. I got my tube like a year and a half ago, maybe they changed the color? I hope not because it is one of my favorites. Now I am curious, lol, I’m going to check next time I go to Mac.

plumful was my first MAC lipstick and i liked it at first but then i thought it was kind of blah on me but on you it looks so pretty. Well, thats cause everything looks good on you Christine πŸ˜€

I’m so confused!

I bought Plumful last month and it is definitely plum in the tube. My lipstick looks nothing like yours. Your plumful looks pink mine actually looks plummy.

I have very pigmented lips and fair skin and when swatched on bare lips it still leans plum.

Did they change the formula within the last 30 days? :S

I bought mine about 3 months ago. I’ve quadrupled checked, and this is what it looks like! I remember being really surprised when I initially swatched it, because I expected it to be darker.

I have to agree with those who say this color doesn’t look like Plumful! I have a brand new tube that I bought from MAC Pro about four weeks ago, and it is indeed darker, more plum/berry than pink. Did you apply very lightly?

I got this as a x-mas gift last year and still love it! I didn’t think this would look nice on me but luckily it did. I just bought the Chanel Stunt Allure Laque and it’s quite almost the same color.

this is one of my fav lipsticks (if not my #1) it’s what I wear when I’m in a hurry and don’t know which color to choose. What I love about it is when I wear it it is more plumy while when my friend wears it it comes more as a pink, it’s one of those colors that you think is so blah but you’ll LOVE once you try it on and goes perfectly with every skintone. I’ve made all my friends try/get it and they love it.

Maybe its one of those bizarre colors that looks really different on different people, like Chanel’s Rouge Coco Mademoiselle! It looks so orange on some people, even with similar skin tones to me.. or even leans coral, but on me it looks pure dusty beige.

I bought this to wear in my friend’s wedding and it’s one of my favorite MAC lipsticks. I wish it was a little more moisturizing but I love the color on my pale skin πŸ™‚

Hi! Christine I just bought the lipstick at the Mac store near my house and this shade is gorgeous on you and pretty on me too but look totally different. Even in the tube! weird on my lips it’s a medium plum (darker than yours) and with no blue undertones. Anyway thanks for the review. Bye

Lol don’t worry it’s still a pretty shade and I have no regrets maybe next time I’ll buy sweetie to have a more light pink. It would be nice if I could see sweetie on your lips also. lol sometimes I’m like I wish Christine had all the lipstick I want so I could see the swatches.lol

awww! Thank you so much for the link you are so sweet to take the time to show me what sweetie looks like (it’s gorgeous I’ll get it tomorow). Thank you so much have a nice day. (or night lol) Bye

Hi Christine so I just bought sweetie lipstick and it’s gorgeous!! It matches almost perfectly my lower lip which is great! Also it’s great for everyday use! Thank you so much I am obsessed with lustres right now! bye

that is such a pretty colour! normally i would steer away from the light pink tones, but from the previous comments it seems to look different on everyone so i might just have to check it out…maybe the sheerness will help? the wishlist of lipsticks is just ever growing!

ive been reading some of these comments and i have a medium dark skintone and plumful looks not even close to pink on me. its a very true berry. how funny this is hahah πŸ™‚

When I saw your swatch I just loved how Plumful looked on you so I went to MAC and bought one. However, the lipstick color is much darker in the tube and on my lips. It definitely looks much nicer on you! πŸ˜‰

christine, I went to MAC to try on this beautiful color. Like everyone said, it definitely does not look like the color you have on in your pictures. It looks like a more berry color on me, as did the swatch. Even the color in the tube is quite darker.

I tried on the lipstick from a MAC tester (after it was cleaned of course!) and it was much darker than this. I know this can be inconvenient for you, but is there a way you can swatch this from an actual tester and compare it to the one you have?

I’ll be buying another one next time I go to the MAC store, but mine says Plumful and I’ve tried it FIVE freaking times already and it looks exactly the same as in these photos. Nothing I can do at this point πŸ™

gorgeous shade! picked it up yesterday and it looks the same on me as it does on you, christine (and we have the same skin tone). I love how pigmented it is despite it being a lustre finish. very silky and moisturizing!

I bought this lipstick after reading this review and even though it was freakishly dark in person, it looks exactly as your pic when i put it on my lips and saw photos from events i attended. basically, im trying to THANK YOU because i love this color and it doesnt look too harsh after all =)

I actually went to a MAC counter to try this based on your review, and although my natural lip color is fairly dark, I *loved* it and ended up buying a tube! It’s a really happy medium for those who may have had bad luck with pink lipsticks in the past (that would be me, lol), but want to try a lighter shade for early spring!

Hi, I just got Plumful today too, and oh my god I love it! I admit, the shade is darker, but I’m really fair, so it might just be that. But I love it nonetheless. I’m considering buying Sweetie now, since you’ve been recommending it. Thanks a lot for all your reviews and hard-work, and please keep at it! I don’t have a lot of makeup, so I spend a lot of time picking things from your blog so I can go buy stuff and finally have a makeup kit of my own, so I stop stealing from my mom. πŸ˜› I haven’t been disappointed!

I know this is old but I must put my two cents in I’ve recently ordered & have received plumful from maconline.com & my gosh how different my tube look from your lip swatches & the actual tube pic itself yours look so creamy pink….I must say that somewhere along the productional line @ mac….different variations of colors were spit out…thanx for all the great work that you do on this site!!!

Hello Temptalia! I’m NC20 in mac and I really want a pink-purple lipstick for fall. Would you recommend Plumful or Craving? Or something else? Thank you for your time. πŸ™‚

LOL i like whoever asked you to swatch a store tester(with government officials present to notarize that you did, in fact, swatch plumful)…different color-payoff for different lips is what it all comes down to–and it looks freaking amazing on you, cheers to that.

christine pls help. i’m looking for a muted pink lipstick (neutral) for indian skin. any top recommendations? i’m tired of finding something too shocking pink or too pale pink. i just want to slowly venture into pinks since i do everyyyyything nudes w/lipstick.

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!