MAC Hey, Sailor Eyeshadows Review, Photos, Swatches


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow

MAC Hey, Sailor: Eyeshadows

MAC Hey, Sailor Eyeshadows ($16.00 for 0.05 oz.) includes five shades: Barefoot (tarnished gold), Crystal Avalanche (white with reflects), Feeling Fresh (bright green), Jaunty (light yellow beige), and Nautical Navy (blue).

  • Barefoot is a dirty warm gold with hints of bronze. This has a veluxe pearl finish. The texture was soft but it wasn’t fully opaque–there’s some sheerness in it. The color has a lot of warmth and some orange in it, so it doesn’t look like your traditional yellow gold. It’s not quite subdued enough or brown enough to be the average antique/tarnished gold. OCC Acacia is lighter. Bare Escentuals Remix is a bit lighter and yellower. MAC Goldmine is yellower and lighter. Inglot #404 is darker and more bronze. Milani Drenched in Gold is a little lighter, less orange.
  • Crystal Avalanche is a highly frosted bright white. This is part of the permanent range, and it has a veluxe pearl finish. It had the best color payoff of the five shades in the launch. It can be an interesting shade to use, because of both its brightness and the frostiness of its finish, so using a light touch with it may be best. Maybelline Too Cool is a bit cooler-toned. theBalm Sassy is a bit more frosted. Bare Escentuals Cheers is very close. Inglot #453 is more metallic.
  • Feeling Fresh is a grassy green with yellow undertones and a silver sparkle. It felt more like a velvet finish to me, but it is a frost. The color payoff is pretty disappointing when swatched, and it has a dry texture that skips and doesn’t bind together well. I wasn’t able to get it to apply well over bare lids, but over a primer and packed on with the 213, I was able to achieve true-to-pan vibrancy. It’s much yellower compared to MAC Jealousy Wakes. OCC Foxfire is lighter, yellower. MAC Fresh Flare is a bit darker. MAC Wondergrass is much yellower and brighter. Inglot #384 is darker, yellower.
  • Jaunty is a warm, light-medium beige with a slightly metallic sheen. This has a frost finish. The color payoff is so-so, but I imagine most people who gravitate towards this shade will like some of that underlying transparency. Buxom Collie is a bit darker. NARS Ramatuelle is lighter.
  • Nautical Navy is a dark navy blue with soft blue and silver shimmer. This has a satin finish. The texture is very, very dry, stiff, and chalky. It skips on the skin, and it still continued to behave poorly when I applied it to the lid both over a primer and over bare lids. MAC Naval Blue is similar but more intense, a little brighter/bluer. MAC Lunar is very comparable. MAC Shop & Drop is also very similar. There’s really no shortage of navy blues on the market, all with varying degrees of quality, but the majority are better than this one.

I think people will like these shades, but I don’t think they’re the best in regards to quality.  Barefoot, Crystal Avalanche, and Jaunty are the best out of the five, while Nautical Navy is by far the worst.  Feeling Fresh isn’t superb, but if you use it over a primer, it’s much, much better, which I suspect is how many readers use their eyeshadows, so it’s not lots and lots of extra effort. Nautical Navy is extremely dry and stiff, which makes blending difficult and getting intense color nearly impossible.

With an eyeshadow primer, I had no wear problems with these eyeshadows, and I’ve worn all five (three on one day, five the next). There was no creasing or fading after eight hours of wear over a primer.  MAC does indicate these are long-wearing, so I also tested them without a primer, and there’s very slight creasing after eight hours and some fading.

MAC Hey, Sailor Eyeshadows Review, Photos, Swatches

B-
8
Product
8
Pigmentation
8
Texture
8.5
Longevity
4
Application
81%
Total
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow


MAC Barefoot Eyeshadow


MAC Crystal Avalanche Eyeshadow


MAC Crystal Avalanche Eyeshadow


MAC Crystal Avalanche Eyeshadow


MAC Crystal Avalanche Eyeshadow


MAC Crystal Avalanche Eyeshadow


MAC Crystal Avalanche Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh Eyeshadow


MAC Jaunty Eyeshadow


MAC Jaunty Eyeshadow


MAC Jaunty Eyeshadow


MAC Jaunty Eyeshadow


MAC Jaunty Eyeshadow


MAC Jaunty Eyeshadow


MAC Nautical Navy Eyeshadow


MAC Nautical Navy Eyeshadow


MAC Nautical Navy Eyeshadow


MAC Nautical Navy Eyeshadow


MAC Nautical Navy Eyeshadow


MAC Nautical Navy Eyeshadow


MAC Feeling Fresh on lower two-thirds of lid, Barefoot in crease,
Jaunty on brow bone, Blue Stripe on lash line


MAC Crystal Avalanche on inner corner, Barefoot on middle of lid,
Feeling Fresh on outer third of lid, Nautical Navy in crease, Jaunty on
brow bone, Handforged on lash line

* Barefoot, Feeling Fresh, and Jaunty were provided as press samples. I purchased Crystal Avalanche and Nautical Navy.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

About the Reviewer

Reviewer

Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). For more matches, please read our full Foundation FAQ. For more information on our review process, please read our Review FAQ.

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

54 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.

 @Ani_BEE I completely agree,  I love navy eyeshadow and have purchased many duds Nars, Bobbie Brown, etc..  In my opinion, MUFE #60..  the best I’ve found so far 🙂  I’m NC 25-30ish and it’s really brings out my dark khaki/coppery eyes.

If paying extra for packaging wasn’t enough, MAC could at least made the formulas better quality. The payoff to most of those shadows are lousy.

I wish I had brown eyes to pull off those colors like you! This collection is kinda disappointing. Either the colors are boring and dupable with other brands, Colors MAC has put out a lot lately…
 
This whole collection is very basic, compared to past summer collections. If I had money to burn, I might buy one or two items, but I’d rather save for something more unique.

Wow, Nautical Navy reminds me of my first Maybelline blue palette when I was just starting with makeup as a teenager. 

Wow, from what you have reviewed.. this whole collection is a huge disappointment.  I’m so glad I go to your site before I think about purchasing something.

How disappointing! I had high hopes for both Barefoot and Feeling Fresh. But if I’m going to purchase a gold eyeshadow I want it to be as pigmented as possible. I really like the way Feeling Fresh looked on your lids Christine, but would you say I’m better off with Fresh Flare?

If you use it over a primer, it’s not a big deal. Fresh Flare is not quite as vibrant when you can get Feeling Fresh opaque. Like I’m partially annoyed that it absolutely requires a primer and a fair amount of product packed on, but I’m drawn to the color personally so I’d put up with it.

 @Christine (Temptalia) Thanks! I was hoping you’d say it wouldn’t be worth it to get Feeling Fresh. But I’m kind of glad you did, I love the color! I almost always use a primer and I don’t mind packing it on, so I guess I might as well get it. Thanks again, seriously, I don’t know if you know how much us makeup lovers appreciate everything you do!

LOL at Nautical Navy! Doesn’t MAC have any quality control?
 
Jaunty looks nice, though, but I already have about 40 beige/highlight shadows already, so I doubt that I need this one.

Wow, well I was hoping the Navy would be much better then that. I guess it’s just Barefoot and Jaunty! I have Lunar and Shop and Drop so I’ll skip this one.

Maybe the samples you got were not so good. I got 3 of these yesterday and all of mine are very nicely pigmented. I didnt find them dry or stiff or chalky at all. My Nautical (wearing all 3 of them right now actually) is very dark and pigmented…opaque… same with Barefoot.

 @liesierre Nautical Navy is one I purchased! Only one press sample I received (out of all the products from this launch) was labeled sample, so the rest were from the larger runs of the product, so they shouldn’t differ, as they’re in regular retail packaging!

 @Christine (Temptalia)  @liesierre thats seriously really strange. I ordered with overnight shipping so I got mine yesterday. I had no problem with the pigmentation or texture of Nautical, Barefoot and Crystal Avalanche. The Nautical came out dark and opaque immediately for me (no primer, just swatched with my finger on the back of my hand)…. I also wore it today in my crease and it came out really dark and not patchy at all. I would show you a picture if I could but I dont think thats possible here, lol. 

Jaunty looks so nice IN THE PAN  but it looks like almost nothing applied.  The blue and the green shades both look so patchy.  This is what so many of us complain about – why MAC feels the need to release so many collections when the items in them are so sub-standard. It really does cheapen the brand’s reputation, IMO.

I’m disappointed that the navy shadow is so poorly formulated.  What’s with MAC nowadays, so many of the new colors have such lousy staying power or bad application.  Very disappointing esp. with newer lines like Tarina Tarantino having such nice colors and butter-smooth application.  MAC seems to be more concerned with promoting new lines with cute packaging or celebrity endorsement than the actual cosmetic itself.  Thanks Christine for doing the research and keeping us informed!!!!

The pigmentation doesn’t look good at all. I loved the idea behind this collection and the packaging is adorable, but after seeing swatches and reviews, I don’t even want to spend my money on these products anymore. 🙁

I honestly just find it insulting that MAC has been releasing some incredibly poor-quality shadows in recent launches, and it particularly stings at the higher price point.  It just makes me feel like they assume their fan base will buy their products just because they say “MAC” on them and don’t feel the need to actually put effort into making sure their formulations are good quality.  It also bugs me that they’ve been shoving collections through the door left and right without doing any kind of packaging variation, and now they’re charging extra for the rare occasions when they bother to change up the packaging a bit.  So now they’re expecting us to reward them for putting less effort into their launches?  Thppt.

Feeling Fresh is the only eyeshadow I purchased from this collection. I swatched it in store and the payoff was superb. Mine isn’t chalky at all. Looks like there is a quality control issue, because these eyeshadows have been getting inconsistent reviews.

I’m still torn on Feeling Fresh! I love the color of it and I do wear primer every day anyway, but I suppose on principle I’m a bit put off by the description of the formula. Thanks for the review, Christine!

Well, the only product I was interested in this collection was the navy eyeshadow and I actually guffawed when I saw the swatch.. Ick!  (I will stick with my beloved MUFE #60)  I also ove the Feeling Fresh colour, but I’m going to stick to Illamasqua for beautiful greens.  Thanks so much for the detailed reviews, Christine, this collection is definitely a bust for me.

MAC seems to be having quality issues. I have better looking Wet N’ Wild eyeshadow. It is weird that these cheaper brands are tacking on a dollar or two and raising their quality so much and MAC is raising prices and seem to be having worse quality (except lipsticks). I’ve been disappointed in their collections lately.

I bought Barefoot because I LOVE golds, and I don’t have a tarnished looking gold. My favorite will always be Urban Decay’s Honey, but that’s for another day. ;]

so sad…i was hoping that barefoot was going to be similar to my beloved warming trend…MAC has been so crappy in the last few years of collections. WTF. ugh.

the blue and green shadows look close to the colors in the wet n wild pride palette. the shadows in the wet n wild palette look better than those!

How does Feeling Fresh compare to Sassy Grass? Would you say more blue in Feeling Fresh and way sheerer than Sassy Grass? Thanks, in advance!

Hi Christine, I love your blog. Is Jaunty similar to
Pro Longwear Sweet Satisfaction? How does Barefoot compare to
Amber Lights, one of my favorite MAC shadows?

Hi Christine!
 
I’m surprised by your result with Nautical Navy – I agree completely that when swatched – it’s terrible.  I ordered it online though and when I applied it was very, very pigmented to the point of having to tap off the brush!
 
Saying that – I bought all 5 shadows and haven’t had any issues with swatches or using them.  Maybe the UK got a different batch, I’m unsure.  Shame you haven’t had good luck with them.  🙁

 @Christine (Temptalia) It really is such a shame you had such issues with it – the batch I have is absolutely beautiful pigmentation for all of them.  🙁

Christine! Thank you for your posts and honest reviews. Are you going to do a overall round up and recommendation post? I miss that!

 @alej1234 Apply Jaunty on the lid and then put Naked Lunch in the outer and inner 3rd if the eye. It’s a beautiful combination <3 

I was just searching for Jaunty at Nordstroms online and i couldn’t find it D:. All the other eye shadows are there though. Odd.

I just wanted to say I really appreciate when you mention similar dupes, including how they differenciate. It really “adds value” to the review and swatches. TY! 

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!