MAC Dare to Wear: Eyeshadows Review, Photos, Swatches (Part 2)

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear: Eyeshadows, Part 2

First, make sure you’ve read Part 1. In this post, you’ll notice four blue-based shades–this collection is definitely skewed towards blue. There are three permanent shades here: Sky Blue, Atlantic Blue, and Winkle; the first available only at PRO, the latter two at all freestanding stores.

  • Zingy is a medium blue that leans just a little green. It’s a less intense version of Electric Eel eyeshadow. It was also a little fussy to get to layer right in a swatch–though it’s pretty once it comes together.
  • Sky Blue is a soft, pale sky blue with silvery-white shimmer in a frost finish. It’s a little on the sheer side and can be a bit dusty. This is a permanent PRO shade.
  • Atlantic Blue is an intense shade of deep blue with a violet undertone in a matte finish. This is one of my favorite shades–period! This is a permanent PRO shade.
  • Winkle is a softened cornflower blue with a satin finish. It needs to be layered to get a nice level of intensity, but it has a very buttery texture. This is a permanent shade.
  • Shock-a-holic is a medium-dark purple with strong red undertones in a matte finish. It’s a little brighter, richer version of Vibrant Grape; brighter/purpler version of Nocturnelle or Fig 1.
  • Crazy Cool is a shimmery cool-toned lilac with a silver-white sheen in a veluxe pearl finish. It’s a darker version of Digit and a lighter version of Beautiful Iris. It’s a little on the sheer side and not as smooth as I’d expect for a veluxe pearl.

Temptalia’s Recommendations

  • Must-Haves:Β  Atlantic Blue, Winkle
  • Nice-to-Haves: Zingy, Sky Blue, Shock-a-holic
  • Skip: Crazy Cool

Recommendations by Skin Tone

  • Light: Zingy, Sky Blue, Winkle, Shock-a-holic, Crazy Cool
  • Medium: Zingy, Atlantic Blue, Winkle, Shock-a-holic
  • Dark: Zingy, Atlantic Blue, Winkle, Shock-a-holic, Crazy Cool

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadows

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Zingy Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Zingy Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Zingy Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Sky Blue Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Sky Blue Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Sky Blue Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Atlantic Blue Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Atlantic Blue Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Atlantic Blue Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Winkle Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Winkle Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Winkle Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Shock-a-holic Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Shock-a-holic Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Shock-a-holic Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Crazy Cool Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Crazy Cool Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Crazy Cool Eyeshadow

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Eyeshadow: Zingy, Sky Blue, Atlantic Blue, Winkle, Shock-a-holic, Crazy Cool

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Eyeshadow: Zingy, Sky Blue, Atlantic Blue

MAC Dare to Wear Eyeshadow
MAC Eyeshadow: Winkle, Shock-a-holic, Crazy Cool

About the Reviewer

Reviewer

Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). For more matches, please read our full Foundation FAQ. For more information on our review process, please read our Review FAQ.

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

124 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

So pretty I like Crazy Cool a lot! <3 Can somebody answer a question I have? I want to know if these are in MAC stores? And if they are how long will they be available? Thanks so much <3

They launch in-store on Thursday. I don’t know how long it will be available for – probably a month or more, but certain shades may sell out faster than others.

Thank you!!! I’m taking a shopping trip at the end of August and I’m picking up some MAC items and I want Sassy Grass. πŸ™‚

Christine,
Do you find Shock-a-holic easier to work with than Vibrant Grape? I have a really hard time getting a good pay off on that one and I am putting it up for sale cause it doesn’t work for me.
Liking the colour maybe Shock-a-holic will be better?

I really like the slight green tinge to Zingy! I think I might end up with Going Bananas and Zingy even though I keep trying to talk myself out of Zingy! I really want Shock-a-holic, but I think I might get Sugarpill’s Poison Plum instead since it seems like Shock-a-holic might be harder to work with.

How does Zingy compare to Urban Decay’s Dashiki? And how does Shock-a-holic compare to Psychedelic Sister? Obviously the finishes are different, but I’m wondering how similar the colors themselves are. (Trying to talk myself out of things!) Also, what are the textures of these mattes like? I have trouble with lots of MAC’s mattes, so I’m hesitant to pick a lot of this collection up.

I have green eyes (well one is blue-green but shhhh) NC20 and dark brown hair…Not sure I could wear blues or greens from this collection. I like “Shock-a-holic” though. I’m just thinking “do I need it”? I have “Vibrant grape” Nocturnelle” “Beautiful Iris” and “Stars and rockets.” I barely wear colors on my eyes…But I love purple.

What do you think?

I think if you barely wear colors and already have those four – I think you could skip it without regretting it, but if you really want it, and it’s not out of your budget, it’s not a bad choice πŸ™‚

The blues are so pretty! even though i don’t wear blue eyeshadows, i’m tempted just to get one because my favorite color is blue! zingy looks so bold and bright πŸ™‚

Christine — did you like the texture of Crazy Cool? It is a Veluxe Pearl, but I don’t think it lives up to the normal quality. I have it on hold, and may skip. Thanks!

It’s not as buttery as the usual VPs. I thought it was a frost at first, actually! It’s not bad by any means, though!

I really need to get Sky Blue and Crazy Cool, though I am really not sure how to wear these. Christine, would you be willing to do a tutorial or two with some of these eyeshadows?

I’m sure I will do some once I have a chance to play around with them some πŸ™‚ They just arrived this afternoon, so I haven’t had much time to use them yet!

I was wondering if you thought that Zingy was anything like Electric Eel. (i could be way off haha but i was wondering your opinion) and i was also wondering what about Crazy cool you don’t really care for. Thank you so much!

I’m sorry i just realized that you said it was a little less intense version of Electric Eel! Which one would you recommend formula wise?

Hey,

I don’t know if you meant to say winkle is a matte finish, but its actually a Satin.

Thanks for you review too, made me realize I don’t “need” crazy cool as much as I may want it.

Do you know how Crazy Cool compares the mineralize duo from last christmas? I think it was called devil-may-care and had lavender/silver.

I have Sky Blue and Atlantic Blue and honestly……..they’re not working for me.

Atlantic Blue – I know you love it and try to love it as well but it’s just not working out well. Not a lot goes on the brush and it’s hard to blend it out – still trying to make it work though.

Sky Blue – grr…I love blues but when I put this in a look, I never like how the colour turns out (whitish-silver with a TiNy hint of blue) and I just end up mixing with the medium colour. >_>

I was wondering why you chose Crazy Cool as the “Skip” item. Is the quality lacking? It’s the only colour that appeals to me, lol.

It’s very similar to two existing, permanent shades that MAC has, and it’s not quite as smooth as I’d expect from a veluxe pearl. It’s not bad – it’s just skippable.

Do you know how Crazy Cool compares to Devil-May-Care (from last Christmas)…sorry if I already asked this…I double checked the shade and that’s what it’s called.

Hey Christine, another comparison if you don’t mind. How does Shock-a-holic compare to Sugarpill’s Poison Plum? And if you had to decide between the two which would you choose. Thanks for your time. πŸ™‚

off topic but i brought a mac 189 brush from mac today and i noticed that my brush didnt have a location stamped into it..like france or japan…is this unusual? does your 189 have a location stamp?

hey chrisitne! what was that really helpful tip one of the commenters had about MACs manufacturing dates? those A69 numbers and all. i completely forgot.

The letter indicates the batch number (A = first, B = second), while the second number/letter indicates the month (1-9 = January through September; A = October, B = November, C = December), and the last number is the year it was made.

Hey Christine. Your site has become a daily necessity for me and a must read before purchasing.
Just wanted to say that I think it is SO AWESOME that you respond to every question. I actually started reading the comments regularly because your responses actually make it feel like a discussion section!
Also, I wanted to say that I think “Free to Be” is practically an exact dupe of “Perky” from Spring Forecast. Any thoughts on this? Am I crazy? I haven’t heard anyone make that comparison.
xoxo
*SC*

Aww! Thank you! πŸ™‚

Perky is pinker, I’d say, and the texture is a bit different. Free to Be definitely has this coral tone to it.

The point of the collection is to be bright, though – so if it’s not your thing… doesn’t make the rest inherently bad, IMO. Different strokes for different folks!

Looooove these shades. I’m so bummed that this eyeshadow is only available in our Pro MAC store in Amsterdam. I live far away so now I can’t get Shock-o-holic πŸ™

Yes – I just received these yesterday afternoon, so I haven’t had much time to do anything but review them, but I certainly plan to do a few looks with them. I have also used many of these shades in the past, since they are permanent.

Hey Christine thanks for the swatches really appreciate it, was just wondering if you would be able to do some looks using some of these shades for a little inspiration???

Wow. A collection of bold shades many leaning towards blue – sign me up! I’ve only had mild, if any, reaction to Mac collections but this one actually has me wanting to go to Mac (it has been at least 8 years since I bought any Mac).

What a fun collection! I loved the colours but would hardly touch them so I only got Crazy Cool with B2M πŸ™‚ It was different enough from the MAC perm. shades to get… for me at least. But I’m a sucker for purples. Shock was chalky πŸ™

Thanks for the swatches, Christine!

I noticed you said that some of the colours require some packing on; I was just wondering which M.A.C. brush is the best for this??? As at the moment I’m using a non branded brush which just doesn’t cut it with matte colours such as chrome yellow etc. Would defiantly appreciate the help as I am looking to purchase some of these colours and so will be needing a decent brush to work with.

Thanks for the swatches Christine! I got Zingy, Sky Blue, and Atlantic Blue today (also got others but they’re not related to today’s DTW). The Atlantic Blue was purchased on your recommendation alone. It’s really not a color I would normally choose for myself because it’s so dark and matte. I haven’t tried it out yet. As of right now I can only think of wearing it in the crease. What’s your favorite way to use it?

I hope you love it! I wear it in the crease or outer corner/lid area most often (just ’cause it’s dark!) — LOVE it with aquas, teals, greens, and purples!!

Woo! Dare To Wear just hit stores here!! I think I might skip Zingy because it’s so close to Electric Eel (right?). I’m going to try to get my hands on Going Bananas. Do you think Crazy Cool is a good choice if you don’t have any purples? Digit might be too light for my taste! Also, is Louder, Please similar to Passionate (but less pink perhaps?)?? Sorry for all the questions! Thanks πŸ™‚

It IS close. Like you could own both and see differences but you probably wouldn’t miss either.

Crazy Cool would be a good choice if you don’t have any purples πŸ˜‰ I find Louder, Please brighter and pinker than Passionate!

Hi Christine!!! what would you pair sky blue eyeshadow with? would it go with aqua eyeshadow you think?? i would like to get both eyeshadows but i dont know how to wear them! am an NC30, thank you!! πŸ™‚

Blues, aquas, teals… yes, it would definitely work with Aqua, though I’d probably use something darker/more contrasting!

I’ve got a quick question. How does Crazy Cool compare to the lightest color in the Togetherness mineralize eyeshadow trio from In The Groove? Would you suggest one over the other?

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! πŸ™‚ If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!