Archived Post

MAC Colored Zoom Lash Mascara Reviews, Photos, Swatches

Green is Green, Blue Charge, Plum Reserve, High Esteem

MAC Colored Zoom Lash Mascara

I reviewed Green is Green initially, and here are swatches of the other three shades, as well as the mascaras worn on lashes. I actually found that Green is Green did the best at coating lashes, with Blue Charge close behind. Plum Reserve and High Esteem didn’t coat my lashes as effectively and didn’t give them much color.

Blue Charge is darker than Themyscira, while Plum Reserve is darker and purpler than Victorious. I think you’ll notice less color difference when they are worn, though, but swatched, their differences are easily seen.

my thoughts on the mascara formula: Zoom Lash is supposed to “build density,” while the “ultra-sculpted brush has three-sided fibres to embrace and separate each lash.” My favorite MAC mascara is Plushlash, but I used to use Zoom Lash for quite a bit (because Plushlash didn’t exist). I like how it’s a really thick formula–thick as in it really coats each lash really well in the formula but without clumping. Zoom Lash, being a thicker consistency, will clump if you start going beyond two coats, though. (In my experience, you shouldn’t need more than two.) Zoom Lash separates and defines lashes while thickening them for me. I didn’t have any issues with the mascara flaking or smudging on me.

MAC Colored Zoom Lash Mascara Reviews, Photos, Swatches


Green is Green, Blue Charge, Plum Reserve, High Esteem

High Esteem

Plum Reserve

Blue Charge

Green is Green, Blue Charge

Plum Reserve, High Esteem

High Esteem

Plum Reserve

Blue Charge


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Carrie Ann Avatar

I’ve never seen a gray mascara before, so I’m really curious about that. I’ve been using the regular black Zoom Lash for the first time and I’m surprised at how much I like it. It definitely makes your lashes pop.

kate Avatar

Thanks for the photos and review, Christine. It reminds me why I don’t bother much with coloured mascaras. I had some hope for High Esteem, since it supposedly had a kind of shimmer, but I don’t see any of these really warranting a purchase atm.

Liz Mc Avatar

Does anyone know how long unopened mascara will keep? I have, am using and love all the colored mascaras from Wonder Woman, was thinking of getting this as backups and saving them until I run out of the WW ones.

Shannon R Avatar

Hi Christine,

I have a tech issue rather than a makeup comment. I subscribe to your RSS feed to keep updated on your posts (can’t say enough good things about RSS). Works fine in general – I can see the swatches and look breakdowns and everything. The only thing that doesn’t show up is the ratings, but only since you moved to the new ratings scheme. On the site you have this nice purple table/graphic breakdown of the Glossover, but in the RSS feed, there is just text with no score (e.g. “PIGMENTATION : /10”) I thought the techie bf might want to know. Maybe you could get him a philosophy shower gel if he could look into it 🙂


Ana Carolina Ribeiro Avatar

I’m using Google Reader and I have a similar complaint. The Glossometer doesn’t show with the nice pink design – it’s plain text, althought it does come with the actual results. The old rating system would come exactly like it showed on the website.

Shannon R Avatar

I’m using google reader as well. Just wanted to let you know that today’s review of the Surf Baby eyeshadows did have the ratings included, although not in the fancy pink design.

Lindsay Avatar

I don’t have that problem with my RSS reader; her scores show up just fine.

Unfortunately, I actually have a different problem. 🙁 for some reason, only the newest *3* posts will actually be displayed. I don’t know if that’s how it’s supposed to be, but I dislike it since I know I end up missing posts!

I’m using Pulse Reader on an iPhone. None of my other feeds have so few stories/posts; I can swipe left/right through at least a dozen (probably more).

Edelmc Avatar

I like the blue and purple and I use an eye lash primer so, like you said, they will pop even more. I think I have to wait till they come out next month in Europe!

Hillary Avatar

I hope you don’t mind me asking but what moisturiser do you use? I wish I could get the skin around my eyes to look as nice as yours! 🙁

MissMercurial Avatar

Thanks for the swatches – it helps kill my lemming XD.
Out of curiosity, though, what (if any) colored mascara that you’ve tried gives good color payoff? Particularly blues and/or purples?
I’ve tried a colored mascara from LA Splash in red, which was surprisingly pigmented even on my bare (DARK) lashes, but of course that’s not an indicator that other colors will be just as saturated/noticeable. The color addict in me just won’t let go of the idea of colored mascara, haha.

Shanna Avatar

I’m actually here to comment about the same thing as Shannon R. I was scrolling through the page looking for some sort of “contact me” button and noticed her comment (I gave up looking when I saw it haha). I’m not sure if I’m subscribed by RSS (I get the daily email) or not, but I have the exact same problem that she does. Ever since you updated your layout for the rating system, I can’t see the actual rating. To answer the question you asked her, I don’t really know about an RSS feeder, but I do read it in Yahoo mail.

I took a screenshot of what it looks like in my email.

Maureen Avatar

I’d love to try the blue one. My eyes are smack in-between blue/green/gray, and normally makeup that is intended to “bring out the blue!” is straight up… ugly blue eyeshadow. All of the blue mascara I’ve seen out there is NOT subtle.

IN SHORT, lol, Blue Charge might look good.

Chloe Avatar

I wished they had made the mascara from a collection last year permenant (it was a small one around the same time as champale) because it was a nice colour 🙁

Gabi Avatar

I was looking forward to this, but now I’m not so sure. The mascaras seem very sheer and thin. I can barely see the colors in your eyelashes except for one dot here and there. Truth is they did nothing to your eyelashes. Could you please post new fotos using a eyelash primer so we can check the difference? Thanks! :}

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!