Archived Post

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set Review, Photos, Swatches

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set

A Cool-Toned Set of Chunky, Metallic Pigments

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set ($32.50 for 0.40 oz.) consists of four shades: She’s Got Class (silver frost), Moss Garden (light green blue frost), Spruced (teal frost), and I’ve Got a Crush on You (browned teal frost).  This set will launch early next week online and in-stores on November 8th.

She’s Got Class is a silver-tinged white with a frosted, metallic finish. It’s sheer when applied dry, and it comes together and yields better payoff when applied damp. There are a number of shades that are comparable, including Wet ‘n’ Wild Shimmer the Night Away, Cinderella Ball Gown , MAC How to Marry, theBalm Metal-ica, and Maybelline Too Cool.

Moss Garden is a pale, dirty green with a gray-rown base. It’s a very interesting color, though it is a repromote from the Butterfly Party (Vera, ’12). Lancome Enduring Vert is greener. Chanel Rivere is lighter, greener. MAC Water is much, much darker. Urban Decay Money is similar, but it is darker.

Spruced is a rich emerald green with a hint of teal. It had good color payoff both wet and dry, and it was less metallic/frosted compared to the other shades in the set. Just a heads up, this shade stains incredibly easily. I would absolutely recommend using a base underneath it to minimize it. I had major staining on my arm (and it wasn’t on for longer than five minutes there) and my eye when I wore it in the crease. Tom Ford Emerald Lust is greener, lighter. MAC Jealousy Wakes is greener, less teal. MAC Double Feature 4 is darker. Urban Decay Minx is lighter.

I’ve Got a Crush on You is a strong red-toned, medium-dark brown with a green-teal duochrome. It’s like a jacked up version of MAC Club, MAC Blue Brown, and Too Faced Label Whore. When it’s applied dry, it’s much redder and has less of a duochrome–the duochrome mostly comes out when it is applied damp.  The texture on this shade was a bit finer than She’s Got Class or Moss Garden.

I always feel rather torn over these sets. The colors are often gorgeous, but the finish, which looks fun and sparkly and glitzy on my arm, looks spectacularly awful on my lids. I find they have to be used very sparingly and take some patience to work with, because they give my lids a very wrinkled, crepe-y appearance. All the frost and metallic just tends stick against itself and accentuate any texture on the lids. I used these wet for the look, as it tends to be the easiest way to minimize fall out, amplify color, and get each shade to smooth out.

I want to love these so bad, but they’re a product I never return to, for as beautiful as the colors are, they are difficult to use and are unflattering on my eyes.  They are similar to MAC Pigments, but the texture is much chunkier–think of the chunkiest MAC pigment (Kitschmas always comes to my mind), and these are going to be chunkier.  They wear well, though, and used damp, there is very minor fall out during wear, and they do not crease or fade even if used alone (without a primer or base).

Something really cool: these sets have always been a really good value, and the holiday sets are actually $1.50 less than the sets released in February ($34.00).

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set Review, Photos, Swatches

B
8.5
Product
9
Pigmentation
8.5
Texture
9
Longevity
3.5
Application
86%
Total

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC She’s Got Class Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC She’s Got Class Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC She’s Got Class Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC She’s Got Class Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC She’s Got Class Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Moss Garden Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Moss Garden Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Moss Garden Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Moss Garden Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Moss Garden Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Spruced Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Spruced Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Spruced Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Spruced Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Spruced Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC I’ve Got a Crush on You Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC I’ve Got a Crush on You Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC I’ve Got a Crush on You Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC I’ve Got a Crush on You Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC I’ve Got a Crush on You Crushed Metallic Pigment

MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set
MAC Brilliantly Cool Crushed Metallic Pigments Set

21 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Irina Avatar

The sparkle and shine of them are mesmerizing. Will probably end up buying all of the sets just for the beauty of it, even though it’s so much money!

Yellowlantern Avatar

Moss Garden is a gorgeous and nuanced color. I love the mint green with a brown base and white shimmer. Too bad I’d have to buy the whole set to get it. Ah well, I guess it’s just as well since you say the formula isn’t very good anyway.

Tessa Avatar

Spruced is the only one that I liked, its a gorgeous color, but if it’s going to stain my skin, then there’s no way I’ll be getting it. Thanks for the heads-up!

Becca @ The Beauty Sample Avatar

These are gorgeous shades, but I do get what you mean by the pigments accentuating the texture on the lids. I find that many of the L’Oreal Infallibles look heavy and give this wrinkly appearance too, which is why I don’t ever wear the ones I own :/

Tina Avatar

Check out Fervent pigment by Illamasqua as a dupe for I’ve Got a Crush on You. I think it is a bit more reddish though but the duochrome effect is more beautiful 😀

Huda Avatar

Christine do you think that pressing the pigments would ruin the color pay off or quality? I hate how gritty they are and I have the ones from last holiday and they just sit there.. i was thinking of maybe pressing them into a pan?

Christine Avatar

I don’t think it would ruin the payoff or quality, but I’m not sure it would improve them! I’m thinking the payoff might be sheerer, but it may be more buildable.

The upside is if you never reach for them, there’s no real harm in trying 🙂

Kris Avatar

When I got the pigments today I was: OMG, this texture, this metallic finish, these colors…And they do look absolutely stunning on my lids too. Can’t understand, that you don’t like them…

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!