Thursday, May 13th, 2010

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Scorcher Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection — Nail Lacquer Reviews, Photos, Swatches

To the Beach includes two shades of limited edition nail lacquer ($12 a pop). The one not yet included in this review is Scorcher (creamy bright coral-red), which I will be sure to include as soon as I can.

  • In the Buff is a muted, brownish-green. It’s not quite the green I’d think of when I hear the word “avocado,” but it’s not totally off from there either. It’s almost like an avocado that’s been exposed to air for a few too many minutes. I’m not entirely sure this is a flattering color, but it seems like a unique one to me.
  • Scorcher is a brightened, intense red-coral with a cream finish.  It was pretty easy to apply with very little streaking, even on the first coat.  I used three to get to a nice, solid color.

The application was fine for me, but I generally don’t have issues with MAC lacquers. It has a cream finish, so no shimmer, and two coats is enough to get pretty opaque, but I did three because I messed up on one finger for the second coat.

See more photos & swatches!

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Scorcher Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Scorcher Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Scorcher Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC Scorcher Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC In the Buff Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC In the Buff Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC In the Buff Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC In the Buff Nail Lacquer (Flash)

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC In the Buff Nail Lacquer

MAC To the Beach Collection
MAC In the Buff Nail Lacquer

In the Buff was provided as a press sample; Scorcher was purchased by Temptalia.

Please do not repost these images without permission! If you want to share, please link back to this post! Thank you :)

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

54 thoughts on “MAC To the Beach Collection – Nail Lacquer Reviews, Photos, Swatches

  1. i must say it’s a very um, unique color but i think it looks like cream de baby poop!

  2. Abbie

    Hey, it’s hard to tell from the photographs but would you say its more green or more beige? The first photo looks very beige-y/neutral and the second two look more green. I want to purchase Originality from the pret a papier collection and don’t want to buy another MAC polish if its not worth it! Thanks x

  3. Lisa

    Honestly, I like the OPI Fiercely Fiona or Who The Shrek Are You from the Shrek Collection better.

  4. Danielle

    It looks like those avocado-coloured appliances from the 70’s!

  5. Victoria N.

    This looks sooo much darker than in the promo pics! Its a shame :( I would have liked to see a muted, lightened avacago color, it looked so dreamy almost in the promo!

  6. GretalovesMAC

    sorry to the people who do like this color but it looks like poo-poo!! It looked a lot better in the promo pics.

    • You know, I can totally see that — in fact, I was thinking to myself, while I was swatching, that surely someone would call it vomit green!

  7. Princess Lolli

    This so reminds me of the horridly tacky avocado colored appliances from the 1970s. I’m a nail polish junkie and tend to gravitate toward less traditional shades (and I can never get enough greens!), but this is horrid.

  8. Tekoa

    Ewwww. This is worse than Dry Martini. No. Just….no. No no no and no to the HELL NO.

  9. Becca

    I actually really like this color; like the review says “may not be the most flattering” but it’s definitely unique! I have a few outfits I think would love gorgeous with this laquer. This might have to be my first MAC polish~are the polish’s pretty high quality??

    • Some people have issues with MAC polish — I’d say that a good portion do, but I, personally, have no issues. I use Zoya’s Color Lock System and don’t have chipping problems with my MAC polishes!

  10. Wow, usually, I think Mac can do no wrong but… omg. I love nail polish and almost any color but… omg. This pushes the limit of even what I consider ok. This is hideous! It’s like Linda Blair puke green!! OMG. It’s honest to God, exorcist split pea soup vomit!

    I hope you hurry and get it off your pretty nails! Recuperate by wearing one of the new Zoyas, and soothingly coo to your fingers how you’ll never do that to them again!! XD

    • LOL! I didn’t think they were puke-y, but I think it just depends. I didn’t have it on for long, for I was busy swatching China Glaze 😉

  11. Paloma

    This looks like what I found in my daughters diaper today…..

    gross, but thanks!

  12. Nadine

    I’m really thinking about getting this one.It’s definetly a unique colour and I don’t understand why so many don’t like it.I’m just wondering how it would look with my light skintone,because I’m a NW 15.Would you say it’s more flattering on light or darker skintones?

    • Both, I think. I think the lightness against lighter skin is nice, but I think the lightness against darker skin tones offers a nice contrasting effect.

    • christine

      i do like it, especially the in the buff, its v.pretty 😀 i got one already 😀

  13. Janet

    Ok, this doesn’t really have to do with the nail polish, but how do you paint it so precisely with the neat border? I’ve always heard to keep a small border around the cuticles, but the way you do it is so professional and I have no idea how to do it myself. Anyone have any tips?

  14. Petra

    I totally see where peopel are coming from – even the MA at MAC said: Really, this one? when I asked her to give me one.
    But I think it’s unique and as long as I’ wear a colour as clothing, I’ll wear it as a polish, too. I think it will look really nice with my light skintone, and it seems very summery-lazy but kind of chic to me.
    But yeah, I’ll get hell for it from so many people. :)

    • I think it’s totally not pukey, too 😛

      I don’t know… I feel like maybe at first glance it’s a bit pea soup, but give it a few glances and it’s lovely!

  15. Hmmmm…. Interesting. I’m not sure what to think of this…

  16. Diana B

    very nice and different.

  17. JoElla

    I am all for wild colors for fingers and toes, but this one looks like baby food peas.. Not my favorite color. But hey for those who buy and love it, rock that look!

  18. aradhana

    i wonder why they call it in the buff? i was expecting something a little more in the beige family…
    i tried the two polishes in the store today…i think i’m more likely to go for scorcher, but for that a second haul may be required.

  19. I’m sorry to say this…but this is probably one of the most horrible colors a nail polish can have. I would never wear this…MAC what is wrong with u?

  20. Natalie

    Haha all the comments crack me up! Love your description of ‘avocado that has been left in the air for a few minutes’ lol. I think it is so different and nice! Definitely getting one!

  21. Nadine

    OK,I just ordered Scorcher instead of In the Buff.Safer pick:)I think Scorcher will be sold out much more quickly,since In the Buff doesn’t seem to have a lot of fans.So I can still think about getting In the Buff later.

  22. Lisa

    Blech…I have to say, In the Buff has got to be one of the ugliest things I’ve ever seen. Would that color flatter ANYONE?
    Scorcher’s okay, it’s not ugly…but its rather LOUD.

  23. leigh

    Wow, In the Buff is one of the ugliest polish colors I have ever seen. It looks like someone looked at the inside of a dirty baby diaper and said, “that would be a good polish color.” Truly beyond hideous.

  24. G

    I love the scorcher red, do you know when its out?

  25. aradhana

    i discovered yesterday evening upon returning back to the flat that rimmel 60 seconds has an ‘almost’ identical dupe for scorcher — 430 coralicious. it’s sllllllllightly more towards pink, but not much. so i decided to wear it, and skip on scorcher. more money for blush?

  26. Claudia

    I love In the Buff but then again I’m currently wearing RBL No More War =P

  27. lylyoo

    i bought both the nail polishes today. i just wore In the Buff two layers and all im gonna say is: put it on your nails take a look from distance and you are gonna love it. it looks nice with both one layer on two layers. and i think this is one of the easiest MAC nail polish to put on, tiny tiny tiny waves on first layer but second layer everything is perfect. and instead of poo or pea, this reminds me of olive oil & green olive gone greener.

    • I’m getting both. I”m so pleased with the brown bag color from Pret, I think these colors look interesting.. Scorcher is a no brainer.

      In the buff may be a funky nude.

  28. jaspreet

    Thank you! I think it will look good on my hands

  29. scorcher is sooo pretty~

  30. Kristy

    If you are one of those women with ivory skintone, auburn hair and avocado green eyes, this will be your dream color. For the other 5.9 billion of us, not so much.

  31. Carin

    Do you know if there are any dupes for these colors?

  32. *Carin*

    Are these two colors now in the premanent line?

  33. Kristen

    Maybe China Glaze “High Hopes” from the Up and Away collection could be a dupe for Scorcher? I’m wearing High Hopes right now and they look similar, but Scorcher is sold out :( so I cant compare.

    • *Carin*

      I went to look if there are any pictures online of these two nail polishes, so I found the pictures Christine took of her swatches, and it seems like High Hopes has a bit more of a pinkish undertone, while Scorcher has a red one, but they are sooo similar 😀 thanks!

  34. Shan

    Hmm.. I love scorcher, but on me its an intense deep pink rather than the orangy coral in your pictures. Ah well, still a dazzling pretty color for summer :)