I personally like more shimmery than matte shades, but I like a variety in shimmer levels and still want a couple of mattes included (typically in more basic shades). I also prefer for pre-made palettes to be cohesive–that I can use it to create multiple looks without having to add in other products. It should be slim, travel-friendly, and sturdy. I don’t use palette mirrors, so a lack of mirror wouldn’t be a deal-breaker for me.
P.S. — I love seeing everyone interact with each other here, so I am also going approve comments without replying (with the intention of still replying personally!) as I can so that you can see each others comments ASAP!
For sure, Guerlain Parure Gold when I look at an “all time” record! Following that, I wore MAC Studio Fix Fluid for at least a couple of years long ago. Currently, Tarte Rainforest of the Sea has been my go-to since it debuted, and I don’t expect to give it up any time soon!