We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

43 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Your skin tone/coloring: Cool, fair.
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Cover Girl Perfect Point Plus. I never lose it unless I’ve been crying or I take it off physically.
Best long-wearing foundation? Don’t wear foundation.
Best long-wearing blush? Nars blushes. I’m wearing New Order today.

Your skin tone/coloring: light/olive undertone
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Urban Decay 24/7 liners and liquid liners. They stay on foreverrrr.
Best long-wearing foundation? Honestly don’t wear foundation much. But my MAC mineralize foundation is pretty decent.
Best long-wearing blush? Tarte Amazonian clay blush. I desperately need more of them 😛

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20

Best long-wearing eyeliner? Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes

Best long-wearing foundation? Guerlain Lingerie de Peau

Best long-wearing blush? Estee Lauder Pure Color Blush and NARS Powder Blush

Your skin tone/coloring:

Fair Skin with Neutral Skintone, (Nars Mont Blanc, Guerlain Lingerie 01. Chanteacaille alabaster, Chanel 12 Beige Rose, MAC NW15),
with oily+acne-prone skin :'(

Best long-wearing eyeliner?

MUFE Aqua Black, excellent eye gel/cream eyeliner.
Etude House (Korean Brand) Oh m’ Eye Line Liquid Eyeliner.(around USD$7)
One day I argued with my bf, then I cried crazily…but nothing was off..My liner was still perfect!! verrry impressed. It’s very BLACK and easy to apply. (After cry&whole day).’cause I live in HK, there are many korean brands everywhere, cheap and good valued. This is my HG liquid eyeliner.
For pencils, I voted for UD 24/7 and Nars Larger than life eyeliner pencil.

Best long-wearing foundation?

These days I’m addicted to Guerlain Lingerie Liquid..Quite long-lasting and beautiful finish.
(humid weather, 32degrees)
Chanteacaille Future skin.. I love the color shade..it’s Perfect for me, Not too yellowish or too pink
But I think Chanel mat lumiere perfection compact foundation is the most long-lasting..sadly in some lighting I saw a little white mask on my face..not as natural as Guerlain’s..
In my opinion, to make a long-wearing makeup, the most important is to prepare well and use a suitable primer.

Best long-wearing blush?

I looove Chanel & NArs blush, very flattering and long-lasting, MAC is a bit shorter.
I wanna buy Tom ford but they don’t have any shade that attracts me..(I own too many different shades).Only tried on counter, very good texture ! Mr. ford.
OH! Le Metier de Beaute is fantastic too. romeo & juilet is a wonderful product for light complexion or pink lovers.(I’m not a coral or orange lover)

â– Your skin tone/coloring: Medium NC35
â– Best long-wearing eyeliner? Urban Decay Zero
â– Best long-wearing foundation? MAC ProLong
â– Best long-wearing blush? IT Cosmetics Vitality Cheek Flush Powder Blush Stain

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair with neutral to pink undertones. Chanel BR-12 in Vitalumiere Aqua foundation (Probably MAC NW-15 ish)

Best long-wearing eyeliner?Smashbox Limitless Liner in Onyx is pretty decent, and then any of the UD 24/7 liners are great.

Best long-wearing foundation? Revlon Colorstay (oily). I have dry to combo skin, so this stuff lasts forever.

Best long-wearing blush? Tarte’s Blushing Bride in the powder formulation. I’m extremely fair and this is a pretty deep color, so that combined with the formula makes the color last forever on my skin.

-skin tone/ coloring: very fair neutral, nc/nw10
-best longwearing eyeliner: mac gel liner, urban decay waterproof liquid liner, urban decay 24/7 pencils.
-best longwearing foundation: lancome teint idole 24hr.
-best longwearing blush: Tom Ford (i’m obsessed with blushes and these wear all day with no fading or color change on my oily skin, the best i’ve used!)

â—¾Your skin tone/coloring: NW20

â—¾Best long-wearing eyeliner? I don’t wear eyeliner sorry !

◾Best long-wearing foundation? Kiko BB Glow Foundation ( cream, very good and pricey 13,90 € )

â—¾Best long-wearing blush? Dior duo blushes ( 001 and 002 ) or the Chanel ones

I’m light to fair-skinned, and while I’ve had decent success with longer lasting foundation and blush, I really have to give it up to Jemma Kidd’s liquid eyeliner that has since been discontinued and was carried at Target. I have used dozens of long-lasting eyeliners and they’ve all done very well, but this stuff is ROAD TAR. It takes a while to set and feels kind of greasy until it does, but you’ve got to really rub at it to remove it and I’ve worked twelve-hour shifts in a demanding food service job with it coming out completely unchanged, even after sweating and doing messy dishes! I’m utterly heartbroken that it’s discontinued. It’s my Chanel Dragon!

Your skin tone/coloring: Light with yellow undertones
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Mac Fluidline
Best long-wearing foundation? Any of the full to medium coverage Prescriptives ones are amazing
Best long-wearing blush? Estee Lauder Pure Color Blush

Your skin tone/coloring: – NC25
Best long-wearing eyeliner? – Tarte EmphasEyes Waterproof Liner – I use the brown and despite my eye rubbing and love of using copious amounts of eye cream, it actually stays on!
Best long-wearing foundation? – I dont wear foundation typically, but for a tinted moisturizer, NARS pure radiant tinted moisturizer lasts pretty well
Best long-wearing blush? – Illamasqua for sure! I am wearing Ambition a lot lately and it has great staying power.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Mac Fluidline or Urban Decay 24/7
Best long-wearing foundation? Revlon Colorstay (I’ve tried combo/oily and whipped. Both last and last) or Estee Lauder Double Wear (original, not light)
Best long-wearing blush? Lancome Blush Subtil

Your skin tone/coloring: NC05

Best long-wearing eyeliner: These are all waterproof~ NYX, Milani, and Too Facced for pencils and any Gel liner I’ve tried. 😉

Best long-wearing foundation: Tarte Amazonian Clay and Illuamaqua Skin Base (both silicon based)

Best long-wearing blush: FACEatelier Facade

Your skin tone/coloring: fair/warm
Best long-wearing eyeliner?Urban Decay 24/7 liners
Best long-wearing foundation?Tarte Amazonian clay 12hr foundation
Best long-wearing blush? Tarte Amazonian clay blushes. Love love love them

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool-toned
Best long-wearing eyeliner? GOSH Velvet Touch (I think that’s the name) pencil
Best long-wearing foundation? MAC Pro-Longwear (Clarins has a good one too but not as many colour choices)
Best long-wearing blush? Hand down Tarte Amazonian Clay powder blushes.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW25-30

Best long-wearing eyeliner? I’m only referring to the black versions of these
Pencil: Either Sephora Waterproof Retractable or Physician’s Formula Shimmer Strips retractable. Sumita pencil (but only on top lash line)
Liquid: Eyeko Skinny Mini
Gel: Bobbi Brown
What people love that doesn’t work for me: UD 24/7, MUFE aqua liquid or pencil, Milani Liquif’ye, MAC Technakohl, Revlon Colorstay
I want to try: Giorgio Armani Smooth Silk, Tarina Tarantino

Best long-wearing foundation? Sorry, I don’t wear foundation.

Best long-wearing blush? NARS powder

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair, warm undertones.
Best long-wearing eyeliner? To be honest, I don’t wear eyeliner much. But I’ve had good experiences with the Bobbi Brown gel eyeliners.
Best long-wearing foundation? I’d have to say Bobbi Brown Stick foundation, but I haven’t got on with much else because the colour ranges of most companies are much too dark/orange for me!
Best long-wearing blush? Tarte Amazonian Clay!

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair and cool ~ (Urban Decay NAKED Foudation in 0.5)
Best long-wearing eyeliner?: Urban Decay Glide On 24/7 Eyeliner pencils, Physician’s Formula Lash Booster 2-in-1 Eyeliner & Serum (some name along these lines) liquid liner. This is also the only liquid liner I can wear since its hypoallergenic; the others I’ve tried so far have irritated my eyes. It stays on nicely but can get rubbed away easily or if I really start crying!
Best long-wearing foundation?: I’d say my SKIN79 Super+ Hot Pink BB stays on my (currently) combo-oily skin!
Best long-wearing blush?: I don’t wear blush very much 😀

i used to like skin79 (hotpink) too
It’s good but a little heavy for skin.
And there are many other brands’ bb creams which are much much better.

It might be heavy for your skin specifically but its fine for my skin in the summer. Its made for oily and acne prone skin, as well as it blends in perfectly, which is normally a big problem because I’m so pale. Since a lot of Korean BBs have one or two, maybe even three colors, I’d have to go find samples or try to find the full-size of a specific color–something that’s not super easy to do on the Internet. Plus, since there’s so much varying SPF and various levels of titanium dioxide are used for many, I could get a severe breakout as an allergic reaction.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW35
Best long-wearing eyeliner? UD 24-7 Liner in Perversion
Best long-wearing foundation? I actually mix MAC’s PLW Concealer with Careblend Oil so it stays on all day but looks soft and 2nd skin like.
Best long-wearing blush? MAC Stay Pretty

Your skin tone/coloring: Light medium with warm yellow undertones

Best long-wearing eyeliner? Oooh, Milani Liquid Like or LA Girl Glide eye pencils

Best long-wearing foundation? The one I’m currently using that I mixed myself!

Best long-wearing blush? Mehron Cheek Creams (set with powder) – they last all day!

skintone: medium/deep

best long wearing eyeliner: rimmel scandaleyes shadow pencil in blamed blue, it is AMAZING as an eyeliner, also tarina tarantino spark of envy liner, and YSL dessin du regard waterproof eye pencil

best long wearing foundation: revlon color stay and YSL le teint touche eclat

best long wearing blush: Nars blushes and Milani blushes

â– Your skin tone/coloring: Warm/Fair
â– Best long-wearing eyeliner? I have found many very good ones: Bobbi Brown, MAC Fluidline, MAC liquid eyeliner, Lancome Artliner, MAC PowerPoint Pencils
â– Best long-wearing foundation? I wear Missha BB Cream and it wears long on me.
â– Best long-wearing blush? NARS Blush wears well.

Your skin tone/coloring: Tan
Best long-wearing eyeliner? L’oreal Lineur Intense
Best long-wearing foundation? MUFE HD
Best long-wearing blush? Nars

Your skin tone/coloring: NC35
Best long-wearing eyeliner? MAC fluidline
Best long-wearing foundation? Giorgio Armani lasting silk
Best long-wearing blush? Chanel

Your skin tone/coloring: Neutral/Beige
Best long-wearing eyeliner? MUFE Waterproof Liner
Best long-wearing foundation? Chanel Mat Lumiere and Estee Lauder Double Wear Light both stay on all day for me.
Best long-wearing blush? I’ve never had an issue with my blush fading! I use NARS, MAC, Tarte, & BECCA.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Urban Decay 24/7
Best long-wearing foundation? I wish I knew. I sweat everything off!
Best long-wearing blush? Nars Orgasm

1. NW20
2. Rimmel Scandaleyes, the only thing that lasts in my waterline ALL DAY
3. Mac Studio Fluid
4. Haven’t found an amazing long wearing blush yet. I use the cheap Essence ones in either 10 Adorable or 20 Babydoll

Your skin tone/coloring: NW 20-25

Best long-wearing eyeliner? MAC Fluidlines, UD 24/7s, and Tarina Tarantinos

Best long-wearing foundation? Revlon Colorstay and Colorstay Lite, back when I wore foundation.

Best long-wearing blush? They all seem to vanish by the end of the day on me.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light with pink undertones, more neutral than cool or warm.
Best long-wearing eyeliner: Either the Stila waterproof liquid eyeliner pen or Kat Von D’s liquid eye liner pens, theyre literally the same product but Kat Von D’s a few bucks cheaper.
Best long-wearing foundation: I dont use foundation, I just wear a bb cream. Ive been loving my Dr. Jart+ Premium bb cream with 45 spf. Its lasting me forever and doesnt break out my oil and acne prone skin. <3
Best long-wearing blush: Tarte's amazonian 24 hour blushes are the best hands down.

NW45ish
Tie between UD 24/7 in perversion and its dupe Prestige Intensity in blackest black
Don’t wear foundation, only tm
Milani Luminosity at the moment

Your skin tone/coloring: NW20

Best long-wearing eyeliner? Stila Stay All Day Pens (liquid) or their smudgesticks (for pencil)

Best long-wearing foundation? Kat Von D foundation

Best long-wearing blush? Kat Von D Heartagram in particular, but her other blushes last on me nicely as well and MAC Mineralize Blush in Style Demon – idk why that one (probably because it’s super pigmented and I’m very fair?) lasts all day even though the other mineralize blushes don’t.

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium (MAC NC35)
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Kiss Me Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner
Best long-wearing foundation? MAC Studio Fix
Best long-wearing blush? Illamasqua Powder Blush in Hussy or NARS Blush in Deep Throat

Your skin tone/coloring: NC40 – 44
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Bobbi Brown gel liner
Best long-wearing foundation? Revlon Colorstay 24 Hr
Best long-wearing blush? Toss up between Tarte Dazzled and NARS Rotonde

Skin: Light, neutral.

Eyeliner: Essence Longwear pencil; I’ve been wearing this on my waterline the past few weeks, and I walk an average of 2 miles a day, and even in 85+° F weather, this does not budge. Most pencils (including UD 24/7) slide right of within an hour, but the Essence stays until I take it off. As for liquid liners, UD 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner; it can withstand a 12-hour Summer day at Disneyland, complete with multiple runs on Splash Mountain.

Foundation: It really depends on what I’m wearing under it, the weather, my level of physical activity, etc. What worked for me when I had a bank job, sitting down in an air-conditioned space, doesn’t work for me, now. I spend alot more time outdoors, and therefore wear more/heavier SPF. My activity level is also higher, so I definitely needed to switch. Before I worked in a bank, I worked a night-shift in a restaurant, so although no SPF was needed, I still required a different foundation than what I used at the bank.

Blush: Again, there are many variables. If my foundation breaks down, no matter what blush I’m wearing, it won’t stay. I’ve used many foundations over the years, and while I loved some, they didn’t quite mesh with my chemistry. I don’t judge the “wear-time” of a blush, since I find they all work better (or worse) given a specific foundation, and/or environment.

Your skin tone/coloring: Ultra Fair (NARS Siberia)
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Jesse’s Girl Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner. This doesn’t budge on me, which is a miracle with my hooded eyes and oily lids.
Best long-wearing foundation? Good question! I’m not sure what the longest wearing foundation is on my skin these days. Maybe Illamasqua Skin Base (I use a mix of 1 and 4, though 2 works well too).
Best long-wearing blush? tarte Captivated from the Aqualillies palette.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light (NC 20-25), pink undertones
Best long-wearing eyeliner? Miliani liquify
Best long-wearing foundation? Revlon Colorstay, Revlon Colorstay whipped
Best long-wearing blush? MAC- Warm Soul

Your skin tone/coloring: Light with cool undertones (UD Naked 3.5)
Best long-wearing eyeliner? For my waterline, Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner. It lasts about an hour or so before I have to touch it up. For my lash line, either the Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner or the Kat Von D liquid liner. The chiseled felt-tip one.
Best long-wearing foundation? I’ve only ever used three. xD UD Naked Skin foundation lasts the longest on me.
Best long-wearing blush? Only used one. =P

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/Pink undertones. Usually NW15
Best long-wearing eyeliner: I prefer the MAC Prolongwear eyeliner
Best long-wearing foundation: Shiseido sun protection liquid foundation, Chanel vitalumiere Aqua, and MAC Prolongwear are my fail safe foundations that give beautiful finishes, protect my skin, and stay on all day.
Best long-wearing blush: MAC blushbaby, well dressed, and Benefit’s Dandelion

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!