Sneak Peek: Tarte Metallics Shadows (Summer 2017) Photos & Swatches

TARTE

Metallics Shadows

Eleven new shades were added to the Tarte Metallics Shadows ($14.00 for 0.07 oz.) range last week. I bought them through Tarte, but unfortunately, 8 of the 11 arrived broken, so apologies for the messier photos! (Tarte said they would refund me, and I’ll be repurchasing them but want to go through Ulta/Sephora, in case it happens again, so I can just deal with it in-store. There was no damage to the package, and it was packed fine, so I’m not sure what led to the damage.) Nevertheless, here are photos and swatches:

Metallics Shadows

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

38 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

OMG Christine! Did they just toss your order up in the air and hope it landed at your house? Yikes. The Amethyst I ordered from Tarte came double wrapped in bubble wrap. Revel is on my want list but judging from your swatches, I may also want Downtown and Genie.

It’s very weird – there was no sign that there’d be anything broken at all, and it didn’t seem like it was poorly packaged. My inkling is that the eyeshadows arrived damaged to the warehouse!

I’m brand new to your site – can’t believe I didn’t discover you until recently!

The tarte metallics are gorgeous! But seeing as they arrived broken I’ll hold off. I’m waiting for full reviews of all the new tarte stuff before I buy!

Also would love to see a review from you of tarte palettes Maneater and Sex Kitten. Thank you!

These look quite good….let’s just hope they won’t be online only or Tarte exclusives. That would lead to a js type breakage debacle and all kinds of furor. Should be popular. Even the blue is decent. Nice issue.

Downtown and Dark Seas look nice, though they’re not unique shades. Amethyst and Jade are pretty, but I wish they had a richer base or maybe a brighter sheen. I was curious how these would compare to the new palette they just released. I bought that, and though the shades are pretty, I wish they all had richer bases because the sheen overwhelms the base colors and end up making them look a little pastel on my fair skin. I’ll wait for your reviews before picking up any of these!

Also, I forgot to comment that it’s pretty sad that 8 out of your 11 shadows came broken. Were they not packaged well? I’ve never ordered from Tarte before, but if this is any indicator of how they package their shipments, I don’t think I will.

The box had no exterior or visible damage, and everything seemed to be packed fine – even the eyeshadow boxes were in pristine shape! My guess is they actually arrived damaged to the warehouse vs. damaged en route to me (it also went overnight, so it did not sit in transit as long!).

Ordered some original shades from Sephora yesterday (because I looked at your swatches of the original shades and instantly fell in love) and then I saw yours broken! I prayed hard that mine will be safe. Thankfully the packaged arrived safely.

Love the formula! now waiting for Jaded to be available here.

I don’t recall having issues with the first set of shades they released, though those were housed in plastic compacts (these are in cardboard) – oddly, cardboard usually absorbs impact better! No idea what happened with these at all.

Go figure — I threw/dropped one (by accident, lol) that WAS intact, and I was like, “Oh, great” but it was totally fine, so I’m not sure if it’s really fragile!

Wow, they look so pretty and swatched well. It’s a bummer they arrived broken! Do you usually try to fix them (how??) or just throw them out? One of my faves from MUFE broke after I dropped it and ended up just throwing it away 🙁

If it was one, I’d just throw it away after testing it, but with eight, I don’t think that’s reasonable for me to absorb. Tarte said they’d refund me, and I’m going to repurchase later on (with so many of them broken but no damage to the package itself nor did it seem poorly packed, I’m not sure what’s going on).

Oh great! I have 7 of the originals, which are buttery smooth and crazy pigmented. If these are anywhere near as good, looks like I will need about 7 of the new ones.

They are not wowing me, certainly look better when I see the individual swatches zoomed in; but otherwise, seem rather typical shade and texture wise to lots I have seen before. Neither am I impressed with the cracked shadows. They are not something I would be rushing out to purchase.

Downtown is gorgeous, and I’m also loving Jaded and Grommet. The fact that so many are damaged is really concerning though. I buy everything online in order to use rebate sites and I wouldn’t want to receive broken shadows…

Genie and Downtown could make for one bangin’ hot smoldering summer smokey eye! Pairing them with black , of course!
But, one has got to wonder whether these are a particularly fragile formula or a looser press, though. Or just very mishandled in the warehouse.

I’ve got to say, I was pretty excited for these but the swatches are fairly lackluster for metallics, in my opinion. With the exception of maybe Downtown and Dark Seas (which is stunning), they don’t have that foiled look I’d expect from metallics. For the price, I think I’m going to have to stick with the MUG foileds!

Amethyst is just beautiful, and Clueless also calls to me. And Vintage, though I think the Viseart Minx gold/copper will be a dupe and I do have that.

I’m all over the Tarte Revel eyeshadow!! I have bought from Tarte online and nothing has been broken. Everything was packed nicely and with loads of bubble wrap!!

I had so much trouble ordering from the last release too, and that was for sephora! I had to send things back three times since no one carried anything IN store nearby!
I noticed you said you would be ordering from ulta or sephora… are they going to be carrying these? I checked sephora’s website when that palette was released and I saw no sign of these singles…

as much as I like this formula, (and am really hoping the palette is surprisingly amazing!) these look pretty dupeable– except jaded! I’m kinda drooling over that shade! ?

I’m not sure! Ulta had three of the new shades (which I’ve already since purchased) when I looked this morning – but oddly, they have a very small selection of shades.

Augh. Jaded and Dark Seas look stunning, and exactly up my alley. It’s a shame these bold jewel tones didn’t make it into the new palette release!

Five of the seven I ordered arrived broken, which gave me a chance to see how super-thin the layer of shadow is in the pan. I was kind of surprised, but then remembered it’s not like I ever finish a shadow, anyway, so it’s not as much of an issue (also, while I like some of the colors a lot, none are the kind that I said, ‘I can put this with anything and it’ll look good’, so I doubt I’ll hit pan no matter how little there is. Like yours, my package appeared to have been prepared carefully.

When I called, they asked me for photos and the ‘batch codes’, so maybe they’re having this problem across the board? I did check against yours, and all five of mine are ones of yours that were broken, too.

They asked me photos, which is par for the course with Tarte (I’m not keen on that policy).

But yeah, to have 8 of 11 arrive broken without any visible damage to the original box nor the individual eyeshadow boxes suggests there’s a bigger issue (which is why I decided not to pursue an exchange).

If you click on any of the shade names, you can see full photos, which includes the back of the box (presumably where a batch code would be?) – http://www.temptalia.com/product/tarte-metallics-shadow/revel/

Downtown,Revel,Jaded,and Dark Seas are my favorites!I love the original Metallics from Tarte I have all of them except the gold and white and I put them all into a Tarte leopard Z palette that they sell and I use them all the time.I think I want most of theses but I’ll wait until there is a discount.Looking forward to your reviews!!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!