Cremesheen Glass lip swatches! 🙂 The ones that I found gave my lips the most color were Creme Anglaise, Melt In Your Mouth, and Petite Indulgence. Looks Like Sin is a bleeder, though I’m not sure why, because none of the others are. Fashion Scoop, Partial to Pink, and Ever So Rich all kind of looked the same on my lips! FYI, these are heavy applications! Anyway, enough of the recap, onto the pictures!
Creme Anglaise
Fashion Scoop
Partial To Pink
Boy Bait
Petite Indulgence
Ever So Rich
Looks Like Sin
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). (For more information, please check the FAQ.)
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.
Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.
Comments on this post are closed.
Shanel
im lovin petite indulgence, melt in your mouth & looks like sin 🙂
are these LE? i hope not!
my mac counter never had these out yet!
🙁
yea sadly they are Limited Edition BUT they sell them at an online makeup store called http://www.allcosmeticswholesale.com/. maybe you’ve heard of it, its like an online CCO. hope that helped
Yvonne
Hey! Do you have a makeupalley account? I’m swapping those lipglosses on my account! If you’re interested the account name I’m under is: Iheartcaliocean 🙂
Their texture is what sells them, since the colors are just so sheer.
meagan
I heart the texture of these. I got Petite Indulgence to wear over Lickable and Melt in Your Mouth to wear on their own. I think its hard to find opaque glosses like these with no shimmer or duochrome – they are really pretty.
For me, they’re not opaque at all, which is why they’re not my fave :/ The price also grates on my nerves.
meagan
maybe opaque’s not the right word…milky maybe? i have lighter lips than yours. but i think its definitely hard to find glosses without a ton of bells and whistles (like lots of different colored shimmer, etc) with this kind of texture – which is why i liked these and find them a fun alternative to my other glosses. they also just look gorgeous in that packaging – AND i love that they have the doe foot applicator 🙂
Yeah, I definitely think one is really all you *have* to own. If you love yourself some sheer, milky gloss with no shimmer… these are definitely great. I’m fine with $18 a pop if it was a brand that I’d expect it from – NARS, MUFE, Stila, etc. Not MAC.
-sigh- Oh, Looks Like Sin, how I USED to adore you. Your online swatch was so inviting, with its dark vibrancy; but now, I can only loathe you. Shame, for shame.
They last just fine, but compared to Rouge Volputes? Different animal. These aren’t creamy at all.
wendy
Thanks for the swatches Christine!
what do u think would be a good dupe for boy bait? i want it but i cant bring myself to spend CAD$21.50 for less the product!! makes me so mad! and, doesnt it look like the lipgloss kinda settles into the spaces in your lips? i noticed that when i tried it in store too.
To be honest, you could try a lipgelee (maybe Saplicious) if you want the texture but more for your money (0.5 oz for $14!) or Plushglass in Wildly Lush.
Some of them definitely do that!
Leah
I just tried these today since I heard they weren’t going to be as stick as other MAC glosses. I was skeptical, but they really aren’t! I bought Creme Anglaise, which is great for someone like me who doesn’t wear that much color on the lips. I wish it had a brush aplicator instead of a doe foot, though.
Whoa, boybait looks gorgeous. I was thinking of skipping on these because of your review but boybait really does look fairly gorgeous (sadly with a heavy application, but oh well!)
It’s not that they’re a bad product per se (if you don’t mind sheer colors), the price just bugs me so much!
No harm in getting one, right? ;P
babyboo
Boybait seems nice – very nude-ish!!!
I’ve never been much of a fan of any lippie that wasn’t nude (my lips are already tinted enough!!) but for once I’d like to own Petite Indulgence – a very bubble gum pink (to me anyway).
Its been REALLY hard for me to find lipglosses without any shimmer and glitter so I’m actually excited. I did swatches cuz it was out here in Asia much earlier on but I never realized it was shimmer-less until I read about it. However, I have to say I am concerned about the negative reviews on the lipglosses. 🙁 And yes, i did notice the price hike and thanks for bringing it to light that it has even less quantity than the other lipglosses! yikes. I actually want two but with that price I think i’ll just pick one…. its hard to choose though! Thanks for the clse up swatches. it made it a lot easier for me to decide. At the shop I didnt want to apply directly on my lips and it would have been hard to try on the different colors cuz after a while ur lips go numb/redder than usual.
The product itself isn’t poor quality, and the gloss has a great texture, but the price gets me. Price and less quantity… yeah, not fun! But you could get one and not need tons 😉
Sarah
ooh.. i got fashion scoop and partical to pink (should get them hopefully on monday, i’m loving the look of melt in mouth, boy bait and creme anglais! seriously!!
i know many people are skeptical about these, but i always wear sheer glossy colours on my lips and besides i hate traditional mac lipglasses, they’re teeny little things, i go weak-kneed at the idea of bigger sized containers (even though they scandalously contain less product), i’m fickle, it’s all about packaging… and i love the idea of these!
Ooh, glad you were able to pick up some! The price is just too high for a MAC gloss, especially since it’s way less 😛 I got no beef with lipglass packaging personally, so that helps!
Sarah
I’m actually loving mine and will go back for more. I suppose this substantiates how everyone is different. These tick all the bozes for me. I just like easy breezy, translucent/sheer pinky/nudey colours, non-sticky gloss, that I slick on with my eyes closed (doe-foot applicator helps) and kind of flatters. If I’m genuinely charmed by the product I don’t mind forking out that wee bit extra.
The thign with lipglasses and their micro size, is i think back to buying a sean john unforgivable fragrance and with it i got three gorgeous lipglosses and they were the same size as mac lipglasses. So psychologically I don’t see the point in buying things in ‘freebie’ sizes. I’m weird, I know. 🙂
That is weird, considering you get more product with the lipglasses than the cremesheen glasses so the cremesheen glasses feel like samples to me!
It’s not really about paying more for a product, it’s about the price being very different from MAC pricing in general. The majority of their lip products are $14, maybe $14.50–even new ones that have come out, up until dazzleglass. I pay $27 for lipgloss, but it’s Chanel and I expect that–I don’t expect MAC to do that.
Darla
Yeah but aren’t these cheaper than those sticky dazzleglasses?
ugh I would love to go and buy Petite Indulgence and Melt in Your Mouth but honestly, I just don’t think these lipglasses are worth CAD$21 each — I only purchased Boy Bait… seems like it’s a good nude gloss to go over any kind of lipstick… but it kind of reminds me of C-Thru, which is a perm.. and is cheaper…
You look great in all of them! And I do see a difference between Fashion Scoop, Partial To Pink and Ever So Rich ^^
I want them all….. but only Partial To Pink, Boy Bait, Ever So Rich and Fashion Scoop seems to be left
i have the Mac cremesheen glass in right image and its such a goergous babie pink! its great by itself and i dont even need a lipstick! super hydrating and i will mind it with my life 🙂
If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!
im lovin petite indulgence, melt in your mouth & looks like sin 🙂
are these LE? i hope not!
my mac counter never had these out yet!
🙁
Yes, all the glosses are LE!
yea sadly they are Limited Edition BUT they sell them at an online makeup store called http://www.allcosmeticswholesale.com/. maybe you’ve heard of it, its like an online CCO. hope that helped
Hey! Do you have a makeupalley account? I’m swapping those lipglosses on my account! If you’re interested the account name I’m under is: Iheartcaliocean 🙂
i think looks like sin better on with creme in your coffee…i should have gotten melt in your mouth! waaaaaa….
Creme In Your Coffee is SO pretty! I’m totally impressed by it.
Petite Indulgence is the one I got… so very pretty!
That was one of the better ones to get 😀
Creme anglaise is gorgeous on you. I don’t know if I should get Petite Indulgence, it is pretty but expensive.
Thanks, Miss QQ! 🙂 It’s pretty, and I don’t really think it’s worth $18.
Thank you soooo much 😀
You’re very welcome 🙂
they all look the same lol I like the looks like sin tho!
LOL! They’re similar, but not quite THE same… not HK the same.
Ugh, I have to say I really don’t like them. 🙁
Their texture is what sells them, since the colors are just so sheer.
I heart the texture of these. I got Petite Indulgence to wear over Lickable and Melt in Your Mouth to wear on their own. I think its hard to find opaque glosses like these with no shimmer or duochrome – they are really pretty.
For me, they’re not opaque at all, which is why they’re not my fave :/ The price also grates on my nerves.
maybe opaque’s not the right word…milky maybe? i have lighter lips than yours. but i think its definitely hard to find glosses without a ton of bells and whistles (like lots of different colored shimmer, etc) with this kind of texture – which is why i liked these and find them a fun alternative to my other glosses. they also just look gorgeous in that packaging – AND i love that they have the doe foot applicator 🙂
I like the bells and whistles, haha! That must be why I just can’t get over the price of these and love ’em.
I might get Petite Indulgence, but in general they don’t blow me away & what you mentioned about the pricing makes them even less attractive.
We shoulda boycotted and said price it normal!
I mean, give me lipglass packaging and make it $14 😉
I’m happy with the singular Boy Bait I have. The price is irritating even if the texture is nice. It looks very similar to Partial to Pink! Tisk tisk.
Yeah, I definitely think one is really all you *have* to own. If you love yourself some sheer, milky gloss with no shimmer… these are definitely great. I’m fine with $18 a pop if it was a brand that I’d expect it from – NARS, MUFE, Stila, etc. Not MAC.
-sigh- Oh, Looks Like Sin, how I USED to adore you. Your online swatch was so inviting, with its dark vibrancy; but now, I can only loathe you. Shame, for shame.
Yeah, it sheers out quite a bit. For me, the fact that it bleeds instantly is a total turn off.
Christine – how are they compared to the latest YSL lispticks (forgot the name), lemming lickable. are they lasting?
They last just fine, but compared to Rouge Volputes? Different animal. These aren’t creamy at all.
Thanks for the swatches Christine!
what do u think would be a good dupe for boy bait? i want it but i cant bring myself to spend CAD$21.50 for less the product!! makes me so mad! and, doesnt it look like the lipgloss kinda settles into the spaces in your lips? i noticed that when i tried it in store too.
To be honest, you could try a lipgelee (maybe Saplicious) if you want the texture but more for your money (0.5 oz for $14!) or Plushglass in Wildly Lush.
Some of them definitely do that!
I just tried these today since I heard they weren’t going to be as stick as other MAC glosses. I was skeptical, but they really aren’t! I bought Creme Anglaise, which is great for someone like me who doesn’t wear that much color on the lips. I wish it had a brush aplicator instead of a doe foot, though.
They’re really not sticky at all, huh? Very nice for those who aren’t lovin’ lipglasses ’cause of the sticky factor.
Lipgelees are also a great non-sticky lip product by MAC. Oh, and Tendertones!
Nope! And I can’t take *any* stickiness lol.
PS: Creme Anglaise looks amazing over Freckletone lipstick…
Ohh, thanks for the tip, Leah!
Whoa, boybait looks gorgeous. I was thinking of skipping on these because of your review but boybait really does look fairly gorgeous (sadly with a heavy application, but oh well!)
It’s not that they’re a bad product per se (if you don’t mind sheer colors), the price just bugs me so much!
No harm in getting one, right? ;P
Boybait seems nice – very nude-ish!!!
I’ve never been much of a fan of any lippie that wasn’t nude (my lips are already tinted enough!!) but for once I’d like to own Petite Indulgence – a very bubble gum pink (to me anyway).
Its been REALLY hard for me to find lipglosses without any shimmer and glitter so I’m actually excited. I did swatches cuz it was out here in Asia much earlier on but I never realized it was shimmer-less until I read about it. However, I have to say I am concerned about the negative reviews on the lipglosses. 🙁 And yes, i did notice the price hike and thanks for bringing it to light that it has even less quantity than the other lipglosses! yikes. I actually want two but with that price I think i’ll just pick one…. its hard to choose though! Thanks for the clse up swatches. it made it a lot easier for me to decide. At the shop I didnt want to apply directly on my lips and it would have been hard to try on the different colors cuz after a while ur lips go numb/redder than usual.
The product itself isn’t poor quality, and the gloss has a great texture, but the price gets me. Price and less quantity… yeah, not fun! But you could get one and not need tons 😉
ooh.. i got fashion scoop and partical to pink (should get them hopefully on monday, i’m loving the look of melt in mouth, boy bait and creme anglais! seriously!!
i know many people are skeptical about these, but i always wear sheer glossy colours on my lips and besides i hate traditional mac lipglasses, they’re teeny little things, i go weak-kneed at the idea of bigger sized containers (even though they scandalously contain less product), i’m fickle, it’s all about packaging… and i love the idea of these!
Ooh, glad you were able to pick up some! The price is just too high for a MAC gloss, especially since it’s way less 😛 I got no beef with lipglass packaging personally, so that helps!
I’m actually loving mine and will go back for more. I suppose this substantiates how everyone is different. These tick all the bozes for me. I just like easy breezy, translucent/sheer pinky/nudey colours, non-sticky gloss, that I slick on with my eyes closed (doe-foot applicator helps) and kind of flatters. If I’m genuinely charmed by the product I don’t mind forking out that wee bit extra.
The thign with lipglasses and their micro size, is i think back to buying a sean john unforgivable fragrance and with it i got three gorgeous lipglosses and they were the same size as mac lipglasses. So psychologically I don’t see the point in buying things in ‘freebie’ sizes. I’m weird, I know. 🙂
That is weird, considering you get more product with the lipglasses than the cremesheen glasses so the cremesheen glasses feel like samples to me!
It’s not really about paying more for a product, it’s about the price being very different from MAC pricing in general. The majority of their lip products are $14, maybe $14.50–even new ones that have come out, up until dazzleglass. I pay $27 for lipgloss, but it’s Chanel and I expect that–I don’t expect MAC to do that.
Yeah but aren’t these cheaper than those sticky dazzleglasses?
No, they’re the same price!
ugh I would love to go and buy Petite Indulgence and Melt in Your Mouth but honestly, I just don’t think these lipglasses are worth CAD$21 each — I only purchased Boy Bait… seems like it’s a good nude gloss to go over any kind of lipstick… but it kind of reminds me of C-Thru, which is a perm.. and is cheaper…
No, they’re definitely not worth it :/
I like Looks like Sin and Creme Anglaise. They are beautiful on you!!!!
Thanks, Rosie!
Fashion Scoop looks really good over mac snob lipstick!!!!
Thanks for the tip, Allison!
You look great in all of them! And I do see a difference between Fashion Scoop, Partial To Pink and Ever So Rich ^^
I want them all….. but only Partial To Pink, Boy Bait, Ever So Rich and Fashion Scoop seems to be left
Thanks! 🙂
i have the Mac cremesheen glass in right image and its such a goergous babie pink! its great by itself and i dont even need a lipstick! super hydrating and i will mind it with my life 🙂