MAC Archie’s Girls Collection Photos & Swatches (Preview)

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

While I work on editing photos, testing products, and writing up reviews, here are some photos and swatches in the meantime. Oh — and here’s something that’s funny and GREAT news for you: I received press samples at lunch time, and all the products I ordered yesterday are out for delivery today (but haven’t arrived yet!) — so I have a ton of duplicates, which means we’ll be having a massive Archie’s Girls giveaway with the products I bought. Cheers all around! Β (Please hold questions until I’ve had a chance to review.)

P.S. — I am still waiting four nail polishes and a few of the accessories, but otherwise, I think this is 90% of it!

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Archie’s Girls Collection

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Betty Bright Lipstick

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Girl Next Door Lipstick

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Oh, Oh, Oh Lipstick

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Kiss & Don’t Tell Lipglass

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Stay Sweet Lipglass

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Summer Sweetheart Lipglass

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Flatter Me Pearlmatte

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Flatter Me Pearlmatte

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Cream Soda Blush

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Black Swan Pearlglide Eyeliner

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Lord It Up Pearlglide Eyeliner

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Caramel Sundae Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Caramel Sundae Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Caramel Sundae Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Caramel Sundae Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Lucky in Love Pigment

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Cheers My Dear Pigment

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Boyfriend Stealer Lipstick

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Daddy’s Little Girl Lipstick

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Ronnie Red Lipstick

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Feelin’ So Good Lipglass

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Mall Madness Lipglass

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Strawberry Malt Lipglass

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Veronica’s Blush Pearlmatte

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Veronica’s Blush Pearlmatte

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Prom Princess Blush

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Designer Purple Pearlglide Eyeliner

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Petrol Blue Pearlglide Eyeliner

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Spoiled Rich Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Spoiled Rich Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Spoiled Rich Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Spoiled Rich Eyeshadow Palette

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Magic Spells Pigment

MAC Archie's Girls Collection
MAC Black Poodle Pigment

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

About the Reviewer

Reviewer

Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). For more matches, please read our full Foundation FAQ. For more information on our review process, please read our Review FAQ.

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

83 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Thank you so much Christine, I can’t wait to see you try them on you. Betty’s products look amazing neutral palette and coral blush are my favorite. Betty bright lipstick is so pretty.

Soooooo happy to finally see your swatches of this collection Christine! One question though, are the two photos of Veronica’s Blush Pearlmatte supposed to be exactly the same?

THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU!
I took the risk to wait for your swatches before ordering! I had major doubts about how these would look (esp. since Im a few shades darker). Now I can shop πŸ™‚

I had Ronnie Red ready to go, but it sold out right before I made my purchase. πŸ™ I bought Ruby Woo instead. Black Poodle is more glittery than I anticipated, but that’s OK. Seeing your swatches, I now wish I had added a couple more things.

Already bought Oh Oh Oh lipstick but want the Betty Bright and Daddy’s Little Girl and a few other things maybe but those lipsticks are sold out πŸ™ Will wait for reviews for the others. Great swatches as always Christine!

oooh i’m curious to try the cream soda blush but i’m not sure how it would look on me :/ could you maybe do a look with it? I have a similar skin tone/hair color as you!

Im afraid the eyeshadows will be a miss like the LE ones from the newest collections πŸ™ And also oh oh oh lipstick does not look like the one from mac me over at all!! the new one is much more brown than the one i have which is more plum

The onlt items I would buy are the two black pigments, it’s not the prettiest collection i’ve seen from MAC (i dont think any will ever be as pretty as fall colour 2011 was!!)

Can’t wait for March: I want either the Flatter Me Pearlmatte or the Cream Soda blush. Never cared for Archie, but I love the packaging.

Great swatches as always! I can’t wait to get Ronnie Red & Betty Bright in the mail! I wish the swatches I looked at yesterday were as good as yours…I definitely would have ordered Daddy’s Little Girl!

I don’t get it…Why don’t you just return the make up you bought for this collection, if you have the sample press given to you….Why are you wasting your money, I don’t understand…..!!!!

I’m giving it away to readers! πŸ™‚ I normally buy several extras from each collection to giveaway, so it’s just an extra special giveaway!

id love ronnie red too..its my sons name. πŸ™‚ but im wondering if it is ronnie and not reggie? when i looked on the archies girls site…i saw the name reggie. because the two names are known together im wondering if the lipstick is meant to be reggie, and on here is a misprint. maybe im wrong.

MAC Betty Bright Lipstick is a pretty coral pink color. ^^

Boyfriend Stealer doesn’t look as pigmented as the other two lipsticks below it. I think I might like how sheer it is if it is still buildable. I don’t usually wear dark colors like it.

Thank you for the swatches! ^^

Aaaaaand I just ordered Veronica’s pigments and am *seriously* considering a LE brush set, which I never ever do. I want Lucky in Love as well but I think that’s potentially more dupeable. Buying MAC since ’98 and those are the first pigments I’ve ever bought.

I wanted to get Daddy’s Little Girl but it had already sold out when I went to purchase it last night. At least I got Boyfriend Stealer though. It looks beautiful!

omg oh oh oh lipstick is awesome, I love it! I got it from make me over collection and been loving it! Ronnie red and Daddy’s Little Girl lipstick looks so pretty! I will look into that and I might get them :p Girl next door looks interesting πŸ™‚

I can’t wait to receive my goodies! I’ve been hauling like crazy with MAC collections lately so I made this one a small haul. I ordered Daddy’s Little Girl, Betty Bright, Mall Madness and Kiss & Don’t Tell. Can’t wait for the reviews!

I am looking forward to your review of these products. I have all of my items on hold and awaiting your review to see if I actually want to purchase them. Several items appear to be repromos. For instance, the Betty quad..I already have Dreammaker(plus a backup)and Showstopper(have backup), the pink looks like venus and the carmel sundae looks like Modelette. Betty Bright reminds me of Watch me simmer and the coral lipglasses looks like something I have seen before. Like always, you are wonderful.

Uggh I love and want everything!

I would love to see the comparisons of Daddy’s Little Girl to Up The Amp, Heroine, Nocturnal Instinct and Strong Woman. That might be the only one I don’t need since I have all the others. :/

Can’t wait for your reviews. πŸ™‚

I know these are your press samples and not the stuff you actually ordered but I was wondering…Were you able to order the Black Swan and Lord it Up Pearlglides? I was so excited b/c those are my favorite liners and I wanted to order a couple in the LE packaging but they are not on the website! I chatted with a rep last night and they said it should be up soon…Just wondering if anyone else had the same issue! Thank you for the swatches!!

Hi Stacy!

I reached out to MAC PR specifically after seeing them go in and out of stock and when the Pearlmattes were in stock, the pencils were out! And then they were gone. I had already bought everything except the two Pearlmattes and the two missing Pearlglides, so I kind of begged MAC to please, please send those to me so I could review everything at once. So in short: the two missing Pearlglides in the LE packaging were press samples. I wasn’t able to nab those two online – but I did see all four in stock at one point (I had the two missing ones in my cart) but then they went MIA again.

Thank you so much for your help Christine! I’m glad they were able to send you everything! I will keep checking to see if they go back up. If not, I will just try to grab some at the counter…I guess it really is a serious tech issue since they are going in and out of stock like this! Thank you for the pics and the giveaway also!

I was looking like crazy for the Black Swan Pearlglide Eyeliner but never saw it online at all. At least not part of the collection. I assumed it wasn’t released. πŸ™

First of all you are awesome for planning a giveaway with your extras. Not that you don’t do that kind of thing all the time, but I just want to reiterate that it’s really cool of you to do it. Second, I am SO happy looking at your swatches, I feel like I really made the right choices in the items I ordered yesterday. I’m especially excited for the Veronica’s Blush Pearlmatte.

Why whenever a makeup brand comes out with a very dark lipstick that looks like it’s going to be amazing, they always cop out and make is super sheer…….I was SO looking forward to Boyfriend Stealer and hoping it would be a nice opaque colour, but now I am just super disappointed with it. At least the eyeliners looks nice.

I know exactly how you feel. Veronica is a no apologies lipstick kinda girl and if she’s gonna do some boyfriend stealin’ I imagine she would go opaque or go home.

I’m going all out, all six lipsticks, both pearlmates, both blush and my biggest treat for myself I ordered the brush set. That is a beautiful collection I love the light approach its classic just like Betty and the white is so clean looking I just love it!

on a side note I have to say that guy they have to model for the Archie character is very creepy, I think the double pierce hoop earrings were a very bad idea, ruined the whole concept of Archie Comics character πŸ™‚

The eyeliners, glosses and pigments look pretty but the blushes and eyeshadows….. I am not at all impressed. They don’t seem at all pigmented.

I never realized how much of a “Betty” girl I am. After going over your pics I wish I had order the lipsticks sooner. I got the OH OH OH lipstick, the others were sold out. I also got the Betty eyeshadow quad and the adorable mirror. I will stop by my local MAC store and Macy’s to see if I can get those lipsticks.

Another mixed bag.

The pigments are pretty – but I’ll never go through enough of them to justify buying them and I already own the Pearlglide liners (love ’em). I was interested in Spoiled Rich, but not so much now after seeing the swatches. I’ll have to wait for the review, but it looks like they continue to have quality issues in the palettes. Sigh.

When I first saw the press release for this collection I wasn’t that excited, but now that I’ve seen the swatches I’m definitely interested! I haven’t really been buying any MAC lately, mostly because by the time I get to the counter they are sold out of whatever I want a buy (not always a bad thing, I’ve saved a TON of money) so I hope that I get lucky this time and pick up something from this collection!

I was so worried this afternoon, everything on the Canadian website was sold out! They must have restocked because I just ordered Oh Oh Oh lipstick, Strawberry Malt lipglass and the Caramel Sundae palette! This is one happy girl πŸ˜€

I adore this collection, it’s really cute. I have been anticipating it for sometime and was lucky enough to be online when it was released. I think this was one of my largest purchases. I managed to buy the lipsticks I really wanted like Girl Next Door, Betty Bright, Daddy’s Little Girl & Ronnie Red. I am fighting the urge to buy Cheers My Dear pigment. I really want it but I already bought Lucky in Love & Magic Spells. Too many lovelies…haha.

It looks very hit and miss, as per usual! Some things look STUNNING, others meh, or downright BAD. I was intriuged by the Betty Blush, Cream Soda, but by looking at the swatch I think it would wash me out!

You’re a STAR, by the way!! Can’t tell you enough how much I enjoy this website!

Nothing in this collection really interested me, but now I’m sort of interested in a few of the lipglasses. I wish I could remember what lipglasses feel like on the lips, it’s been six years since the last time I wore a lipglass (and I think that was a lustreglass I wore back then not a lipglass).

Hi, I was just wondering would you say that boyfriend stealer or oh oh oh lipsticks could be close dupes for the LE Evil queen Sinister lipstick?

Im going to wait for your proper reviews on the Pearlmate and Betty Bright, I kinda want to know if its slightly comparable with Vegas Volt because I don’t want to rush haha =) thanks for this Christineeeee <3

Don’t get me wrong, I’m a huge Mac fan. However, nothing in this collection speaks to me, Betty’s side is much too light for my tastes, and Veronica’s is way too dark for me to comfortably wear. Betty Bright is all I’ll look at, and it will most likely be sold out anyways. I’m going to skip (even though I love the packaging and Archie) and purchase from their permanent line instead. In the early promo info for this collection, it seemed they were releasing blackline pearl glide in this, but it seems they just got the color description wrong and it was black swan instead. This does make me a little sad πŸ™

Wow, for all my bitching about the whole Archie collection holding no real significance for non-Americans, this is a really nice collection! I can see myself buying a lot from it!! ^_^;

I received my order from MAC yesterday. I was so excited for it to show up, but now that I’ve seen it in person, I think I’ll be returning the majority of it unused. The Betty e/s quad, blush & Summer Sweetheart Lipglass are way too similar to shades I already have to justify the expense.
I love the Veronica e/s quad colours but at age 32, I feel too old to wear such vibrant colours ;}
But on the “bright” side, I really like the Betty Bright lipstick πŸ™‚

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! πŸ™‚ If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!