Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette Review, Photos, Swatches

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette ($58.00 for 0.332 oz.) contains six eyeshadows and two cheek colors. Everything about this palette was a disappointment. It’s a bit like wearing a bunch of faded, barely-there eyeshadows that just make your natural lid look muddied, dreary, and powdery. Both cheek colors were stiff and required a spatula to scrape off color to get anything to show up in a swatch, but I couldn’t get either to visibly appear on my cheeks. The eyeshadows are very soft and powdery, and unfortunately, most of them blend away to poor versions of themselves in practice. I was a bit surprised, because it swatched better than anticipated, but it was a mess trying to use this. The only way to salvage it would be use to a white, tacky/creamy base. The only nice thing about this is the packaging, which has “water’ droplets on the exterior (exactly like MAC’s Alluring Aquatic collection).

Mist is a muted, light-medium green-teal with strong gray and cool undertones. It had a satin finish. It had decent color payoff but was so soft that it sheered out to semi-sheer coverage. It was noticeably faded after five hours of wear. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Fog is a light-medium, khaki green with subtle, warm undertones and a satin finish. The texture was soft yet powdery enough that it tended to blend away to a rather sheer, faded color applied to the lid in practice. It wore well for five and a half hours on me. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Storm is a muted, overcast green with subtle, warmer undertones and a satin finish. It had semi-opaque color coverage but was prone to sheering out to a very faded, sheerer version of itself. It only wore well for six hours on me. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Wind is a soft, muted pink-lavender with hints of gray and a subtle, warmer undertone and a matte finish. The color payoff was mostly opaque, but it had a somewhat powdery texture that made it difficult to keep at that intensity–it wanted to sheer out almost instantly. It lasted for six hours on me. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Purple Rain is a cool-toned, purple-gray with a semi-matte finish. It had so-so pigmentation with a soft texture that was somewhat powdery. It was faded within six hours. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Cloud is a muted, medium-dark gray with cool undertones and a matte finish. It was powdery, semi-sheer, and lasted a mere five hours on me. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Sunset (Cheek Color) is a pink-peach with subtle warm undertones and a satin finish. I had to chip away at the pan’s surface to dislodge product with a metal spatula, because the surface was so firm and hard that it nearly felt like plastic. What I managed to scrape away ended up being chalky, powdery, and dry. I couldn’t get it to show up on my skin tone, but I did see a slightly chalky cast in person, though it seemed to disappear nearly instantly, because it was gone less than an hour later. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Earth (Cheek Color) is a medium-dark reddish brown with a satin finish. It had a similarly hard surface that required scraping to get any product out of it for swatching. It was powdery, dry, prone to fading, and incredibly difficult to blend on the skin. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Mist Eye Color
Laura Mercier Mist Eye Color

Laura Mercier Mist Eye Color
Laura Mercier Mist Eye Color

Laura Mercier Fog Eye Color
Laura Mercier Fog Eye Color

Laura Mercier Fog Eye Color
Laura Mercier Fog Eye Color

Laura Mercier Storm Eye Color
Laura Mercier Storm Eye Color

Laura Mercier Storm Eye Color
Laura Mercier Storm Eye Color

Laura Mercier Wind Eye Color
Laura Mercier Wind Eye Color

Laura Mercier Wind Eye Color
Laura Mercier Wind Eye Color

Laura Mercier Purple Rain Eye Color
Laura Mercier Purple Rain Eye Color

Laura Mercier Purple Rain Eye Color
Laura Mercier Purple Rain Eye Color

Laura Mercier Cloud Eye Color
Laura Mercier Cloud Eye Color

Laura Mercier Cloud Eye Color
Laura Mercier Cloud Eye Color

Laura Mercier Sunset Cheek Color
Laura Mercier Sunset Cheek Color

Laura Mercier Sunset Cheek Color
Laura Mercier Sunset Cheek Color

Laura Mercier Earth Cheek Color
Laura Mercier Earth Cheek Color

Laura Mercier Earth Cheek Color
Laura Mercier Earth Cheek Color

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette
Laura Mercier Watercolour Mist Eye & Cheek Palette

173 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Carrie Avatar

I remember being super excited for this palette when the pics came out.

Then I saw Dustin Hunter’s review and completely lost any and all interest – such poor quality product in such a tiny compact for $60?! Criminal!

I still am bummed about it though, because I love the concept. I may go dupe hunting instead!

Sara@ColorMeLoud Avatar

Hi Christine,
I have this palette and I am really loving it. I use it without any white base and it shows perfect on my eye lids, which are deeper than my complexion. I also like the idea of moodier pastels, like a rainy spring day, very pretty and unique. I am wondering if your product had worse quality than mine and was from another batch.

Chelle Avatar

Oh JEEZ! I was so looking forward to this palette too since I’ve fallen rather madly in love with the textures of Laura Mercier’s eyeshadows in her Artist palettes. As you said, the swatches aren’t bad, but when I see them on your eyes I can’t figure out what’s what. What a disappointment!

(However, thank you so much for reviewing the palette, you just saved me the splurge!)

Sunny Avatar

Ugh wow, you’re right: the palette looks miserable on the eyes! I wonder if a primer would help (which I systematically wear because I don’t have a choice), but then again the colors don’t really speak to me to begin with anyways.

Aline Avatar

This is crazy! I don’t understand why they released this. Their artist palette from 2013 is fabulous and one of my favorites. I hope they’re not going down the Bobbi Brown palette road.

Adhishree Avatar

the funny thing is, like you said, they swatch quite well so after I read your review i’m thinking “huh.. that is odd” but then they barely showed up on your lid! overall, the colour selection isn’t appealing to me either. I don’t know what they were thinking when they were coming out with this palette. I mean is there a NEED to bring out new products just for the sake of bringing out new products?

Katherine T. Avatar

Oh, no! I see you bought this yourself. I had swatched these in store, and they were absolutely horrible. I was rubbing and rubbing my fingers across the shadows and could only get a little bit of pigment to show up. The blushes were even worse, was like rubbing plastic. Thinking I got a bad batch, I even went to another store to test another kit -same thing. So sad. Absolute worst kit I’ve come across – you have better luck buying makeup at the dollar store. I loved the fog/mist theme and the droplets on the packaging are so beautiful, but the product should never have made it to market.

Donna Avatar

In photos this palette looked quite pretty. But after seeing in real life, its dull and boring. I usually love Laura Mercier palettes, but the last few have missed big time. Have gone for the new By Terry Eye Design Palettes instead.

Katherine T. Avatar

OMG, I can’t believe you used 5 of 6 shadow colors and there’s barely anything showing up on your lids! I thought you had used only 1 color. This might win one of those most disappointing products prizes.

Aditi Avatar

I thought this palette was so pretty when I first saw it, but I was also quite disappointed because it didn’t seem to be suitable for darker skins. I don’t feel so bad now since the quality isn’t there, lol.

Christina D. Avatar

I’m sorry, Christine, but I’m hoping you got a “dud” because I ordered this when I saw all those lovely, muted colors. I can’t resist cooler, gray based shades and these are about the closest to pastel as I get. It seems like a nice, albeit safe, change from all the nude and natural palettes, but I am crossing my fingers that it performs better than the one you used.

xamyx Avatar

This is definitely a palette for the fairest end of the spectrum-which isn’t a *bad* thing!-, and with a bot of primer/base I’m quite certain the shadows would perform much better, as they look like they swatch well… I also think it was designed to use a single shade as a wash, as they are all in the same tonal range. That said, I’ll still likely skip this one, since the cheek shades don’t suit me, but I do really like the eyeshadows.

Cindy Avatar

wow! Certainly expected more from this brand! The colors are so interesting- too bad they were a total fail! Maybe LM should recall this and re formulate! Thank you for the review and saving us money!

meganlisa Avatar

How awful! And it barely shows up on your lid. At that price point…wow. This review is a perfect example of why what you do it so helpful! I was eying this palette then got super busy and forgot about it. Thankfully so, it now seems.
Appreciate the honest review. Too bad you bought this one.!

Kate Avatar

I don’t know if you remember, but a while back in your “Temptalia asks you” feature, you asked what people would really like to see in a Spring collection. I said that I really wanted some eye shadows that were misty, like watercolours, instead of the usual pastels. So when I saw this, I was beyond excited. It was EXACTLY the sort of thing I’d been hoping for. So to say I’m disappointed is a major understatement.

Brian aka Roulette Avatar

I am not surprised by this at all…when the Laura Mercier rep in my store and I saw this for the first time, we both thought ‘What was she thinking?!?!’

It looks like a childs’ makeup palette from the ’80s…and performs like it too.

Katherine T. Avatar

I think the SAs were too embarrassed to even sell this kit. One of them had it tucked all the way in the back on a shelf, the others didn’t know about it, or tried to steer me to other products. They must not like dealing with all the unhappy customers and returns.

Andie Avatar

The packaging is beautiful, but the quality of those shadows and cheek colors is terrible. It makes me sad when high end brands put out something that under performs this much. For $58 I expect a lot more.

Mariella Avatar

Even IF the quality has been present in this palette, it’s like they’ve confused “Spring” with “dull, drab and washed out”. These colours are just depressing looking!

Veronica Avatar

I live in the American Northeast, and our spring is generally one long series of rain showers, so this was spot on as far as I was concerned. πŸ˜› I thought it would look particularly fetching on cooler skin tones.

Mariella Avatar

Ha – to me, that’s all the more reason for pretty, bright, “hopeful” colours. I’m in Canada – we have freakin’ blizzards in March but that doesn’t mean I don’t want Spring collections to look like there’s light at the end of the snow-drifts!

Brenda P Avatar

first thought “Oooh, pretty!!” then saw the words “disappointing” and thought “sigh, really?” then “dupe shopping!!!!” lol. Saves my budget!! Thanks Christine!!

beka Avatar

wow! usually when you give something an “F” you still manage to create a look that is at least decent. this looks truly awful! i don’t mind sheer/translucent eyeshadow, but this is just bad. i think i could rub chalk on my eyes and it would look better:D

Sarah Avatar

I’m not very experienced, but I don’t understand how it swatches reasonably decent, but just muddies up like that on the lid! I’ve had my colours blend together before, but not so much so that they were that unrecognisable! Weird!

fuji Avatar

I kinda wanna say, I knew it!

Years ago, I bought a NARS eyeshadow trio, with grey, shimmer green and shimmer cool-toned pink in there. That grey one gave me the same feeling that”my natural lid look muddied, dreary, and powdery.” That was a huge lesson learned and made me become cautious about pastel colors.

Kimmy Avatar

This definitely confirmed my suspicions. I almost, almost got this palette but I had this feeling it would not end well. When I was shopping the early Spring releases back in late December/early January, I saw it and was intrigued at first. Of course there were scarce reviews up so early, one that I saw was kind of positive but I could tell from the photos that hmmm, I wasn’t too sure…. thank goodness I listened to my instincts! πŸ™‚

Nicole Avatar

You should take it or send it back! A company should know when their product is bad so they can learn from their mistakes or they are going to go out of business eventually. You will be helping them out and it’s your right as an American consumer Christine. (;

Nicole Avatar

I respect that decision. I hatee returning! I get embarrassed for some reason.I have a ton of stuff I have been putting off returning. I almost have to pep talk myself beforehand. Its ridiculous because I obviously keep a ton more than what is returned!

Nancy T Avatar

Oh Lawd NO! If this looks this awful on you, and literally just about everything ALWAYS looks great on you, Christine, I cannot even begin to imagine how horrible this would be on me because my skintone is darker than yours, and these wouldn’t even show up on me except to make me appear to have not slept in over a week! Yikes!

Fran Avatar

This is a real shame, I would love some of these shades for spring if the quality was even decent! And I often love Laura Mercier eye shadows, even if some of them are a bit subdued for my taste! Too bad! I’m going to check out NARS Kamchatka and MUFE M110 for sure.

Denise Avatar

Ye Gads! How can a company that makes such fantastic caviar sticks for the eyes get it so wrong with this! (Although to be honest I’d never have been tempted because its got such a dreary selection of colours anyway. Makes me go Meh!)
What a shame…

Sylirael Avatar

Hehe, I still want this palette so badly!! It’s probably lucky that LM isn’t easily accessible here though, as I’m not really in a financial position to just buy a palette for the ‘concept’ at the moment πŸ˜‰

It’s a shame the execution is in such contrast to the concept/packaging. I wish high end makeup was the kind of thing that reliably went on sale, because then I would totally get this as a collector’s piece! The *colours* of purple rain, cloud and wind are just so lovely… SO FRUSTRATING! πŸ˜›

El Avatar

Wow. I am really, really glad I didn’t get this! I was tempted, but it’s much more desaturated than the colours I normally wear, so I was on the fence as to whether it would be interesting to play with because of that, or if it would just sit in a drawer. Now I know it isn’t worth the money.

I applaud your valiant effort to get enough applied to your eyes to even show up. That is so not the behaviour I would expect from a Laura Mercier eyeshadow, can’t believe these are SO bad. πŸ™

miekogirlie99 Avatar

i’ve been so on the fence about this one but now for sure I wont bother. thank you! BUT maybe if it goes on sale I’ll reconsider…hahaha

Genevieve Avatar

What a shame – I love subdued colours like this sometimes – but there is no excuse Laura Mercier! No matter how lovely the packaging is -the product has to be really good.
The colours in the swatches look insipid and boring. I really dislike matte finishes like this.
I can tell by your eye look Christine that very little of the colours reached your eyes.
Thank goodness we have you to help us save some money.

Laura Avatar

Yikes!

I personally love the idea and didn’t love the execution when I swatched it. I’m just surprised to actually see an F.

Glad to know it’s not just me.

Glad I saved my money for Guerlain and Tom Ford this season.

Jill Avatar

So sad. LM really has had some great spring collections in the past. FE the Orchid and Marekesh collections– were great. Hope they find their way back to greatness soon!

Lilac Avatar

Except for the Earth-toned blush, this palette would be my dream palette, colourwise. I was so happy to see that a brand would release these kind of colours, and even all in one set πŸ˜€ But I saw these kinds of blue tones recently in fashion photos, so perhaps we can hope they’ll become a trend for 2015 and other brands might follow suit. I would take an UD-palette with cool-toned depressing rainy-day-pastels anytime! ;))

Jenn Avatar

I know when I was a kid, watercolor paints sometimes did not have the best pigments. I think they did take the word “watercolor” too literally. (Color is washed away!) Thanks for the review and sacrificing ugh… $58 and a few hours to test before throwing the palette against the wall.