If you could only use one lipstick for the rest of your life, which one would you choose?


If you could only use one lipstick for the rest of your life, which one would you choose? Share!

Probably Guerlain Gems!

Thanks to Antonia for today’s questions! Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

118 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.

Harder than I thought!!! Ok, so if my lips stay full and young looking: MAC Maria Moretti (gorgeous red!) , but if they de-pouf: MAC Marque Ultimate Lipstick! And it gets even more difficult now that I’ve had an opportunity to try on a few Estee Lauder lippys ( the ones that DON’T smell like figs)….because they feel so nice on!

I would have to resurrect L’Oréal Tendre Mauve (the “regular”/original lipstick). In fact, it pretty much was the only lipstick I wore nearly every day for about 2 years, and was one of the few I actually finished (along with 2-3 backups…). It was the *perfect* blend of nude, pink, & mauve, with a faint hint of grey, and wasn’t too light or dark.

For something more recent, I’d have to say L’Oréal Frieda’s Nude, which is unfortunately LE…

I think it has to be Chanel’s Liberte Rouge Coco Shine! Its the best sort of peachy nude I own and because its permanent it beats my other favorites for that spot!

Have to start, again, by saying “Let’s hope it never never ever happens!” A girl SHOULD NOT be made to commit to only one lipstick, it’s too cruel 🙂 If it did, however, I”d most likely choose Japanese Maple or Hue by MAC, depending on how I feel at that exact moment 🙂

Hands down Kat Von D’s studded kiss lipstick in Lolita. It’s just the perfect rosy nude shade for my skintone and I really like how it adheres to the lips.

I like that I’ve been reading long enough to know your answer as soon as I read the question, Christine!

For me, I’d say Guerlain Garçonne – definitely not the most practical of choices, but it’s my favourite by far. I can live without MLBB shades, but I can’t do without Garçonne!

This is a cruelly difficult question to answer, because I love brights, but those shades don’t go with everything. Plus, wearing neon pink or blinding red to a funeral isn’t very cool, even by my liberal makeup standards.

I’d probably go with UD Sheer Revolution Lipstick in Sheer Rapture. It’s pretty pigmented on my ultra-pale lips, and I would consider it a MLBB shade. There are always lip glosses, tinted balms and pencils for my color fixes. 😉

Chanel Rouge Coco Venise. If I dab it on lightly it’s the perfect nude lip for my complexion, but if I swipe it on it’s a dramatic deep red. It’s an amazingly versatile lipstick.

This is a hard question. It would be a toss up between MAC Cream in Your Coffee (the perfect nude lip for a brown girl) and MAC La Vie En Rouge (if it wasn’t limited edition, I would wear it literally everyday).

I’m so mad I missed out on La Vie en Rouge, it’s so stunning. Here’s hoping they’ll re promote someday and we can all stock up!

They really need to make La Vie En Rouge permanent. I’m kicking myself for not buying a backup. (I did get Toxic Tale and Make Me Gorgeous, which are similar at least.)

Ohhhh, man! This question is hard. I have so many favorite lipsticks and not enough lips. Lol.
But, the “rest of my life lipstick” would have to be OFFSHOOT, by MAC. It compliments my skin tone so well, and I can wear it with practically anything.

I knew you’d say Gem! My most worn lipstick is MAC Relentlessly Red, so I’d say that. It just makes me feel so pretty and confident, and if I wanted a more neutral lip for a certain look I’d just go bare-lipped.

That’s a hard one! Either MAC Dubonnet, or Givenchy Framboise Velours. But then a nude would be easier to wear with everything… oh well, I’d wear bold lips every day!

Mac heroine would have to be my ride or die. It’s the perfect purple lip for ladies with bronzed and even deeply chocolate skin tones. The shade is permanent, price is doable, and the finish is so comfy. I will never get rid of it.

maybe i’ve been here for a while now that i knew that would be your answer lol, what a shame it’s discontinued, on you looks amazing. i’d love to test it on myself.

as for my answer… for a lipstick lover sticking to only one lippie would be too harsh but probably Nars Anita (im just in love with that formulation and the shade suits me really well) for practical pourposes you can’t go to a funeral rocking a purple lip either way i would gladly stick with it but i would miss a lot my Mac Heroine, Twig and Velvet Teddy… i would put more but the list would be too long (realizing now that im a lipstick addict)

i see a lot of you saying lolita by kvd and i’m really curious about it *puts on wishlist*

it could be easier if the question was ‘the 5 lipsticks you couldn’t live without’ LOL

NARS Walkyrie or Revlon Balm Stain in Honey…. or MAC Brick o La. These are the three I wear the most and are not LE. But, this is so hard… 😛

Airy Fairy by Rimmel! I have tried so many high end as well as drugstore lipsticks and this one is by far the most flattering on me.

Probably my day-to-day shade for the last few years, which is MAC’s Plumful. But it is so hard not to choose a bright red instead!

My choice would be Too Faced La Creme Lipstick in Cinnamon Kiss. Perfect blend of red, pink, brown and plum. Goes on like silk, wears like iron, and smells like lemon candy. And, an A-plus from Temptalia!

Kat von d studded lipstick, in hellbent a deep matte red ,lasts all day and doesn’t dry out my lips with great color payoff and little to no kiss marks on a drinking glass. I own 12 shades! My go to lip color ?

I’m torn between my classic cool red (which can look different depending on the liner and/or gloss) and a less buttery version of Revlon’s lip butter in Berry Smoothie (great pink for me).

Probably MAC Velvet Teddy because it just goes with pretty much everything, plus it’s matte without being super intense desert lips.

Such a hard decision! Especially when I still don’t think I have found my perfect shade yet, although MAC Notice Me and MAC Happy Hibiscus are both practically there!

If you highlight the text, then right click, you can choose “Search Google for…” and you can see pictures. Not as convenient as accompanying pictures would be, but not bad, either.

Still Lip Glaze in Brown Sugar, not really a lipstick, but everyone (including my husband and several makeup counter consultants from competing brands) compliment me on it. Just a “my lips, but better” nude on me. And long-lasting/pigmented enough to be in the lipstick “weight class”, I suppose.

This is a really tough one! I’d say Bobbi Brown Rich lip colour in Rose Blossom – its such a flattering shade – bright but not too bright! If i could cheat then I’d sneak in MAC La Vie en Rouge! Love the shade! Its such a happy shade!

Clinique Tenderheart. Basic, but polished. It is the only lipstick for me that works day or night; casual or formal; winter, spring, summer, or fall!

My choice would definitely be the versatile Marc Jacobs Le Marc Lip Creme in Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang. It’s the perfect semi matte, dusty rose that can be worn at the office and stays put all day with minimum reapplication. The color is also just vivid enough to wear out on the town in the evening! My lips are comfortable all day as this lipstick doesn’t dry out lips like a lot of mattes do, and it doesn’t settle into cracks, nor does it feather. All around a winner I will wear until it’s discontinued!

honestly i am not sure ! i am such a lip fanatic lol but this is a very interesting question :)…so only allowing one & i am really a colorful person but i would probably go with a neutral..& honestly i dont own many neutrals, so gosh i guess i would choose my mac ” i love winter ” from the iced delights but would have to find a dupe cause that was LE, wow just way too hard here , i bet i’ll think of something way better later 😛

Since it just arrived two days ago, I admit this may be a little premature. But Colourpop’s Sheer Lippie Stick in the shade “Juice Bar” is so unbelievably perfect for me, and so comfortable to wear, I could see myself happily living in it exclusively.

Probably MAC Go For It. It was limited edition (so I only have one tube left that I bought on eBay) and it’s a cremesheen finish so it has to be reapplied more often, but it’s a true cool pale-ish to midtone blue violet. I love that color; it goes great with my caramel brown skintone! 🙂

This would be a REALLY tough choice, but if I had to choose only one, I’d go with NARS Audacious lipstick in Kelly. It’s the perfect shade of reddish-pinkish-coral for me.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!