Archived Post

Best Makeup Brushes for Cream Eyeshadows

Best Makeup Brushes for Applying Cream Eyeshadows

When it comes to applying cream eyeshadow, synthetic brushes are my go-to as creams as natural hair brushes can soak up liquid and creams too much and produce either sheer or streaky results (and creams tend to necessitate washing often, and synthetics can take the extra washing easily).  I find a flat, synthetic brush is necessary for all-over lid application; a fluffy, dome-shaped brush key for diffusing crease color and applying creams to the brow bone; and a dome-shaped, denser brush for depositing pigmented color into the crease.

I would love to hear about the brushes you can’t live without for applying cream eyeshadow — share your picks in the comments! ๐Ÿ™‚

Applying Cream Eyeshadow to the Lid

When I’m using a cream eyeshadow on my lid, I consider whether I’m laying down a sheer wash of color (or that I’m applying it as a base for powder eyeshadow) or using it as a standalone lid shade.  Typically, for the latter, I’ll reach for a flat, synthetic brush, which will pickup product well, apply and pack the color on without diffusing the edges or reducing the intensity much.  For a sheer wash of color, a fluffier, dense, synthetic brush will work best for picking up a moderate amount of product but giving an airier application that makes for a good one-and-done all-over wash of color.

Best Makeup Brushes for Applying Cream Eyeshadows
MAC 242, IT 212, IT 322

  • MAC 242S Shader Brush ($25.00) is a flat, synthetic brush; works best for applying color all over the lid (a uni-tasker in my arsenal but one I keep multiples of on hand as it’s so good at what it does).
  • IT Cosmetics Essential Concealer Brush (212) ($22.00) is a small-to-medium sized, fluffy dome-shaped brush that has moderate density and a tapered, diffusing edge that works well for applying sheer washes of color all over the lid, diffusing and blending out crease color, as well as for laying down and blending out color applied to the brow bone.
  • IT Cosmetics All-Over Shadow Brush (322) ($26.00) is a medium-to-large sized, synthetic brush with a flat, dense shape that is good for applying color all-over to a larger area; it has a softer, more tapered edge compared to the MAC 242, so it can apply cream eyeshadows with more coverage but can also diffuse and sheer out cream eyeshadows.

Applying & Blending Cream Eyeshadow in the Crease

I’ve found that working with cream eyeshadows in the crease can be a little trickier, so I tend to apply as a two-step process with one brush to apply the color more precisely into the crease area with fuller coverage and then using a different, fluffier brush to diffuse and pull the color outward as necessary to get a subtle gradient.  For working with color above the crease and on the brow bone, I use the same, fluffier, dome-shaped brush that I use for blending in those areas.

Best Makeup Brushes for Applying Cream Eyeshadows
Urban Decay Moondust, Urban Decay The Finger, Makeup Geek Pointed Crease, Urban Decay Eyeshadow Contour, Urban Decay Tapered Blending

  • Urban Decay Moondust Brush (E210) ($24.00) is a small, dense synthetic brush with a fluffy, tapered edge that grabs eyeshadow well and can really pack it on while also having good movement and the ability to blend out edges without sheering out the eyeshadow too much.
  • Urban Decay The Finger Brush (F110) ($26.00 is a large, dome-shaped synthetic brush that works beautifully for diffusing crease color (also fab underneath the eyes for concealer) when a really diffused, sheer edge is desired (it’s larger, so it won’t work as well for any precision work).
  • Makeup Geek Pointed Crease Brush ($8.50) is a small, lightly fluffed, tapered crease brush with synthetic bristles that I love using for applying dense, more opaque color into the crease.  The tapered edge also can help to blend out edges, but I prefer something a little fluffier for that purpose and tend to use this solely for depositing initial color into my crease.
  • Urban Decay Eyeshadow Contour Brush (E211) ($22.00) is a medium-sized, domed-shape crease brush that fits well into the socket to lay down and blend out cream eyeshadow.  It’s particularly good for transition-type shades into the crease as well as the inner corner.
  • Urban Decay Tapered Blending Brush (E209) ($24.00) is a small-to-medium-sized, tapered blending brush with synthetic bristles.  It has a more pointed edge that has a flattened tip, so that it can apply color more precisely into the deeper crease but will not leave behind a harsh streak of color.



Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Jess Avatar

I own eye brushes from UD, IT Cosmetics, and MAC but my most used brush is the $3 ELF C brush. I love that thing and own several and ive never had any issues with shedding or falling apart even though I use them everyday and wash them every week. Writing this comment makes me want to pick up another one. I could never have enough. My second favorite would be the IT Cosmetics eye brushes…but they’re a distant second.

Nancy T Avatar

Obviously, I snoozed on yesterday’s brush post! But as for my favorite brushes for cream shadows, I absolutely love the ones I got from ColourPop! A few fluffy dome brushes that allow me to buff and blend crease and transition shades, plus a few flat shades of theirs that work almost as well as my fingertip. Although, in all honesty, I much prefer using my ring finger for lid application, and my pinky for inner corner highlight.

Eleanor Meister Avatar

it’s been a while since i’ve been to colour pop’s web site as i have lots of their products. didn’t know they sold brushes. thanks for the info. will go take a look at them.

Iron Maiden Avatar

I don’t use/like brushes for cream shadow application. IMO, they need to be warmed up to apply well, which i think is why many people don’t like cream shadows much. I use fingers and blend with an old-school wedge sponge if absolutely necessary. It’s fast, looks great, and all you have to wash are your hands.

Brenda C Avatar

I don’t wear a lot of cream shadows as my eyelids are so oily. But this info from you Christine is so interesting, I’m learning a lot and filing it away to use in the future. Thank you! I have a full set of Wayne Goss’s brushes and a full set of Rae Morris’s brushes which are natural hair brushes, but I also have some synthetic Sigma brushes that would work for cream shadows.

Rachael Avatar

Christine, I love the Chanel illusion Dโ€™ombres in Melody and wear it almost everyday. Itโ€™s that weird hybrid between cream and powder.
Iโ€™ve been using my fingers but sometimes thatโ€™s not the best, any recommendations for that type of formula?

Denise Avatar

Kudos to you Christine!!!! Great information on which brushes help to create beautiful makeup applications. I found it so interesting and useful because lately many of my brushes are just not making the grade.Thanks again and keep on posting. Best site ever.

CatG Avatar

This was really interesting for me to read because I never use brushes for cream eyeshadows! Most of my eyeshadows are powder, and the few cream eyeshadows I do have I just have always used my finger. I do sometimes use the Elf C brush though. I really want the UD finger brush!

Dominique Avatar

I actually haven’t done much eyeshadow blending with the UD Finger Brush. I have used it once or twice with cream shadows and I’ve been wanting to try it that way more but I mainly use it for really diffusing harsh lines in my nose contour between the highlight and blending cream highlighter down the nose. It’s a brush that is different from most of what I have so that is one of the reasons I really like it. I’ve used my UD brushes so much the numbers wore off mostly but they should have printed the writing on to them with something more visible. I love hearing your favorite brush choices Christine!

Ginny Avatar

My favorite brushes are my favorite, regardless of the type of product. I would still use the Morphe G17, MAC 217, and Real Techniques Base Shadow for creams. I find the 217 works great with MAC paint pots. ColourPop Shadows I just use my finger- I hate using brushes with those.

Ginny Avatar

Oh but I was wrong! Real Techniques Deluxe Crease brush. Dense and dome shaped, great for creams as it can really move them around. I never use it for powders because it’s too dense.

Tracey E. Avatar

Christine, thank you so much for these incredibly informative posts.

I am a regular cream shadow wearer and tend to use a MAC 242 or Bobbi Brown Cream Shadow brush. I’ve recently been experimenting with a MAC 217 and the discontinued WG 18, the latter of which applies cream shadows beautifully.

I prefer to use Charlotte Tilbury’s smudger brush with her cream shadows. It applies, diffuses, and even polishes her cream shadows to a reflective shine. The brush doesn’t achieve the same with cream shadows from other brands, though works well on the lower lash line across all cream shadows.

I’ll be looking into your recommendations and those suggested in the comments!

Tina Avatar

Your experience (what with testing and using thousands of eyeshadows) is invaluable. Thanks for the wonderful breakdown of brushes you use, and even specifically pointing out how the shadows are picked up/applied with the type of brushes, bristles, and shapes.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! ๐Ÿ™‚ If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!