Archived Post

MAC Cosmetics - In 3d Collection Review, Photos, & Swatches

IN 3D
Overall, I really enjoyed that MAC came out with two new formulations/products, because I like seeing innovation in the company’s repetoire. In terms of whether or not they’re products I can’t wait to have? I can wait a bit longer. The 3D Glass comes in numerous gorgeous colors, and they should be thought as similar to lipglass in terms of opacity and color payoff, but with the texture of a lip gelee and lustreglass. I sort of was reminded of the way Vaseline feels like on my lips when I put on Boundless. I did wish that there were some more opaque colors, especially since some looked so great in the tube, but quite sheer in use!

3D GLASS
Algorithm – This is a pretty purple, a very light version of Sexy Ray lipglass, sort of, with plenty of shimemr/glitter in it.
Apex – Very much an orange coral lip color, but easily sheered out and perfect for complimenting many lipsticks when paired with green looks.
Backlit – I have a thing for this color family, I think, very sheer, irridescent type glosses. I was briefly reminded of Vibrational lipglass (limited).
Boundless – Oh, how I fell in love with this color, just by sight. Sadly, I was a bit disappointed when I put it on my lips – quite sheer. It made my lips look slightly tinted, which is nice, but I guess I was hoping for a bit more color potency!
Energy – This just seemed really similar to Synched Up; kind of a pinkish coral with a lot of shimmer.
In 3D – A pinker coral than Energy/Synced Up, and way less orange than Apex. Pretty, but not too exciting – similar to Lychee Luxe lipglass with more pink.
Lightswitch – I just loved this one! I don’t particularly need to run head first to buy it, just because I have enough glosses similar to this, but it doesn’t keep me from wanting to make it an impuse buy. It’s like a pinker Luminary lustreglass!
Optical – Kind of dull, just didn’t catch my fancy, too muddied for me, I guess.
Racy – This is a really pretty pink color, and I imagine it makes for a lovely pink pout on the go.
Synched Up – As mentioned earlier, similar to Energy & In 3D; more pink glitter/sheen than Energy.
Touchpoint – A medium pink, which is sheer when swatched, so I picture this working mostly as a top coat on lipstick or as a very quick gloss for neutral days.
Wondershine – Pinks are always pretty, especially when they’re hot (the hotter the better, right?), but it was similar to Racy.


LIPGLASS PENCIL
Brickmate – A warm brown in color with a good consistency.
Coral Craze – The perfect coral liner for one of my favorite lipsticks, Mari-sheeno!
Fuchsia Lining – I like this color a lot, because it will work wonderfully with dark pink and plum lipsticks, without being over the top.
Neutralzone – This is definitely going to be a MLBB color for some people.
Part Nude – A deep medium brown, cool, unlike Brickmate.
Pink Edge – Another great MLBB liner color, and it reminded me of Sweetie cremestick liner.
Plum Mate – More pigmented lips might find this a MLBB color, but it is a great liner color for deep plum lip colors.
Red Stroke – A softer red liner, which will go well with all those red lipsticks I have hanging around. Might not be great with matte finishes (if intended to stay matte), since it is glossy.
Rosebound – A less saturated pink liner with enough lightness to make it wearable.


19 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Jessie Avatar

WOW! These look totally different on your skin than they come out on my lips… I suggest to everyone to TRY THEM OUT, they would be AWESOME over matte lipglosses (if you want to add some shine). I loved a lot of them actually.

They look much different swatched on skin than on the face though… so don’t jsut by just these pics (even though they are super pics :))

Christine Avatar

That’s odd, Jessie! They look pretty much exactly the way they look on my skin… on my lips! LOL! They’re about the same in color, just sheerer in consistency.

But thanks for sharing the tip! I always suggest people try things out if they can 🙂

Rosa Avatar

Are the pencils really that glossy? Hmmm. I’ll have to go check them out.

Oh and do you usually match your liner to your lip shade? I’ve seen people use a sort of neutral red for most shades and I was wondering which worked better.

Saundra Avatar

Hi, I was wondering which 3D glass you would recommend for Sunmetal lipstick. I have been using Moonbathe l/g but would like something else also. The one thing I like about Moonbathe is that it is sheer so the metalic look of Sunmetal still shows through. So I guess I want one that is sheer with shimmer, but to add a little color but still lets the Sunmetal show, if that makes any sense. I generally don’t wear anything too pink as it just doesn’t do well on me.
Thanks

Carrie Avatar

I finally got to my local MAC counter today, expecting to pick up Apex, and was surprised to find myself totally smitten with Energy. On me, it looks nothing like your swatch! (i’m an NW20 with fairly pigmented lips) It’s like a *very* gentle light coral-pink, very sheer, and goes great over the lipsticks and glasses I’ve tried it with so far (blankety, young spark, and my fave, florabundance) and makes them more flattering.

also, i really like the small applicator that these have. i think i’ll have to collect more…!

Janis Avatar

I’m not really fond of using different colored lip pencils coz they just don’t blend with whatever lipstick I use but I do use mac’s lip pencil in Spice and it goes well with whatever lipstick I use light or dark.
I’m still about to check out the collection but looking at the pictures, I’m drawn to the coral shades coz I’m so into Coral lipsticks right now…I’ll surely get either Apex or Energy.

Cristine Avatar

Hi, i was wondering wich 3D lip color should i get, i have red hair, brown/hazel eyes and fair skin but my lips are on the redish side, MAC tells me to go for wondershine but i think it does not look good at all! Maybe its because i dont usually wear anything on my lips.?

Thanks 🙂

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!