MAC Warm & Cozy Collection: Eyeshadows Reviews, Photos, Swatches

Date: Wednesday, December 23rd, 2009 Author:

MAC Warm & Cozy Collection
MAC Chamomile Eyeshadow

MAC Warm & Cozy Collection: Eyeshadows

Four brown-hued shades of eyeshadow debuted in the Warm & Cozy Collection. On my skin (probably around NC20 for the underside of my arm — which is where I do swatches), they were all fairly faint. You can see the color, but they’re obviously not ultra rich in pigmentation. I don’t think that makes them bad necessarily, they’re just softer shades and definitely should be used in conjunction with a base (e.g. Cuddle shadestick).

  • Chamomile is a pigmented light beige. Surprisingly, this was one of the more pigmented shades of the four. It would make an excellent all-over-lid shade or a highlighter. It’s like a beige-y version of Blanc Type.
  • Modelette is a softly shimmered medium brown. It’s decently pigmented, but it’s not at all intense (just to be sure).
  • Mulled Cider is a medium-dark red-tinged brown. It reminds me of a satin-finish Folie or Swiss Chocolate (and sheerer).
  • Embark is a dark, red-based brown with a matte finish. It swatches like garbage, and I really couldn’t tell you why. This is definitely one of those looks-better-in-use shades, though (I’ve owned Embark forever!).

MAC has a whole slew of amazing neutral eyeshadows in their permanent line-up. I don’t know if these would be the first browns I’d go-to, to be honest. I’d probably just check out their permanent range, because there really are some incredible shades available. (You can see my eight must-have MAC neutrals here.)

See more photos and swatches!

MAC Warm & Cozy Collection
MAC Modelette Eyeshadow

MAC Warm & Cozy Collection
MAC Mulled Cider Eyeshadow

MAC Warm & Cozy Collection
MAC Embark Eyeshadow

MAC Warm & Cozy Collection
MAC Eyeshadows: Chamomile, Modelette, Mulled Cider, Embark

33 thoughts on “MAC Warm & Cozy Collection: Eyeshadows Reviews, Photos, Swatches

  1. daphne says:

    Heh. They vaguely remind me of a poor man’s version of the Chanel Kaska Beige quad…for the same price as the quad too! :P The colors are pretty but yeah, I’ve got plenty of nice permanent browns and neutrals. Chamomile is slightly tempting, but probably not enough.

  2. KC says:

    I kinda like modelette now that I’ve seen the swatch, but when I saw the collection in person a couple days ago and I was really not impressed with it.

  3. Lucie says:

    Modelette and Milled Cider are beautiful and they actually suit my fair complexion.

  4. Sara says:

    Great swatches!! Thank you!!!

  5. claudia says:

    Well, I was waiting for your swatches, but I think I’ll skip those and get Warm Me Up instead !!!

  6. selva says:

    hey christine, if you could only pick one eyeshadow from this collection which one would it be??

  7. Jacquelyn says:

    I do like the swatch of Modelette! I do want to see the eyeshadows in person though.

  8. Heatherette87 says:

    I definately won’t be needing these.

  9. thanks for the swatches….
    i don’t need these though,….’meh’

  10. Olivia says:

    Hi Christine! I’m looking for a dark, matte brown. I was thinking Embark- do you think it’s the best choice or is there another MAC shadow you think would work better? Thanks a lot!

    • Christine says:

      I like Espresso, and I was going to say Brun, but apparently Brun is a satin. Embark is OK – I think I prefer a more neutral brown, just because the red undertones of Embark can throw a look off from time to time!

    • Sylvie says:

      Try Handwritten, it’s matte2, much better texture than regular mattes ;)

  11. amy says:

    These are pretty in person and I like the eyeshadows better than the love lace eyeshadows but I agree with buying permanent shades of neutral instead because these are not overly unique and there are definitely prettier and better ones in the permanent collection.

  12. cloudburst says:

    I like the colour of Mulled Cider but is it really sheer? Sheer & splotchy?

  13. Steffi says:

    I think I just want Modelette out of these if any eyeshadow at all

  14. Anitacska says:

    Nah.

  15. Miss_M says:

    I like Chamomile. I thought it was going to be more yellow (which looks awful on me), but this shade of beige makes a great addition to my collection.

  16. Lily says:

    Do You think Modelette would be a nice crease color on my NC30 skintone?

  17. Bridgette says:

    Ehh I think I will be skipping the eye shadows.

  18. Dance00000 says:

    hi ! I am interested in the “mulled cider” shadow but have a few questions. is it similar to mac’s “cork” shadow ? I want to find a crease color that is slightly darker than cork. Also, how much shimmer does it have ?

  19. Ra says:

    Hi Christine,
    I want to buy Modelette on Ebay because I see it online as a color between pink and brown. But in some pictures it looks rather caramelish (closer to Tete A-Tint). Could you help me with the color?
    Is it rather pink or does it have caramel/orangey hues to it?
    I know it is very personal. I will be responsible for my decission :)
    Thanks.

  20. tina says:

    i love chamomille. I have it and the pigmentation is excellent!!!