Sunday, February 5th, 2012

MAC Added Goodness Fluidline
MAC Added Goodness Fluidline

MAC Shop MAC, Cook MAC: Fluidlines

This collection features three new and limited edition shades of MAC Fluidline ($15.00 for 0.10 oz.). These shades include: Added Goodness (blackened mauve), Midnight Snack (soft black), and Wholesome (blackened brown). Fluidline is a gel eyeliner that’s supposed to be long-wearing and is housed in a small glass jar.

  • Added Goodness is a blackened-brown mauve that almost looks taupe in some lighting. There’s mauve, black, brown, and gray all mixed into a very interesting, complex shade that does retain some of that complexity even once applied. It’s dark and lines well, but it’s softer (and yet still has some intensity) compared to full-on black. It’s a lot like Bobbi Brown Black Mauve. Stila Starry is also similar, in liquid form, with more of a mauve look.
  • Midnight Snack is a deep, dark gray with silver shimmer. I couldn’t think of a dupe for this one — a lot of the gray eyeliners I have are much lighter.
  • Wholesome is a intense blackened brown with a natural sheen. It seems like it’s deeper, darker compared to Dip Down–more like if you mixed Dip Down and Blacktrack together.  MAC Avenue is cooler-toned, not as dark.

The majority of Fluidlines perform really well and live up to the brand’s claims. MAC’s form of gel eyeliner is easily one of the best on the market from my experience. The price point makes it very attractive, too. I’ve had many for years, and I haven’t had any problems with the product drying out over time. It’s a smooth, creamy formula that applies well with a stiff eyeliner brush to the upper lash line. I’ve also worn it as an eyeshadow base and on the lower lash line without problems.

The Glossover

product

MAC Shop MAC, Cook MAC Fluidlines Review, Photos, Swatches

A
Fluidlines are one of MAC's cult favorite products and for a good reason, because they work--they're long-wearing, creamy, pigmented, and apply seamlessly across the lid with an eyeliner brush.

Product

10/10

Pigmentation

10/10

Texture

9.5/10

Longevity

10/10

Application

4/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!

See more photos & swatches!

MAC Added Goodness Fluidline
MAC Added Goodness Fluidline

MAC Added Goodness Fluidline
MAC Added Goodness Fluidline

MAC Added Goodness Fluidline
MAC Added Goodness Fluidline

MAC Added Goodness Fluidline
MAC Added Goodness Fluidline

MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline
MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline

MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline
MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline

MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline
MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline

MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline
MAC Midnight Snack Fluidline

MAC Wholesome Fluidline
MAC Wholesome Fluidline

MAC Wholesome Fluidline
MAC Wholesome Fluidline

MAC Wholesome Fluidline
MAC Wholesome Fluidline

MAC Wholesome Fluidline
MAC Wholesome Fluidline

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase it? How much is it?

Online at MAC, $15.00 each. The release date is supposed to be February 9th for in-store.

Is it limited edition?

Yes.

Any dupes?

See individual shade reviews! :)

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

43 thoughts on “MAC Shop MAC, Cook MAC Fluidlines Review, Photos, Swatches

  1. Avatar of Chiara Chiara

    I love Added Goodness and Midnight Snack! I’m gonna check them out. Thanks for the swatches!

  2. Aamirah

    I have two Mac Fluidlines and both have dried out over time :( It’s a shame but I still think they’re amazing products!

    • Christina

      did you store them upside down in the original carton? and turned them upside down after dipping your brush in in between picking up colour? I did this from day1 and have had my black one for years now, no drying whatsoever.. maybe it helps!

  3. Avatar of HamnaH Hamnah

    how come theres no Canadian prices?

  4. MAC Fluidline is the liner that I swear by. I love the new Fluidline in Added Goodness – such a pretty metallic brown for brown eyed girls!

  5. Avatar of Laura Laura

    I think I need about a zillion backups of Added Goodness. I love the colour of BB Black Mauve but I don’t like the formula.

  6. Jennifer

    I love the look of Wholesome!

  7. Avatar of Gail Gail

    I love fluidlines – what do you think of Mightnight Snack w/the new NARS single Lhasa? Do you think thats the best choice – maybe with MAC’s Black Swan liner or the NARS grey pencil? I appreciate your opinions & thank you for all your advice.

  8. I really like Wholesome! :) thank you Christine for the swatches!

  9. Avatar of artemis artemis

    they look nice, especially the last one…like i could eat it, lol <3 mmm, looks like dark chocolate

  10. Grace

    Wholesome looks really nice. This collection is going to be so cruel to my wallet!

  11. Avatar of Sarah Sarah

    I think Added Goodness needs to be my first fluidline! I hope they’ll be in Debenhams/House of Fraser/Selfridges as well because I see all the stuff I want going instantly (as usual :().

  12. Jillian

    Really nice! Added Goodness is one I’ll pick up, I think. I love BB’s Black Mauve, but hate the price point for the gel eye liners! Since MAC’s work just as well and are cheaper, it’s a no brainer.

    Wholesome really reminds me of BB’s gel eyeliner in Espresso… not an exact dupe, but similar. Espresso is very matte, whereas Wholesome has a sheen to it. Color-wise though, similar I think!

  13. Avatar of Rebecca BeckBeck

    Oh man, I think I want all of them, and that’s not a good thing. (I’ve got a massive eyeliner stash already…)

  14. Added Goodness looks interesting! I just don’t know if it’s dark enough to bring my dark brown eyes out. Will get the SA to try it on me!

  15. Tracy

    oh wow ! I have to admit, I have never tried gel liners, not even liquid liners because i’m afraid that i don’t have a steady hand enough for application ! Added goodness is stunning ! Maybe I should try…

  16. I LOVE MAC Fluidlines. For basic shades (like black) there are plenty of good drugstore alternatives, like Physicians Formula or Essence, but for fun colors, MAC’s are reasonably priced and really good quality. I haven’t had any problems with mine drying out either. These new shades look beautiful–a little more fun than ordinary black or brown liner.

  17. Shannon

    I want all of these! I am addicted to MAC fluidlines! Will be purchasing all of these, very wearable colors!

  18. Dana

    I love Fluidlines and am going to pick up Added Goddess. The other 2 look nice as well but when they are applied they probably will just look black. Thanks for the reviews :)

  19. Avatar of Kelly Kelly Marie

    I feel like the first two look like Paint Pots lol…anybody else think that?

  20. Jenny

    I’m so glad I already own BB Black Mauve Shimmer Ink, so I don’t need Added Goodness, Midnight Snack on the other hand I think I must get! And it’s only $15!

  21. Nichole

    I’m so glad you like these. I picked up Wholesome last night WITHOUT reading Temptalia’s review!! For shame.

  22. Wow! I love Added Goodness, might have to pick that one up!

  23. kate

    Ugh, this collection looked so fun. Why follow it up with three completely boring Fluidlines? Total pass.

  24. Avatar of Marina Marina

    Added Goodness is BEAUTIFUL! Reminds me of that Nars Cream Shadow that came out semi-recently and creased badly…NEED THIS FLUIDLINE.

  25. Avatar of Monique monique

    have to decide between added goodness and midnight snack because i know i don’t need both!

  26. Avatar of Solangel Solangel

    Those swatches seem a bit too heavy :/ I do like Wholesome, though.

  27. Avatar of Aimey Aimey

    I’ve only used kohl pencils before, so I’m very excited to try all the other different liners out there! I just need to buy me some brushes first! :P

  28. Avatar of Naziba Ziba

    I picked up Added Goodness and Midnight Snack a few hours ago. They are gorgeous! At first I thought Midnight Snack might be similar to Graphite Shimmer by Bobbi Brown (judging by how it looks in the pot) so I ran over to BB counter to check the swatches side by side and they arent alike at all. Ran back to MAC and bought it!

  29. These are great shades!! Wholesome looks a whole lot darker and deeper than Blacktrack though. Not even close to Dipdown in my opinion

  30. Angie

    Do you think Added Goodness is similar to Avenue from Mac Me Over collection?

  31. Avatar of Nicole Nicole

    Love your blog. I just purchased Added Goodness after seeing your swatches; it looks beautiful, and I love taupes! I also purchased the Vera pearlmatte in Sunday Afternoon. While I have purchased a fair amount of MAC products in the past, these are my first LE products! It is also be my first time trying a fluidline.

  32. Avatar of Emily Emily O.

    I just ordered all three and got stickers- yay!

  33. Mila

    Thanks for the swatches Christine! I bought Added Goodness and Wholesome!

  34. Beck

    Wholesome looks like Nightfish fluidline from the Lure collection , maybe it’s a dupe.

  35. Avatar of Alison Alison

    I SO wish these were permanent! Midnight Snack looks like my perfect shade!