Wednesday, February 2nd, 2011

MAC Capricious Lipstick
MAC Capricious Lipstick

The Sultry Season: MAC Capricious Lipstick

MAC Capricious Lipstick ($14.50 for 0.10 oz.) is a rosy plum with subtle gold shimmer. MAC describes it as a “fanciful rose plum,” and it has a lustre finish. Lustre finishes are “demi-sheer with wet-look lustre finish … Very slick … Makes lips look soft, smooth, ultra-moist.”

If you can’t tell by the photo, Capricious has been a long-time favorite, and I’ve always found it an infinitely flattering shade. It’s got that pop of natural color that enhances lips but never overwhelms a look. It has a cool-tone edge to it but the play of gold shimmer works well to make it very wearable for both cool and warm undertones.

my thoughts on the formula: MAC Lipsticks are vanilla-scented but taste-free. I typically get four hours of wear, but some of the lighter lustre and glaze finishes tend to disappear by hour three. Amplified cremes and amplified finishes, however, tend to go beyond four. I find the formula comfortable to wear and not drying (but not moisturizing–a couple of the matte and lustre shades can be drying).

If you want to know more about how products are evaluated, read out Rating System FAQ! :)

  • Product: 28/30
  • Value: 8/10
  • Ease of Use: 4/5
  • Packaging: 4/5

final thoughts: Capricious is such a great way to wear plum without being too dark or bold.  It is as pretty in springtime as it is in fall.  It was one of my first MAC lipsticks and still a favorite.

where to buy: Nordstrom

See more photos & swatches!

MAC Capricious Lipstick
MAC Capricious Lipstick

MAC Capricious Lipstick
MAC Capricious Lipstick

MAC Capricious Lipstick
MAC Capricious Lipstick

MAC Capricious Lipstick
MAC Capricious Lipstick

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase Capricious? How much is it?

Nordstrom, $14.50.

Is it limited edition?

No.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

70 thoughts on “MAC Capricious Lipstick Review, Photos, Swatches

  1. Vanessa S

    ohhhhhhhhh love this !!!

  2. Avatar of Etaoin baby in a corner

    I love when you do reviews of permanent products that you like! Have to say Plumful is one of my favourite go to easy to wear lipsticks!

  3. Emmaline

    This has just gone on my to buy list! Thanks!

  4. S

    Long-time favorite for me, too – glad to see it get some love!

  5. Avatar of somhrita Somhrita

    have it since you recommended it for my skin tone on formspring. LOVE it.

  6. I just discovered this shade about 2 months ago an have worn it everyday since. Beautiful!!

  7. Avatar of Dawn Dawn

    The perfect colour! Lustres are my favourites. We don’t have Nordstrom in the UK, though

  8. Luna

    beautiful color!

  9. Avatar of Ashley Ashley Sarah

    I really love this shade!

  10. Jennifer

    I have this color, and I love it!

  11. Marcela

    love it! i can totally see this shade sharing the top spot with my fave, Plumful.

  12. Avatar of KRISTANNA Kristanna

    TY christine for recommending this. Im throwing it in my MUA arsenal!

  13. Laura

    How does this compare to Sweetie? Looks like they could be similar.

  14. Zara

    I love this! what would be a pretty gloss to go on top?

  15. pretty but it’s a lustre… I don’t particulary like the finish D:

  16. Kelly C.

    This is one of my all time favorites! Looks great with my fair complexion. It also works as a great stain if you just pat some on with your finger. It’s funny that you mention that it has gold shimmer, I can’t see it myself.

  17. Vijaya

    This lipstick looks like it’s gotten a lot of love! I love this shade myself. I love when you review MAC’s permanent products. They put out so many collections that the gems in the permanent line get overlooked frequently.

  18. Lena

    You reminded me how much I like this one! Such a easy, pretty color. On me it is more plummy than on you, but the gold really balances it all out nicely. I think everybody should at least check it out!

  19. Amrita

    How would you say this is in comparison to Cosmo? I have never tried a lustre just cause they’re so sheer, and I have very pigmented lips. Thanks so much! :)

  20. P

    Preety! I must give this a try

  21. prayers answered...

    wow- love this color on you! very wearable shade. very pretty!

  22. Avatar of Maja Maya

    Beautiful but honestly looks like my natural, pigmented lip color lol

  23. Ginger

    Funny how our lips’ pigmentation can change how lipsticks look. Capricious is probably my favorite lip color but since my lips has natural berry pigment Capricious looks darker and plumy-ier on me.
    If I want to achieve the lip color you have in the photo I ware Plumful.

  24. Avatar of Tiffany Tiffany S.

    Thanks for this review! I’m definitely trying this color on next time I go to MAC!

  25. Jane

    This is beautiful, Christine! I don’t normally go for lustres. but I might have to for this one!

  26. Avatar of Leticia Leticia

    I agree it’s so cool that you reviewed a MAC permanent product that we can add to our wish list…Capricious is now definitely on mine!

  27. That’s like the perfect color for you, you look so pretty!! THIS might be a product that would suck me into the depths of MAC addiction… :)

  28. Alyssa

    Nice coverage for a luster. Lovely color.

  29. Avatar of Michelle Michelle

    It looks great on you, but would it work on a fairer+pinker complexion? I really like it.

  30. Perri

    I love plum lipsticks. I think I need this.

  31. Sophie

    woah – so freaky that i’d actually gone and bought this yesterday (and i love it already) it’s similar to my natural lip colour but looks better

  32. steph b

    I love this color. It is one of my standbys. On me, it looks more like a soft red. I absolutely love the way it looks on you. I wish it was that way on me. I guess my lip pigmentation pulls it in a different direction.

  33. I think this is a lovely colour. I have it on my wishlist.

  34. Hend

    I have it and I lovvve it :D

  35. livnzoe

    it suits your skin perfectly christine!!

  36. Avatar of Mariella Mariella

    Capricious is one of my total favourite MAC lipsticks. It’s a fairly “new” acquisition for me (within the last 2 years) – I don’t change or buy lippies very often but my faves from MAC are Craving, Plumful, 2 LE lipsticks (Total Wow and Laugh a Lot) and Dubonnet.

    • We have very similar taste- those are some of my favorite colors too! If we both like those same lippies, you might like some of my other favorites- can I suggest them to you? After Party, by Clinique. Maybelline Color Sensational Berry Beautiful, and there is this gloss by Evil Shades that is one of my all-time favorites- it’s called Deadly and it’s one of their Wicked Glosses. It’s a great gloss that lasts and leaves a stain behind.

  37. I try to think of the Lustres as stick glosses because I love the colors so much but they wear off so fast, so I have to justify buying them somehow!

  38. Katy

    I love pinks like this!

  39. Justine_X

    This color looks sooooo beautiful! Amazing!
    Only problem is, I can’t have any color of lipstick, if I have lipstick on it’s like I’m a pornstar or something, really annoying :s Maybe this color will work.. Time for another visit to the Mac store! ^^

  40. I agree that Capricious is a long time favorite shade from MAC. I used this color on my best friend for her wedding. It photographed beautifully, and se didn’t require gloss because of its already high shine quality. Looks especially great on olive complexions.

  41. Crystal C.

    I will definitely check this out this weekend!

  42. Courtney

    Wow, I have never been so compelled to rush out and buy a lipstick in my life! I NEED this!

  43. jessica

    Im totally ordering that color today!!!

  44. Lolly

    I just bought this thanks to you and I love it! Such a beautiful everyday colour. It’s my new HG! <3

  45. Jane

    I went to the MAC store and I wanted to buy this one since it looks absolutely beautiful on you Christine. But unfortunately, when I tried it on, it was way darker than what I expected it to be. It looked really red on me. And I usually don’t really pull off red lipsticks but the lady recommended see sheer instead and that actually worked well on me.. whew. I wouldve hated leaving the store empty handed!

  46. Beatrice

    this looks so pretty!

  47. elizabeth

    Can you please make a post on MAC Cosmo?!? PLEASE?? thanks!

  48. I already own Plumful…should I get this too?

  49. Margaret

    How would this compare to craving? I’ve been looking for a rosy lipstick for a while now. Do you have any suggestions? I’m a NC25-30. Thanks! :)

  50. Pamela

    I just bought this and it’s so weird. In the tube itself, the lipstick looks like a more burgundy-wine sort of colour. It is really different from how yours look like! Also, when I applied it, it was not as pinky. But still, it is a gorgeous colour.

  51. ID

    this is a lovely color, i was looking for a dupe to burberry blush 09, this might do..thanx :)