We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

44 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Great quality purple eyeshadows would get me excited. Like an all-purple palette, with a variety of finishes.
A Star Wars themed collection, but apparently CoverGirl has that lined up for fall or winter. I wish MAC would have one too.
And I agree, duochrome lipsticks sound awesome!

If Mac did a Star Wars collection I would pee myself in excitement! Me and my brother have been obsessed with those movies since we were little! I feel like that’d sell really well, maybe bring in some new customers who are a little older than MACs target range.

Also, after I submitted my comment, a page came up that I’d never seen before asking me to verify my identity with a captcha. I didn’t do it and closed out of that page, but I just figured I’d let you know in case anyone else had that happen!

Was it from CloudFlare? If Cloudflare, which we use to serve a lot of images faster, detects potentially malicious traffic, they may prompt a page to ensure you’re a person and not a robot.

I’m sorry, but I can’t remember! I think I was on my first cup of coffee, so it’s a little fuzzy, lol. If it happens again and it’s not cloud fare, I’ll let you know!

I am starting to miss lipsticks with complex colors; the ones that cannot be described as red, pink, brown, etc. I am wishing Nars Audacious Lipsticks would introduce some complex pearl lipsticks in rich colors for late summer and early fall.

I agree! It would be awesome if they made a PERMANENT gorgeous red Amplified as in the LE Maria Moretti lipstick! My favorite red evah!!!

I agree also. I’d love something like Lustering but with better staying power. So, yes, MORE Amplified Creme lipsticks AND more of the Matte2 eyeshadow finish. If they’d bring back either Starflash or Mega Metal shadows (same colours as repromotes with some new colours of equally good quality) that would be great.

I’d love to see some good face and eye brushes with a matching brush roll or bag! Similarly, some beautiful storage pieces would be unique and appreciated – such as a cup for brushes, or a tray to set out on a vanity.

NARS Liquid Matte Lipsticks 🙂 or more selection in their current matte lipstick collections. Marc Jacobs, please come out with a selection of nude/mauve matte lipsticks

Love your idea of duochrome lipsticks. I’d like to see some eyeshadow palettes that are mostly matte with only a couple of shimmers that would have a good range of purples and/or greens with great pigmentation.

Hmmm maybe MAC doing a matte shadow collection with like a new and improved formulation (or maybe bring back some of the matte2 shadows). I rarely even look at MAC shadows because the matte shades are largely lackluster to me. I think that’d be really popular.

yes for the duochrome lipsticks! i’d also like to see some well-done bright shadows and different colored eyeliners that aren’t black/brown/dark purple/etc.

I love a duochrome shadow, but I’d love to see a collection of semi-matte luminous lip colors that stain and are long lasting!

Please; something HEAVY on the purples and plums for lips, eyes, etc. that has FLAWLESS finishes and no application issues!!! No splotchy-ness, no patchy-ness, just PERFECTION throughout!!! Oh, and throw in some really awesome deep plum and aubergine matte lippys that COVER properly!!!

I’m with you on plummy plummy goodness! I think it’s just as wearable as the rose golds or coral craze that we’ve just seen. I hope this fall brings us some nice jewel tones but especially plum, eggplant & some other nice rich purples.

I’d love Chanel to make a line of Gardenias that are large highlighters available in an array of spa steel rainbow shades! I want a garden. 😀 If they’re poly-chromatic.. Even better! 😛 I think the duo and polychromes of so many years ago were missed and need to come back in every formulation for everyone to have a chance to play! And I’d love to see more lines become more WoC friendly! Seriously..

I love lipstick – I would like to see more subtle shades with polish – not matte. I’d like to see a lot of liquid/cream eye shadows too.

More true green eyeshadows. They work amazing for my eyes but there aren’t that many good ones out there. (same goes with emerald green clothes, it’s like they don’t exist unless they have some kind of crazy patter.) I also wouldn’t mind more blue or green lips as I feel like cosmetics are going more “out there” and if purple can become a more normalized color, why can’t green or blue?

I absolutely agree! I love emerald green both in clothes and in eye shadow. Have you tried Charlotte Tilbury’s The Rebel? It’s really good.

Let’s just see

-opaque wearable cream finish lipglosses which don’t settle that much into lines (but some vampier colors would be great, too)
-more complex mineralize type blushes or overall blushes with a metallic sheen
-OPAQUE (like no topcoat like, 1-coar opaque) matte glitter nail polishes
-a Naked type palette with some more natural looking, but interesting color (an olive, a rose gold or a plum maybe) instead some of the browns or taupes

I would like to see a cruelty free brand make a collection of one of the following:

Game of Thrones
Jurassic World
Lord of the Rings

Quality. ha, ha I love your idea of duochrome lipsticks!

Although I do appreciate and love browns and nudes, I would love to see some other colors popping up in more collections. Not necessarily brights and “uncoventional” colors (though that would be awesome IMO), but just more complex, interesting shades and finishes. (Luckily, there are some good indie companies delivering on that score, but it would be great to see more from the larger manufacturers.)

I’m still on board with other readers’ previous suggestions for UD to do a purple-themed Naked palette. Lavender tinged taupes and grays, plummy nudes, violet browns, a true purple or two. That would be heavenly.

I truly metallic bronze lipstick from a quality company. The only one I’ve ever seen was from Wet n Wild and I’d love to have something that doesn’t dry out my lips and taste like a candle.

A collection or palette with really unique eyeshadows. The same browns and neutrals are getting a little boring. I love grays, blacks, jewel tones (beautiful deep blues, greens, purples). No glitter, but a nice shimmer that lights up the eyes. Even with the Naked palette, I have yet to find a palette that has everything I need in it. Also, a nice blush palette would be great. Tarte had put one out a couple of years ago but I never got my hands on it and I haven’t seen anything else like it. We travel alot and I’m always looking for palettes so I can cut down on how much makeup I take with me. 🙂

I agree with some of the other people on here! More Mac Amplified lipsticks! I love the pigmentation and finish of these lipsticks, but there really aren’t many colors to choose from..

I would like Nars to feature a single black matte eye shadow in their Fall 2015 makeup collection. It’s been a long time since they had one. Remember the Black Forest Single Matte eye shadow back in the day? It was one of the my favorite eye shadows Nars made. Hope to see a matte black eye shadow soon in the Nars collection for Fall 2015.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!