87 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Katherine T. Avatar

Wow! I have an Anastasia Dip Brow and have been using it faithfully every day for like 3 years, and I think I’m still only halfway through. Hmm, last item finished was probably a MACcompact with setting powder

Holly Avatar

Josie Maran Matchmaker Powder Foundation, and Tarte Tarteguard Spf 30 sunscreen. I just repurchased both. And my Laura Geller GlamLash mascara dried out. I need to get another one soon.

Eva Avatar

Revlon Colorstay Foundation and ColourPop Ultra Matte in Bumble. Those two are my HG and go to beauty products lately. Never thought I could finish a lipstick though, lol..

Natalia Avatar

– MAC Matchmaster concealer. Weirdly enough, it has grown on me, I really did not like it at the beginning.
– Almost there with my beloved MAC Patina eyeshadow. Will probably repurchase it at some point.
– MAC bronzer in Golden.

Astrild Avatar

Maybelline Brow Satin pencil. I’ve liked it because it gives me a natural brows but it doesn’t last me all day long. I don’t know if I’ll repurchased it.

Erica Avatar

I assume you are talking about the Smashbox Photo primer? I primarily use the Revlon one as an under eye brightener so I cannot speak to it as a primer. As that it brightens, doesn’t creases or make my skin oily. Love it. I tried a sample of the Smashbox. It seems to be for drier skin. It doesn’t really suit me bc I have oily skin. The Revlon one works well with my oily skin but I think it would be suitable for all skin types.

Susan Avatar

You’re talking about the Smashbox eye primer? I am almost finished with my tube and I liked it. I didn’t have to be super careful blending it near the inner corner of my eyes since it is colorless, and shadow stayed all day. But my HG is the NARS primer, which I got with my Sephora discount.

Jessica Avatar

Thank you so much! I was referring to the Smashbox Hydrating Under-eye Primer. The Revlon was is supposed to be q dupe 🙂 Sorry, I wasn’t clear. I got excited! Haha “finally! Someone who has actually tried the Revlon one!” Lol

Mariella Avatar

I’m not entirely sure but I am right on the cusp of finishing up my Eucerin night cream and Clinique SuperDefense day cream with SPF. I have 2 backups of the Eucerin, as I can’t get it in Canada, but have to pick up another jar of the Clinique today after school, because there is a 20X the points event but I’ll only get it if SDM has product with a long expiry date (far too often, I guess because they’re sort of “second string”, their higher end products, which don’t sell rapidly in these smaller outlets, have expiry dates that are way too soon and I’ve even brought them some products from their shelves that have already expired!).

KJH Avatar

3 Paula’s in 2 days. Resist super antiox serum, clinical body butter, and resist sldwd. Got the replacements on time. Just love that TM. It’s either tube 3 or 4. A first real commitment to a product in 40+ years.

angel1jay Avatar

MAC Mineralize Skinfinish in Medium Tan. I’ve come to the realization that I really love that powder to set my face 🙂

MariJ Avatar

I was surprised at how much I loved my Mineralize powder too – never expected it to become my favorite but I’m about half way through it and plan on repurchasing.

Angie Avatar

The packaging on those shows 6M shelf life. Did you use it longer than that? It seemed short to me for a brow product.

Laura Avatar

Either the Almay One-Coat Get Up and Grow waterproof mascara, or NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer. Those are the two products in my entire routine that I go through the most and always replace. I’ve tried other types of mascara and concealer, but these ones do the best job for me!

Laura Avatar

Mini Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes Mascara, full size Covergirl WP Clump Crusher mascara (my HG, I think I’ve been through 3 of them so far), and mini tube of Fyrinnae Pixie Epoxy (can’t live without when it comes to loose indie shadows). My sample baggie of Blackbird Cosmetics Magic Trick Powder in Green and WnW Fergie Eyeshadow Primer are both also nearing the end, but I’ve already ordered a full size jar of the Blackbird powder.

xamyx Avatar

I have about 3-4 days left of Alaffia Everyday Coconut Face Cleanser & Dickinson’s Witch Hazel. As for actual makeup, I have hit significant pan on L’Oreal True Match Blush in Tender Rose, an old L’Oreal Visible Lift Powder I hated for face, but *love* for the undereye setting, WnW Take On The Day Mattifying Powder (already have 2 backups) and Maybelline Age Rewind Concealer in Radiant. I *finally* figured out how to make the concealer work for me, but as I rarely remember to use concealer, I’ll try to get through some others I have before even considering a repurchase.

Nika99 Avatar

I just finished Smashbox cosmetics contour pencil from their contour,bronze,and highlight pencil trio.I am also finishing up my own Anastasiabeverlyhills Dipbrowpomade and it took me forever to finish it too!!

Liesbeth Avatar

Congrats on finishing a Dip Brow jar Christine! Every time I use it I wonder how on earth it’s possible to ever hit pan on it! lol
My last beauty product I finished was MAC Studio Careblend pressed powder. Big love for this powder, I will definitely repurchase when I’ve finished my other similar powders!

MariJ Avatar

Just this week finished these 3: Cle de Peau makeup remover wipes, Biore Self-heating one minute mask, L’Oreal Superstar mascara. All on order again. 🙂

Laura Haslam Avatar

I finish skincare a lot faster than make-up. I’ve just finished Balance Active Snake Venom Eye Cream, which I’ve gone through multiple times as I love it. I’ve also recently finished Secret Key Prestige Gold Snail Ampoule. As for make-up, I’m just about to finish Soap & Glory Retouched Pressed Powder, and finished the lightest shimmery shade in the MUA Undress Me Too palette.

Jenny Avatar

Where do you get the Balance Active Snake Venom eye cream and the Secret Key Prestige Gold Snail Ampoule? Do you notice a big difference using them? I’ve heard great things about the benefits of snail slime. Lol!

Jenny Avatar

I finally finished my MAC prolong wear concealer, but I don’t wear makeup everyday. I also finished my Neutrogena makeup remover wipes and my Ole Henrickson truth serum, which I’m truly bummed about, as it is so expensive. I really wish I had done the auto delivery when I ordered through QVC, since I got a great price when I ordered the last time. Lesson learned!!!

Jessica Avatar

Last week, I used up an old tube of Clinique Almost Makeup! This has been discontinued for years but I forgot about it when I got into other foundations.

Lea Avatar

I’ve actually finished quite a bit recently – Armani bronzer #1 (old formula; now it’s 100), I’m still scraping the edges of the pan but I think it’s time to give up the ghost; Armani Maestro foundation #2; Sunday Riley Luna oil (I’m completely hooked even though my husband hates the smell); Neulash growth serum; ReVive Moisturizing Renewal Cream and Gentle Purifying Gel Cleanser and finally a large box of Dr Dennis Gross Extra Strength Alpha Beta Hydroxy pads. I’m almost finished with a Fresh Black Tea Age Delay Eye Concentrate and SK-II Cellumination Cream EX. I’m either already using or ready to go with replacements for everything but the two face and one eye creams. I think I’ll be switching to the Sunday Riley Tidal water cream for day, Chantecaille Retinol+ for night and either La Mer Eye Concentrate or Armani Crema Nera eye cream. I’ve been dying to get into the Armani Crema Nera, so that’s likely what I’ll open.

Flaky Avatar

I just noticed yesterday that my favorite Chanel lipstick “Julia” is pretty much gone. It’s so low that the empty barrel kinda scrapes off what I just swiped on. I may scoop out the remnants, but I need a fresh one. Julia is my permanent purse lippie.

Jisela Avatar

Estée Lauder Double Wear foundation , MAC Studio Fix foundation. I circulate my makeup so I finished them at the same time. Also my MAC Painterly Paint Pot and just hit pan on my MAC Sheer Select Powder

Pasheeda Morris Avatar

Make Up For Ever Rouge Artist Intense Lipstick in #3 Matte Caramel. I just finished it in time to purchase a new tube after getting down to the bottom of the tube on the old one.

Hildegard Avatar

On the makeup front, my MAC Russian Red lipstick, but as far as skincare goes I think it was a Nuxe eye cream. I go through those real fast, though I’m always looking for a better product.

Beth Avatar

Try the Paulas Choice eye cream. I love it, and if it doesn’t work for you (which I doubt will happen) they have an excellent return policy.

Flicka Avatar

Rimmel Kate Moss lipstick – finally – took a few years. I’m also finishing a sunscreen. They last like 3 months.

Reese Avatar

Benefit Boiiing Concealer shade 02. I use it for both under eye dark circle cover AND eye shadow primer. Bulletproof holy grail. Makes even inexpensive eyeshadow stay all day. Press and hold against skin for a moment to let body warmth make the product easier to apply without pulling, and then tap it on into place.

VAL MARTIN Avatar

Thanks for this tip I’ve recently finished a pot of this and also have a deluxe sample pot containing half Boing and half Eye Bright. Will try this.

VAL MARTIN Avatar

A full sized pot of Benefit Boing Concealer. It was in a Project Pan. I also have a pot of Benefit Lemon Aid and Laura Geller Bronze n Brighten as part of the same Project,

Bon Bon Avatar

I’m so spoiled I’ve never finished a product. I have an Estée Lauder shimmer blush, that was discontinued, that’s been the best match to my skin tone of of every product I’ve ever bought. I’ve hoarded it forever. I pull it out for special occasions like homecoming weekends, Christmas pics, etc.

Meredith Avatar

Tom Ford’s eye shadow primer. It works wonders for covering up discoloration such as purplish or reddish tones on the upper eyelid. Comes with a powder for setting. There is only one color and at first I was afraid it was too orangy but that tint cancels out the blue-ish patches and makes the skin look young and fresh. I often just wear this and no eyeshadow as it makes the skin brighter and rested looking.

GK Avatar

Hourglass Ambient Lighting Palette & Nars Copacabana. I’ve had them for over 2 yrs & used them almost every day! I like to get something different when I finish a product, I’ve tried other things in between, but haven’t found anything I like better.

Naomi Avatar

CVS brand Dead Sea minerals face mask (one time use packet, though there was at least another use but I hate using the rest of the sample after opening the packet, anyone else feel this way?!). just bought a full size today!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!