What type of products excited you at first but don't excite you now?

Highlighters. I think it’s hard to get TRULY excited over a new highlighter now; they keep releasing gorgeous ones, but it’s a category where most brands release within a limited spectrum of possibilities.

— Christine
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Skincare. But 15 years of skincare PR will do that, I suppose ?‍♀️and anything with pigment is far more interesting at baseline.

Liquid lipsticks. I went through a phase of buying them a couple years ago, and wore them every day, but now I stick almost exclusively to bullets.

Also, bright eyeshadow colors. I was very experimental in 2019, and bought quite a few of the ColourPop bright monochromes (yellow, blue, green, pink, purple…), but if I’m being honest with myself, these tiny, hooded eyes of mine look best in neutral shades, especially cool neutrals. There are quieter shades in each of those palettes that I can use, but I have come to the realization that I can’t pull off those gorgeous, colorful eye looks that Christine designs.

Lipsticks. So many great formulas already out there and after purging a rude amount of product over the years, I find myself less and less excited. I go out without lipstick all the time.. just lip balm so there’s that too.

Same here. I think I’m down to maybe 6 at most after doing several clean-outs. Most time I forget to wear it. When I do wear it, I like to apply and then blot and rub it around a bit. I just can’t handle the crisp edges anymore.

Nail polish. Yeah, that’s a shocker to me, too. But I own probably 150+ of them, so there just isn’t much that’s new to me lately. That, plus my nails are in lousy condition in the past few years, so I’m less excited about even doing manicures than before.
Also, all dry-down liquid lipsticks are on my “less than enthused” list, too. I cannot deal with chalky sensations on my lips! Or feeling like the very life force of my lips are being sucked dry.

I’m also over highlighters! I have enough shimmery eyeshadows that work as highlighters! What I’m really over is liquid lipstick! Some formulas are still way too drying and I don’t have the interest or energy to find the perfect ones anymore! I prefer regular old bullet lipstick! Hasn’t failed me yet! Also, mascara! I don’t use it enough to pay more than $5 for it!

Probably liquid lipsticks. At first, I was really excited about the long wear time and then I tried a few and the long wear time didn’t compensate for how dry they both looked and felt on my lips.

Gel liners in pots. I still like them, but I was really, really into them for a while. I just haven’t been doing the more complex liner looks, and it seems like I don’t see pot liners being marketed as much as they were a few years ago.

Also, ColourPop Super Shock Shadows. I still like the ones I own, but I haven’t bought new ones in years. I used to love them because they came in brights and complex colors, and many had lots of sparkle or ultra-metallic finishes. I got less interested when CP got rid of a lot of the colors that initially attracted me, and went more neutral. I know they started adding more brights back into their SSS lineup, but now it’s easier to find brights and interesting finishes in pressed powder form, which I prefer.

Eye pencils and eye liners.
I used to get all excited about having multiple colors (black, different shades of brown, green, blue, purple, burgundy), but nowadays I just end up having one shade of a flattering brown and that’s enough.
Eye liners… a part of me still wants to rock a cat eye almost every day… but nowadays it’s barely once a week. I don’t even buy full sizes anymore, just minis.

I used to feel like I needed to jump on every single Too Faced collection. After busting my butt to get the original, “limited edition” peach palette, only for them to turn around a release an entire collection, I’ve been somewhat disillusioned. Not to mention some pretty garbage quality releases… They do seem to be turning things around but it’s hard to get excited.

I sort of agree. I don’t think these brands are so bad, it’s just that since their moment, there have just been better quality releases, and those of us who buy a lot of makeup now have higher expectations.

I too am overloaded on highlighters. I look at new releases but that is usually as far as it goes, unless the reviews are unbelievably good, then I will investigate further. I’m too much of a makeup junkie to be disillusioned about much else really.

I realize that I do not like “frosty opaque” highlighters. I have purchased so many that I have come to love a bronzy glittery sheer highlighter or a more “wet” look. My perfect highlighters are the bronze color from the Pat McGrath trio.. I WISH she would give me a big single of that one. I scraped the pan and wet it with fix plus to get all the product out! and I love the MAC extra dimension skin finishes.. my fave is Show Gold.. I have several others I like but these stand out for me. I have decluttered all the white base opaque frosty highlighters from my collection.. a streak of product on my tan skin is not a look I’m after 🙂

I’m not making a case for frosty, opaque highlighters as I have a tendency to enjoy more towards your preferences – but. Are you sure you were using a dark enough shade? I’m much lighter than you but I’ve recently realized that I was going too light with my highlighters, giving me a frostier appearance than I wanted.

I am much less interested iin all cheek products; blush and highliter. It feels like every color and texture has been done. I have the ones I love along with a few I don’t. Just don’t need anymore in my collection.

Oh god FOUNDATION! lol Mostly because it’s so difficult for me to find a foundation that does *everything* I want. So it’s not that I don’t get excited about it, it’s more that I’ve had to set my expectations lower lol

Anybody found their “miracle foundation” out there? lol

I just want:

-pore blurring
-color matching
-mostly natural
-long lasting

Foundation! Does it exist?! lol

Pore blurring and natural are almost mutually exclusive, from an ingredient perspective. You kind of need a substantial layer to effectively blur pores and provide enough of the necessary polymers to do so.

I agree on highlighter. While a really beautiful new, artfully done one can still get me excited (Mac Lunar New Year, Becca Lunar New Year, Melt Amor Eterno), overall highlighters are a product I don’t love using. I mean, I do it every day in my makeup routine, but for me, they add the least to my overall look and don’t last that long.

Same with nail polish and eyeliner. I went through my phases with those, having them in every color, but now I reach mostly for black liner and I have enough nail polish.

My next phase was lipstick. I’m still into it, but not like I was.

Eyeshadow palettes are what I’m into right now.

I’m most like you. I go through phases. Right now I’m insistent that I need the ultimate corrector ahah

I can’t believe I’m going to say this…eye shadow palettes. Yes, they are still the FIRST thing I look at for a brand and look for when someone’s putting out a new release, article; etc., but they rarely make me swoon as a year or more ago.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!