We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

72 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Your skin tone/coloring: Light, neutral, MUFE 117 Bobbi Brown Warm Ivory dark hair amber eyes
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Champagne and Taupe!!
Lipstick color you have too many of? MLBB Rosey brown shades like MAC patisserie and hug me
Blush color you have too many of? Coral!!! I absolutely love corals! theBalm frat boy and Benefit coralista are my faves!

Skintone/coloring: Fairly light, very neutral; dark-featured.

Eyeshadow: Neutrals… I just can’t seem to pass up a good neutral palette, LOL!

Lipstick: Corals; I don’t have many, but since it’s a color I simply don’t wear, even one is too many.

Blush: Again, corals. I always seem to end up with one whenever I buy a palette, or set, and it is such a horrid shade, I really wonder what brands are thinking when they insist on including them…

Coral is beautiful! It simply depends on your skin. There are tons of colors that look bad on me but I don’t wear them so I admire them on other women…like candy pink.

My issue is that it is not a universally flattering shade, so why put it in *every* palette/set? Why not put something a bit more neutral in? Coral is just a shade that, while alot of women like it, just doesn’t look good on the majority of those who wear it. I realize this is just my opinion, but like with nude lipstick (for example), it’s not something everyone wants to put the extra effort in trying to pull off. As for “admiring” it on others, I don’t find that possible if it’s not flattering.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool toned

now….in my opinion, you can’t really have too many of variations on your favourite shadows, blushes or lipsticks but in the interest of make up statistics, I will answer nevertheless

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? darker taupes and browns (MAC Prepped for Glamour, Carbonized, Satin Taupe, Sweet Satisfaction, Dalliance and Centre Stage, Benefit, Where There’s Smoke, Guerlain Les Fumes just to name a very few)
Lipstick color you have too many of? rosy or berry tones (MAC Craving and Plumful are examples)
Blush color you have too many of? Also rose or pink – MAC Dollymix and Tarte Natural Beauty are 2 examples and just today, I saw that the drug store near my school now has the entire range of NYX blushes – powder, cream and stick. They never had any NYX blushes til now and I’m excited at the prospect of picking up several of them – Pinky, Peach, Tulip….see, all similar shades to what I already have and love

■Your skin tone/coloring: NW-25
■Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Neutrals, I love them and buy way too many.
■Lipstick color you have too many of? Nudes, not a big fan but I apparently thought I was at one time.
■Blush color you have too many of? Can you really have too many blushes? If forced, I have to say coral. It’s my favorite and I own loads or them from Milani to Tom Ford.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/neutral
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Neutrals! SO. MANY. NEUTRALS
Lipstick color you have too many of? Corals
Blush color you have too many of? Corals

Your skin tone/coloring: NC05

Eyeshadow color you have too many of: all of them. lol But shimmer nudes I have a lot of them.
Lipstick color you have too many of: Coral/Pinks but I love corals.
Blush color you have too many of: Coral as well.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Maybe green? I don’t have a huge stash or anything, but I own 4 greens which is a lot considering that I don’t wear green very often even though I like green.

Lipstick color you have too many of? I don’t have too much of anything I don’t think. Nothing I have is really a dupe of anything else I have.

Blush color you have too many of? I only own two blushes so none.

It’s a good thing this survey didn’t ask about nail polishes. >_>

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair and pink, Chanel BR-12
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Purple. I don’t wear that color enough to have as much as I do.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Red. I love red lips, but I just don’t have enough occasions that deem a red lip acceptable, so it’ll take a lifetime to go through a few tubes for me.

Blush color you have too many of? Light, soft, peachy-pink. Think NARS Deep Throat, Chanel Rose Petale, MAC Dainty, and so on.

Skin Tone: Fairest with neutral/warm undertones (NARS Siberia or Gobi)

Eyeshadow color you have too many of?
I have a lot of neutrals, champagnes, browns, and golds. A LOT.

Lipstick color you have too many of?
Bright pinks with blue undertones. Seriously. I have so many of those in different brightness and blueness.

Blush color you have too many of?
Pinks. Glittery ones.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light/neutral
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Many, many neutral shades. Lots of brown, taupe and beige.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Red. I’ll never stop. It’s a compulsion.
Blush color you have too many of? Pinks, I believe. Though I don’t own an extravagant amount of blush. I’m quite certain that will change!

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? bronze, champagne, and taupe- I can’t resist a good neutral! 😉

Lipstick color you have too many of? berry, plum, and red- I have a penchant for dark, sultry shades.

Blush color you have too many of? coral and peach- I’m always drawn to these shades, I think they’re extremely flattering.

Asian skin tone- yellow. Dont have too much of any of the above…each item bought was meticulously thought out….I buy the product for its packaging, brand name and the color variation…I dont buy on the spur of the moment….

Skintone: NC42, medium tan with slight yellow undertone
Eyeshadow color you have too many of: Browns. Especially warm browns, I can’t get enough of them!
Lip color you have too many of: Probably red. I wish I could wear a red lip everyday.
Blush color you have too many of: peachy corals!

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, pink undertones.
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Dark colors. I never use them.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Neutrals or nudes.
Blush color you have too many of? Very pale pink or peach.

■Your skin tone/coloring: C3/NC20
■Eyeshadow color you have too many of? I have too many eyeshadows PERIOD, of all colors, finishes and brands, but I really have a problem with the number of neutrals I own. Guilty as charged!
■Lipstick color you have too many of? Pinks. 80% of the lip products I own are of the pink variety! I love orange lipsticks, but… Yeah, pink.
■Blush color you have too many of? peach/corals! Or maybe pinks again…

Your skin tone/coloring: light to medium warm

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Too many? What do you mean…? 😉 With eyeshadow that is just not possible.

Lipstick color you have too many of? I actually went to my stash to check, but all my lipsticks are actually different! Some only slighty, but still 🙂 I have pale pinks, peachy tones, warm reds, corals, bright pinks, brownish shades,… Just nothing too dark.

Blush color you have too many of? I always go for peach or pink shades, and I own a couple of those, but they’re still all kinda different.

Your skin tone/coloring:

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Blues and teals, nbt because I have that many compared to other shades, but because I wear them so much less. They look awesome on my arm…

Lipstick color you have too many of? Corals and neutrals. I have a lot of both and neither looks particularly wonderful on me (other than the very pinkest corals). I have a lot more reds and berries, but I wear those shades all the time.

Blush color you have too many of? Actually, I can’t think of one. Although there are a few blushes that I don’t wear that often and a couple of shade ranges where I have a few, the love tends to get spread around. I probably don’t need another hot pink/ magenta blush ever, but I use the four or so that I have and they’re different enough that each has their role in my makeup wardrobe.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light-medium, peachy (NW20-25), dark hair, blue eyes

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? I have too many eyeshadows. In general. All colors (except maybe blue). Lol. I guess I’ll have to go with neutrals (champagne, taupe and cool browns make me drool). Or purple. Or green.

Lipstick color you have too many of? Definitely light-medium neutral pinks! It’s the only shade I feel looks good on me.

Blush color you have too many of? I have so many blushes that I have trouble finding something I don’t already have a (almost) dupe of. Corals are my weakness, though. And plummy shades.

Light olive with warm undertones – MAC C3.5. Hazel eyes & reddish-brown hair.

Eyeshadow: Black! I every MAC palette I have seems to contain Carbon 😉 I also have singles and palettes by other brands that contain black colours.I have matte, shimmer, duo-chrome, glitter, and veined with every colour you can think of.
Lipstick: Red, but then I am on my quest to find my HG – MAC’s Russian Red is the current favourite!
Blush: Pink, but IMO there’s a massive spectrum of pink colours to choose from…at least that’s how I’m justifying it!

■Your skin tone/coloring: NW20

■Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Maybe blue

■Lipstick color you have too many of? Red or pink lippies

■Blush color you have too many of? Pink blushes

Your skin tone/coloring: NC25
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Neutral shades – I cannot get enough of them!
Lipstick color you have too many of? Pinks and berries
Blush color you have too many of? Blush is the product I buy less of, but I do have more pinks than any other color

■Your skin tone/coloring:Warm/Fair
■Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Browns
■Lipstick color you have too many of? Corals
■Blush color you have too many of? Corals

Your skin tone/coloring: fair with cool undertones
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? TAUPE! Even if I had 10 sets of eyelids I’d never be able to use them up!
Lipstick color you have too many of? Reds. I started wearing red not so long ago and at first, I kept buying too bold reds that I wouldn’t dare wearing outside. So they’re still just lying around.
Blush color you have too many of? Can’t have too many blushes. I don’t have two that look alike.

Your skin tone/coloring: NARS Fiji/ pale, with warm undertones; brown/black hair & brown eyes.

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Purples! But after that, definitely neutrals 🙂

Lipstick color you have too many of? Pale/nudey pinks (my lips but better colors)

Blush color you have too many of? Peaches/corals. I’m obsessed & have a problem!

Your skin tone/coloring: fair NC20 – fair Irish Cailin variety!
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Browns, Taupe,anything neutral, how boring!
Lipstick color you have too many of? Pink mainly glosses though
Blush color you have too many of? Coral, same goes for nail polish!

Your skin tone/coloring: Around NC15…neutral leaning on warm
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Bronzy neutral shades for sure. Or just neutrals in general. I absolutely love neutral eyeshadows.
Lipstick color you have too many of: Red! Not that I’m complaining 😉 I can’t seem to stop buying them, I just love them so much!
Blush color you have too many of: Probably peaches/corals. I’m trying to not always be drawn to wearing those tones every day.

Your skin tone/coloring: olive- light tan – dark brown almost black hair and eyes
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? golds – way to many different gold shades but I love them!!!
Lipstick color you have too many of? Reds. I have a lot of reds. I don’t even wear red often. I’m trying for pinks now but me and pink have our moments! (my lips are very pigmented so colors always look different and I don’t often line my lips)
Blush color you have too many of? i don’t really have many blushes- pink and peachy colors

Your skintone: Pale, with cool undertones; UD NAKED liquid foundation 0.5 (don’t know my MAC shade, don’t care)
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Pinks. Shades of pink! I could probably do an ombré of pink shades. And black: sparkly black, matte black, brown-black, etc…
Lipstick color you have too many of: Red 😀 I have two red lipstick and the two red Soft Matte lip creams from NYX. Trying to expand from it but its difficult to find something I both like & feel looks good!
Blush color you have too many of? None! I’ve never bothered much with blush, so I only have two (and only one gets used on my face lol)

Your skin tone/coloring: Light/yellow
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Pinks, purples and blues, my favorite colors to wear on my eyes 🙂
Lipstick color you have too many of? I have very few lipsticks.
Blush color you have too many of? I don’t own that many blushes, maybe 5 or 6.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light with yellow undertones
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Pink-champagne colors like Sin from UD, I have soo many colors like that!
Lipstick color you have too many of? Reds
Blush color you have too many of? Corals. Can’t help it!

Skin: Medium Tan
Eyeshadow: It would definitely be pink!
Lipstick: Nudes and pink
Blush: Bronzers…I think I have every shade of bronzer. That’s all I wear on my cheeks. Occasionally I might wear a pink or peachy shade.

■Your skin tone/coloring: NC15/NW20
■Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Golds & bronzes, but really anything neutral.
■Lipstick color you have too many of? Anything orange, coral, & hot pink.
■Blush color you have too many of? Probably oranges and corals.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30-35 (Medium, yellow undertones)
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Vanilla / Beige kind of colors
Lipstick color you have too many of? Neutral soft pinks (my lips but better)
Blush color you have too many of? Pink blushes 🙂

– skin: medium/tan, neutral; MUFE 128 Almond
– eyeshadow: i haz ALL the browns!
– lipstick: reds. too many reds.
– blush: universal-type pinks and corals.

i struggle with eyeshadows – my eyes split the difference between green and blue and are quite bright. i am drawn to colored eyeshadows but they seem to compete with my eye color, the worst being blue eyeliners and eyeshadows. browns seem to be the best. kinda a boo.

skin tone/ coloring: nc/nw10, very pale neutral, dark hair, brown eyes

eyeshadow i have too many of: black, i have a bunch of urban decay, mac, giorgio armani, the balm, chanel, and more. black is the color i wear most often so i guess it’s not too bad.

lipstick color i have too many of: light pinks like mac creme cup, angel, ysl lingerie pink and many more.

blush color i have too many of: cool toned pinks like mac well dressed, mac pink swoon, tom ford wicked, chanel pink explosion…

NC43

I have too many eyeshadows period but I have an extravagant amount of neutrals. I have all the Naked palettes, in addition to other palettes with tons of neutrals.

I have a good assortment of lip colors, heavy on mattes though. I love mattes.

I was buying a lot of Orgasm-esque blushes, but now I have a lot of pinks.

** Your skin tone/coloring: Extremely pale (Irish/German/Dutch/Danish) nearly paper white skin, warm-neutral undertones, dark brown hair with a lot of red (auburn as a child), brown eyes.
** Eyeshadow color you have too many of?: Well I have too much of every family. But I’d definitely have to say GREENS! Dozens upon dozens, though I don’t think there’s such a thing as too many if I’m utilizing all of them… far too many hues in far too many finishes to stop picking up new e/s!
** Lipstick color you have too many of?: It looks as though I have a little bit of everything. I’m more of a lipgloss gal. Despite my very pale skin, I have bright pink lips. They change the color of my favorite shades, and I hate the texture if I have to mute them first. : /
** Blush color you have too many of?: Pretty even all across the board.

Your skin tone/coloring: Neutral leaning to cool, quite light. MAC NW20/NC20 (right in between), black/brown hair, brown eyes, fairly asian features

Eyeshadow color you have too many of?
Too much eyeshadow everything. Blues or nudes otherwise though, I’ve got a lot of blue eyeshadow that never really gets used, I like it, there was a time I wore Sephora Swimming Pool daily, (well, before I lost it) I just don’t have the occasion. The nudes (browns, taupes, and beiges) do pose a problem though, with quite a few being included in palettes plus just the regulars means I’m knees deep in eyeshadow that’s never used. The funny thing being I don’t like nude shadows.

Lipstick color you have too many of?
Lipstick is easily the thing I own the most of outside of palettes. Reds, though arguably not a problem considering the one nude I own never sees the light of day. Most are cool reds, pretty dark, I’ve got an entire spectrum from poppy to wine, despite my favorite actually being Revlon Fire and Ice, which is not cool toned at all. Realistically, I’d say I have too many nudes. I don’t have a use for the one or the clear glosses, it’s just rotting there as I prefer statement lips or nothing at all.

Blush color you have too many of?
I actually own very little blush, seeing as I don’t use it much. Pinks, probably, I don’t think I own a non-pink blush.

Skin Tone:
Very fair slightly cool toned.

Eyeshadow color you have too many of?
Purple, especially blue based ones (can’t wait for the fall Dior purple palette)

Lipstick color you have too many of?
Reds, especially blue based ones.

Blush color you have too many of?
Cool light pinks.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, neutral/warm
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Taupes, champagnes, and browns.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Reds and berry tones.
Blush color you have too many of? Definitely coral!

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium, about an NW 20-25

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Neutrals! Until a short time they were ALL I wore!

Lipstick color you have too many of? MLBB shades, sheer berry tones, sheer finishes in general.

Blush color you have too many of? Tanned pink or muted plum shades.

Your skin tone/coloring: MAC nc30-35, UD Naked 4.0, Nars Sheer Glow Steomboli,
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Taupe. So. Many. Tapes.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Tie between MLBB neutral pink and red. Tons of each.
Blush color you have too many of? Peachy pinks

Skin tone/coloring: between a MAC NC and NW and 40-44, depending on time of year and specific line.

Eyeshadow color I have too many of: brown. By default, I have switched my preferred neutrals from gray to brown simply because brown is in so many palettes. Grays would have meant another purchase. Maybe that will change soon.

Lipstick: Neutral shades. In my quest for the perfect neutral, I have acquired many “almosts.”

Blush color: I think I’m pretty good in this category. Love them all.

Your skin tone/coloring: cool / pale-fair
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? taupes, bronzey browns
Lipstick color you have too many of? pale nudes, pale pinks (blue-based)
Blush color you have too many of? pale pinks (almost lavender-ish)

Skin tone: Fair/yellow-neutral undertones

Eyeshadow: rose gold oh my I can’t seem to get over this colour.

Lipstick: I would say fushia pinks, I almost never wear them but somehow Its a colour I love to collect.

Blush: Orange/peach/coral blushes get the best of me.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC50

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Browns; I could get rid of all my other colors and just use browns forever and never look back!

Lipstick color you have too many of? I am a sucker for fuchsia pinks (such as MAC Girl About Town – my favorite pink ever)!

Blush color you have too many of? Pinks

Your skin tone/coloring: Pale but fairly neutral, I tend to look better in warm colors though with my auburn red hair.
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Browns, golds, dakr purples. I never wear grey or silver.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Neutral pinks
Blush color you have too many of? Rosy pinks. Anything else tends to make me look kind of sick though.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cooler toned. Currently NC/W15, more NW10 in the fall and winter.
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Probably brown. Can never have enough neutrals!
Lipstick color you have too many of? Some may say I have too many reds, but they are liars.
Blush color you have too many of? Probably less a specific color and more that I need to tone down my obsession with bold blushes. So much negotiation goes into wearing them on fair skin. 😛

■Your skin tone/coloring: NC 35-40

■Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Neutrals and golds!!!

■Lipstick color you have too many of? Coral, coral pink

■Blush color you have too many of? Coral and pinks 😉

Skin tone : nc 50 in studio fix fluid
Eyeshadow colors: pinks, and purples, and oranges, and blue green any bright color
Lpsticks: I tend to buy a lot of pink shades
Blushes: I only have 3 blushes 2 are pink and one is red (from nars)

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30/NW20
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Neutrals! Especially shades like sin, virgin, retrospect etc.
Lipstick color you have too many of? Nudes!
Blush color you have too many of? Mauve-y? Shades like NYX Silky Rose/Dusty Rose MAC Brit Wit

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30 – NC35
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Dark browns and sparkly nude/creams.
Lipstick color you have too many of? WAY TOO MANY NUDES AND NUDE-PINKS. I’m still buying them in search of the elusive “perfect nude.”
Blush color you have too many of? Corals and peaches!

Skin tone– Light, MUFE 117, freckled

Eyeshadows– Neutrals! Sucker for shimmery champagne colors!

Lipsticks– Nudes/pink toned nudes, and cool toned reds

Blush– Corals! Too many for my own good…. blush hoarder!

Your skin tone/coloring: Light Neutral

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Taupe, a big weakness for taupe.

Lipstick color you have too many of? Peachy pinks- I currently have Dior Spring Ball, Chanel Bagatelle, Guerlain Jardin de Bagatelle, Revlon Peony and Revlon Pango Peach in my purse. All pretty much the same color, but I’m obsessed and in love with all of them!

Blush color you have too many of? They are all variations of pinks or corals.

Very sneaky question…… 😉

It’s a trick question. There is no such thing as too many of any cosmetics product!

Ok, so many I have a thing for lipsticks that are coraly/peachy/orangey.

My name is Monica, and I’m a lipstick addict.

Medium – about NW30
Always come home with golds & bronze eyeshadows, red lipsticks (got Sleek Stiletto today) and peachy blushes (like MAC Style and Sleek Rose Gold)

Your skin tone/coloring: very fair, MAC NC 10
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? taupe and brown
Lipstick color you have too many of? bright and dark red
Blush color you have too many of? pink and red

Your skin tone/coloring:MUFE 155/ UD Naked Foundation 7 (beige tan)

Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Probably pink. I have it in different formulas (cream, shadow, loose) and many different finishes. It seems to flatter my skin color.
Lipstick color you have too many of? I don’t really wear lipstick so I have a pretty good varied collection, and it’s small.
Blush color you have too many of? Probably pink again…! Again in different formulas cream and loose and powder. However, I would say overall my blush collection is varied.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light/Medium Neutral/Cool
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Brown tones like bronzes and taupe
Lipstick color you have too many of? Nude
Blush color you have too many of? Pinky-Peach

NC25 and enough eye shadows and lip products to fill 4 4-drawer Muji containers, the rest of the stuff is on shelves. I rarely buy pallettes, rather singles of what I like.

Eye/Lip/Blush – Too many of any? But they’re all so pretty! Must have them all, because they are all just a little bit different. My skin goes from NW in the winter to NC in the summer. The shades have to be adjusted, so I can wear any color I like, no matter what the season.

Skin tone/colouring ? Light/neutral , brown hair and brown eyes
Eyeshadow colour I have too many of ? An insane amount of champagne colors and many 100’s of shades of brown.
Lipstick colour I have too many of ? hot pinks and milky baby pink lipsticks
Blush colour I have too many of ? Warm natural pink tones, my favorite is Too Faced Cocoa Rose. Those blushes look best on my skin tone because they look very natural and not too pink or too bright on my cheeks!

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20
Eyeshadow color you have too many of? Pale nudes
Lipstick color you have too many of? Red– but my mom always said you can never have too much red lipstick!
Blush color you have too many of? Not blush, bronzers. I have way too many bronzers.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!