Too Faced Peanut Butter & Jelly Eyeshadow Palette
Here’s a quick look at Too Faced Peanut Butter & Jelly Eyeshadow Palette ($36.00 for 0.39 oz.) — testing and reviewing soon! It launches officially on February 28th.)
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
This palette is beautiful. I am getting heavy nostalgia of having my way with a jar of Goobers. Ugh. They must’ve put crack in them because I use to stay eating it by itself. Forget bread, give me a spoon and a tv show.
I’m really not interested in purchasing this at all….. but the packaging is seriously SO cute! I’m definitely a sucker for things like this, but alas, I feel like I wouldn’t get much use out of it personally.
Still, looking forward to the review!
Let me just pretend that I don’t have a serious sulfa allergy for a moment:
So, first of all, I absolutely LOVE these colors! A lot. So much so, that in all likelihood I have dupes coming out of my ears! 2 pans of MAC Saddle, for starters, Amber Lights, Arena, plus others across brands, like UD.
I think this will sell like hotcakes to all warm, toasty neutrals lovers!!!
After reading your mention of sulfa, I did a search and found your previous comments on TF. Sodium saccharine = SULFA! How did I not learn this until now! I know a lot about allergies because of my allergy to corn, but this was a huge surprise. You have helped me solve my toothpaste mystery. Now I have to recheck my cosmetics! Nancy, thank you. Christine, I get so much enjoyment out of this site, but now better health, too.
I want it sooo bad! is it limited edition?
This was on my definitely buy list but now I’m not too sure. A lot of the colors look like what I already have in palettes by them. I know Peanut Butter is the same, but are there any other dupes?
I have no need for this. Absolutely none. I want it just because the idea of it is so cute and comforting.
Yup! You put into words exactly how I am feeling about this palette too!
It looks like this could be a nice palette! Unfortunately, it is FAR too warm for me, so I’ll be giving it a pass.
I do really love those purple shades. I’ll have to check out the review & see what dupes you recommend! ?
My thinking exactly. I am a blue under-toned girl and those colors would be ghastly on me. Even Jammin’ would be too warm a purple for me.
I’m super cool toned too! Even the OG Chocolate Bar can sometimes be too warm for me, if I don’t balance out the transition shades right.
Some people talk about wearing cool tones & looking like they got punched in the face, but if I wear too much warm I just look like crazed and weirdly sick.
(Also: I have the same issue with purples! I love them, but I have to walk a very careful line between warm & cool.)
May need a primer..Doesn’t look horrible. I’m probably going to get it if it can be good with a prime because I love the combo and the tackiness!lol!
I usually like warm neutrals but some of these shades just look too warm. I don’t yellowish orange browns would look very good on me!
Looks like I am in the minority, but I do not love Peanut Butter (I have the original Chocolate Bar); I just find it too orange-y. It’s a cute palette and a fun theme, but it is just too umber/orange for me, with the exception of the purples. I’ll be throwing my $35 at Tarte this time, for the Rainforest of the Sea palette.
Ohhhh I want that Tarte one too!!!
Certainly not for me!
Why?! Oh, God, why there is ALWAYS a pink eyeshadow? WHY!?!?! Are we all 11 years old?
Some of us like pink eyeshadow, even if we’re 46 years old. 🙂 😉
… or on the verge of being 49 years old. 😀
I actually don’t see enough pigmented, pink shadows in palettes! That said, Jelly looks more violet than pink to me.
Yeah, I think it’s violet with a pink sheen. The two violets are supposed to represent the grape jelly.
Cat, have you checked out these pink Coastal Scents palettes? I have them and think they’re great. If you use a shade up or break one, the colors are all available as hot pots so you can replace them.
Think Pink Palette: http://bit.ly/21qBbPY
Winterberry Palette: http://bit.ly/21qB86R
I have the think pink palette! It’s kind of a dupe for Saucebox Forbidden Fruits palette at least it reminds me of it! (I have both) can never have too many pink and purple eyeshadows! ? I was going to get winterberry too, but I have fall festival and realized there’s several repeats between the palettes
Hi, Rachel! ***waves***
Thanks for the links! I’ve browsed the Coastal Scents website a few times and wondered how their eyeshadows compare to other brands. I may even have a single shadow… but I can’t verify as I don’t have access to my entire stash right now. (We’re still working on redoing the master bath and built-in vanity. Hopefully, it will be completed today!)
What are the mattes like? I really like some of the shades in the Think Pink palette and at least four of those appear to be matte. I’m still considering picking up the Too Faced Chocolate Bon Bons palette. How are you liking that?
Most of the mattes are pretty good. Some of the really light ones can lack pigmentation and be a little chalky.
Hit “post” to soon. I’m really liking the Bon Bons palette. It’s put together so nicely. Cashew Chew isn’t the easiest to blend, but the other colors have worked great for me. I find I’m using Satin Sheets as a face highlighter a lot, too.
Or in our late 50s, even. I love pink eye shadow, and like any other color, if it’s not overdone it can be really pretty. It helps the neutrals like various browns really pop.
So true!
I find pink (not all) sophisticated and grown up, and as The Silver nail said, it helps neutrals pop.
Where is the pink eyeshadow? Really, I can’t see it! ?
I love it, and I’m 32! Pinks, even bright ones, can look very chic in eye makeup. Dior even has released a few bright pink eyeshadows, as a single and in a palette. It’s not childish, IMO.
I feel like I an the only one not excited by this. It’s a palette of browns with a purple thrown in. Anyone who’s into makeup likely has all these colors already. It’s boring, but the PBJ cuteness has everyone gushing.
IDK, I love PBJ sandwiches, but the mattes look kind of dry and clumpy, and that Jelly shade lacks oomph 🙁
I want this, but I’m not sure if I can justify it because I was just gifted the Chocolate Bon Bon palette!
Seems like warm browns and oranges are super popular right now but I don’t find them as flattering on me as they are on others, maybe because I’m so pale and cool toned. Super cute packaging and I love the concept of adding in purples and making it a “peanut butter and jelly”. Not to mention that the pigmentation does looks very nice! 🙂
I’ve been waiting for this!! I love it I must own it!
I probably have no business buying this as the colors will without a doubt be too warm for me, but
I am COVETING this palette and it must be MINE!
So on the fence about this palette! It’s adorable but I think I might hold out for the Sweet Peach palette instead.
I need another palette like a hole in the head, but I think I might pull the trigger for this one.
These colours are very dupeable except for Jelly and Nuts about U, so I won’t be buying. Though I do like Jelly, it’s not enough to want the whole palette, it’s way too warm for me otherwise.
I really don’t like these colors….
Colour pay off looks good. The moment I saw the sneak peaks on Instagram I wanted it. But I feel I already own these colours from other brands. I’ll just wait on your review and decide later on.
Hmmm – I don’t like the smell of peanut butter, so this would put me off. Secondly – these colours are similar to the City ones you have just reviewed and for the price, I think I like those ones better. Not really original colours.
It SMELLS like peanut butter too? I missed that but I am seriously going “hmmmm?” For starters, the peanut allergy is pretty widespread AND serious. I don’t know if it’s as big an issue in the US but here in Canada, peanut butter has been banned in many elementary schools. But in general I’ve wondered why there hasn’t been more outcry AGAINST TF’s scented eyeshadow palettes. I have virtually no problem with fragranced products (Guerlain’s heavily scented foundations and powders are a joy to me personally) but I recognize that this IS a big issue for a lot of people. And to put a fragrance (even chocolate) into eyeshadows seems to me just really dumb. And yet so many people are going “Oooooh, I love the yummy chocolate smell….”.
It does not contain any peanut products, according to Too Faced.
It’s supposed to have a light chocolate & PB scent. The reviews I’ve seen say you don’t notice it once it’s on your eyes. Hopefully, it’s not too strong. I’m not a huge fan of the smell of peanut scent either.
I know this is mega late but from what I’ve heard it smells exactly like the chocolate bars and not much like peanut butter at all.
I think mine does smell like a peanut butter cup, but it’s not overwhelming at all.
Hmmm I haven’t been able to smell it personally. I would like one but u just bought the Sweet Peach so I think I’m going to skip this palette for now but I’ll definitely go sniff it at Sephora or something. ???
Yup. Still want. These colors will make the green in my eyes sing.
Very orange. Might be a skip for me
I love the packaging, but I’m sure I have dupes of these.
I just wanna know at this point if it smells like peanut butter.
It’s supposed to have a light chocolate & PB scent. It’s not supposed to be noticeable when you’re wearing the shadows.
Nope. These colors would look awful on my skin tone. Packaging is very cute though.
The packaging is too cute! Honestly I only purchase too faced because of the packaging…not the product…I’m such a shameful consumer LOL
eagerly waiting reviews 😀
I love everything about this palette! Do we know if it’s permanent or limited edition?
Just got this in the mail today. It smells so good! I can’t stop smelling it. Hopefully i can pull off these warm tones.
hell yes .
this is my kind of palette .
i love warm tones .
The swatches for Peanut Brittle and Jammin’ have me intrigued! (And perhaps a bit hungry, too…)
Not my shades! Jelly is a very pretty color, though.
These colours just are not for me. The 2 or 3 I could possibly wear are ones for which I already have dupes. I still have a real soft stop in my heart for TF’s 9 pan palettes (and I wish they’d not discontinued the 2nd Smokey one and Romantic) but this one’s just not for me.
Really want this, but this would be a great example of buying something you already own because you always gravitate toward the same colors. Must resist!
I wanted the Peanut Butter shade in the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Bar palette, but since it was the only one I **did** want, I couldn’t justify the purchase. Am so getting this PB&J one!
I like the look of this, it might be a bit on the warm side, though.
It’ll be interesting to read the reviews.
I was so curious about this idea since I first heard about the palette. It looks cute, is an interesting concept, unconventional color combinations, and it’s scented! But something about it isn’t hitting the mark for me. All these parts are great, but together it’s…off? I don’t know. Looking forward to the review.
These are definitely my kind of colors so I’ve been waiting patiently for tomorrow to use this $40 Google Express credit on it. I cannot wait to finally get my hands on it! A Too Faced artist showed it to me this week and it’s even more beautiful in person and it smells soo good. Too Faced is trying to take all my coins this year!
As someone who loves warm tones, this is even a little too much for me to handle. It’s also too orange and I also feel like the shades are all too much the same. I have the Semi Sweet, but if I am to get another palette from Too Faced, it just may be the BonBon.
As cute as the packaging is, I don’t feel like it’s too practical for me. Plus, I feel as though that there is a lot of colors I won’t really use a lot anyway. :(((
I just ordered this Too Faced palette today. I have medium skin tone with warm undertones and highlighted blonde hair, so these intensely warm-neutral colors are exactly what I look for! I’m very excited to try all of these colors. Of course, like most other makeup junkies out there I didn’t NEED another eyeshadow palette, I purchased this solely based on lust…AND I hope it will be great for travel. 🙂
Cut, but no.
Jammin’ is nice, but I’m sure there are pretty good dupes for that too (as for the rest of the shades).
The colors in the palette are right down my alley. I’ll be playing in peanut butter & jelly all summer!
This palette just came in the post, I am loving the colours and textures. Can’t wait to try different looks with these.
Is this cocoa-scented like a lot of their recent stuff? It’s pretty, but saccharin is not my friend!
I just got this in the mail and I love it!
The Bananas shade looks gorgeous! Great quality swatches as usual