Share: Tell us what you love and hate about Lip Balm in Pots!
my answer: They can be hard to keep really clean (or just more tedious to keep clean, I guess), but I like the often thicker consistency of potted lip balms.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
I don’t use them any more (except at night – I use the Nuxe Reve de Miel one) because I don’t like sticking my fingers into thick goop and I rarely have a moment and a free hand to dig out and use a lip brush.
I love them. I know a lot of people find them unsanitary, but honestly, it’s not that big of a deal to me. I don’t like how, when they’re almost empty, it’s harder to get the product out.
I don’t find them any more “unsanitary” than stick balms. I always use a brush/spatula, anyway, with *all* of my lip products regardless of form, and I actually think it’s grosser to apply directly to the lips (the human mouth is laden with bacteria!) than using a clean finger…
Although my lip-saviour Nuxe Reve de miel comes in a pot I actually dislike potted lipbalms! Its definitely not very hygienic
I’m allergic to most lipbalms, the worst for me is carmex in the pot, my lips gets swollen, red, itchy and sore! I can only use all natural lipbalms, I have found one that I love, and it’s made out of olive oil, beeswax. It’s really annoying to be allergic to lipbalms, because I have really dry lips, and i loove my matte lipsticks! 😉
Some of them tend to be way too hard to get any product out of due to a stiff, dense texture, but I like some of the thicker, creamier ones!
I hate that it gets under my fingernails when I try to get it out of the pot. And I hate that my fingers are balmy afterward. Or you have to carry a lip brush around. I infinitely prefer balms that come in tubes. It’s so much tidier and more convenient
I don’t use potted lip balm anymore because i think it’s too unhygienic and it also annoys me that you have a balmy finger after applying and then have to dig out a tissue to clean it. It’s ok to have one in the bathroom where you use it after washing your hands and can wash the sticky finger afterwards I guess but even then a lip balm stick is way more practical imo.
Same here. I tend to prefer potted lip balms for nighttime because they are often thicker, but as much as I try to keep them clean, sometimes I still catch a cat hair in the pot!
I just can’t. the idea of everything gross and invisible that can pool in there makes me cringe.. I am a “little” bit of a germophobe I have to say though! 😀
I feel the same way. I love Baume de Rose, Nuxe, and Dr.Haushka.
My favorite lip balm is in a pot, but other than the moisturising part I hate it. Unhygienic and gets under your nails…
I feel like they tend to get germy from you sticking your fingers in them constantly. However, like Christine said, they tend to be richer formulas, so I tend to reserve them for nighttime lip balm. I don’t want to use them when I’m out at school and touching super germy surfaces, if that makes sense. Haha!
I have long nails and I hate getting lip balm stuck under them. It’s a waste of lip balm too. Much prefer tubes.
I have 3 cats, so the second I open a potted balm every cat hair within 10ft finds it’s way into the pot.
LOL! Same here, but I have FOUR cats.. 😉
I can’t really rave…as I never use them. Well, that’s not true. Little pots are super cute, or may even be glamorous. I can also say hat I have long wanted to own one of the Korres lip butter ones, so I’m not immune to their charms.
Ranting, however… 😉
I need to (or just do) use lip balm regularly throughout the day. Since I don’t want to wash my hands every 5 minutes, potted lip balm is a terrible way to go! I know I could use a potted one at night/ at home, but part of why I want the Korres ones is the tint/colour. There’s no point smearing my pillowcase with pigment…
I like that they are usually thicker and have awesome moisturizing properties, but I hate having to apply them with my fingers and getting the product under my nails.
Rant: They’re messy to use and have bulkier packaging than tubes.
Rave: They often have better formulas than tube balms and aren’t as waxy.
I like to use potted lip balms at night because I feel like they’re more nourishing for my lips. But I don’t like that they’re in a little pot because I’m paranoid that they lose effectiveness over time.
I just dislike having to use my hands to apply lip balm. I am not a germ-o-phobe but I sometimes need to apply lip balm when my hands are not clean, like on the subway. Plus then I have stuff on my hands.
I wouldn’t carry them with me, but I do keep a pot of Nuxe Rêve de Miel next to my bed at all times, because nothing works better on my lips. I don’t find it that difficult to keep clean, although I’m generally using it right after I’ve washed my hands.
They’re usually very hydrating but not too convenient. I prefer to use a brush to keep things sanitary so it’s not something I’d carry in my purse. They’re only suitable for nighttime use
One thing I like potted lip balm is that, if I accidentally put them in my pocket and they melted, it wouldn’t ruin the shape or affect the consistency since the formula wouldn’t require that much of wax to keep the shape. Other than that, I do the same thing pretty much as every body here, using in the nights so i can always wash my hands before to minimize germ contact, using cotton swab if I can.
The only potted balm I’ve ever really enjoyed was Philosophy’s Kiss Me Tonight. One benefit is that you often get more product in a pot than in other forms. I have noticed that quite a few high-end brands do offer their balms in potted form. I’ve always wanted to try La Mer’s The Lip Balm. Has anyone tried it? Is it worth the splurge?
I don’t like to put my fingers in pots, I always use a brush. I just want to keep my cosmetics uncontaminated, especially things I use on my lips and eyes.
i love rosebud salve in the tinned format! i don’t find it gets too unsanitary, just wash my hands before i use it, or use a q-tip for application
The product gets under my nails!!
I love potted lip balms because they’re usually thicker and more nourishing than sticks or tubes. I only use them right before bed to repair my lips overnight, or just after shower in the morning to nourish before applying makeup.
I never take them in my purse, they stay in my bathroom cabinet, and I only use them with clean hands. It’s easier (and cleaner) to use a small spatula to get some balm out of the pot, especially for the ones with harder consistency.
I only use them at home because they’re just not practical (or sanitary) for on the go.
i don’t think they’re that unhygienic unless you share them or dint keep your hands reasonably clean. I use the top of my fingernail like a spatula to get some out and apply it.
I would use them at night, but I hate using it during the day when I just need some lip balm and I have to stick my fingers in there and put it on my lips XP
I dont mind potted lip balm, but I hate it when products get stuck under my nails