Rant & Rave: Mattifying Face Primers

Share: Tell us what you love and hate about Mattifying Face Primers!

my answer: Sometimes they’re packed with too many silicones, which almost feels like a fake… velvety feel to me? I think I can be pickier with the texture of silicone-heavy products. I love that they help keep makeup lasting longer!

40 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Wwendalynne Avatar

I reach for illuminating face primers rather than mattifying. I recall trying one a number of years back, I think it was the Dior HydraLife version..not really a primer per se, and I just couldn’t stand how ‘heavy’ my face felt and seriously regretted the purchase..completely tossed the entire bottle. I can’t tolerate face products that give a mask feeling. I have not tried a different version since.

tzwiggy Avatar

Ugh, I hate that fake velvety feel! Everytime I use a product like that all over my face I know for sure that I’ll break out. My skin is very oily so I kinda need a mattifying primer, but every single one that I’ve tried have left me with clogged pores, blackheads and breakouts.

Jessica Brown Avatar

They’re an absolute must for me! My skin is so ridiculously oily, especially for someone in her late 30s. I love Murad’s, which has SPF 15β€”that’s my current fave. Some mattifiers make it hard to blend in foundation but this one doesn’t.

NicoleAriel Avatar

I totally agree! I used to LOVE MAC’s skin refine zone treatment, and still do, but with some foundations i use it doesnt blend properly whenever i use that primer in certain areas. My nose especially, it just emphasizes my pores horribly. I’ll have to give the Murad one a try! But the MAC one is great, as long as you find a foundation it works well with. πŸ™‚

Cherry Avatar

I have only tried Illamasqua matt primer, but it didn’t work for me. It did stay matt but my makeup did not last. I so wanted it to work! Any good mattifying primers that you girls would recommend? (requirements: mattifying and making make up last!) πŸ˜€

Lotus Avatar

I dislike the extra step. May I PLEASE divert from this question and ask an emergency beauty question? I’ve tried SO MUCH yet am still unsuccessful at fully removing BB cream/ makeup and I do wash twice and use a clarisonic.. My skin is sensitive and will irritate easily.. PLEASE, WHAT cleanser does anyone recommend for me? I APPRECIATE it more than you know! <3 Lotus

Wwendalynne Avatar

try a Shu Uemera cleansing oil. I find cleansing oils really break down makeup very easily rather than foaming or liquid (detergent) style cleansers.

Lotus Avatar

Bless & THANK YOU! I’ve not used oil before.. May I please ask you use the oil? I was looking into Bioderma Sensibio h2O but it’s a liquid and seems to not feel right. I don’t know how to use oil. Thank you so much for responding! I’m so grateful for all communication. <3

Jenny Avatar

Bioderma Sensibio is amazing! I have two bottles of this stuff. One as backup. I use it to take off eye makeup and BB cream. Bioderma is essentially micellar water and leaves a clean feeling and no residue. When I don’t want to wash off my makeup at night I will put some Bioderma on a few cotton pads and take off my makeup that way. This stuff is expensive $30 on Amazon and $23 on Sasa.com (HK) but very worth it. Bioderma is something that a lot of beauty gurus swear by if you do a quick search.

Lotus Avatar

Hi, Jenny! Thank you so much for chiming in about this! People have been so kind here! That’s wonderful news, and I’m further happy about my purchase, which you’ll be pleased to know I found at a great price and grabbed some ultra soft layered Japanese cottons to boot! Thank you! <3 Lotus

Alanna Avatar

Try fancl mild cleansing oil, I adore it πŸ™‚ you do have to use it up, I believe it expires within 3 months due to having no preservatives

Ally Avatar

Try Bioderma micellar water (called Crealine in Australia, but it’s also called Sensibio elsewhere). It’s perfect for sensitive skin. All you need to do is wet a cotton pad with the bioderma, swipe it off your face and everything comes straight off!

Lotus Avatar

Thank you, Ally! That’s what I was originally looking at and just placed my order for a mere second ago! πŸ™‚ Your reply is quite reassuring and I am grateful for your time. Thank you, again. πŸ™‚ YaY! <3 Lotus

Kate Avatar

I second coconut oil. Coconut oil is inexpensive, just make sure you get a high quality one. It also will not break you out. People hear oil and they can freak out.

I also use Dermalogica’s pre-cleanse which is a cleansing oil. I have extremely oily t-zone + normal to dry rest of my face combo skin. It is also so sensitive I cannot use most products. If I am wearing foundation/CC cream I use pre-cleanse, my face wash, and if I still feel like my skin isn’t clean I use Inglot’s toner.

Kay Avatar

Wayne Goss made a youtube video a few weeks ago about using loose powder (lightly) under your liquid foundation as a primer and it actually works for me! If you don’t want to invest in a new primer and risk breaking out you can use a loose powder you already own and love. Just a thought πŸ™‚

makura Avatar

I have very oily skin with large pores and live in Texas lol. I have tried multiple samples of primers and while some of them do help with foundation initially going on better, NONE of them make my makeup last any longer or keep my oil under control after 3-4 hours. I have tested several foundations with and without primers and see no difference later in the day. So, in a nutshell, I think it’s all hype, an extra step and a waste of money (for me, anyway).

Seana Avatar

Ok, don’t laugh, but the mattifying “primer” that I use is milk of magnesium. I have oily skin and this keeps my face so matte and does not have that icky silicone feel, nor does it break me out. I know it sounds crazy, but it really works for me.

Kate Avatar

Like the one people drink if they can’t poop? I tried to think of a better way to ask that question but that’s the best I can do πŸ™‚

Karen Avatar

One of my favorites on my super oily skin is My Prime Multi Purpose Mattifying Moisturizer because it does more than one job and doesn’t break me out. Not a big fan of the price tag ($68) but totally worth it particularly if pressed for time since it cuts out steps.

Danielle Avatar

I prefer illuminating primers in general. But, if my skin has been more oily or if I’m wearing a foundation that can go a bit greasy (Revlon Nearly Naked), I will wear a mattifying primer on my forehead. That is where I get the most oily.

MonicaP Avatar

I find that mattifying primers are difficult to spread. I’m currently trying out BECCA
Ever-Matte Poreless Priming Perfector and it’s just difficult to apply to my face. Plus, it really doesn’t work all that well .. I still get some shine that I need to blot.

M.

Lotus Avatar

I believe that makeup application, quintessentially, is dependent upon great skin, foremost, and that means doing what we can to take proper are of our skin. If ever we’re lucky to have perfect skin, we won’t need such products like primer or foundations. Until then, I highly recommend Becca’s Resurfacing Primer. It does everything you’d hope for all in one primer, is generously sized, non-irritating, beneficial for skin, and adjusts to whatever your skin needs. I don’t think anything will create a matte look except for a finishing powder to blot oil as needed. Wayne Goss did an application he swears by, as can be watched on YouTube, which is odd yet he “says,” and it’s prepping skin with either moisturizer or primer and pressing a translucent finishing powder into that to set it THEN applying foundation. He claims the foundation is going over a smoothly finished canvas which makes application and wear time high improved. (I have no thoughts on this, I’m just contributing as best as I can for the cause of the post) πŸ™‚

Elisa Avatar

Thanks for explaining goss’s reasoning. I haven’t watched his video but saw the technique on twitter and was wondering why he recommended it. I have tried it, but haven’t paid attention to results or lack thereof yet.

SandraJT Avatar

I detest silicone primers. Every single one I’ve tried has been horrible crap which breaks me out. Two great mattening face primers WITHOUT silicones, which took me years to find:

1) Nurturing Force Blot Out – aloe vera based, and absolutely spectacular; can be used alone over moisturizer, under foundation – liquid/cream/wax based/loose mineral – to prevent oil breakthrough, over makeup for blotting oil, or as an eye base for those with super oily lids which are prone to creasing. I can’t say enough good things about this product.

2) Becca Ever-Matte Poreless Priming Perfector

The first one is by far the best and is around $25. Camera Ready Cosmetics sells it.

I found the Becca primer at Sephora, and it’s significantly more expensive (about $45 Canadian), but doesn’t have as many quality ingredients. I’ll be taking this one back as Nurturing Force Blot Out is far superior.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! πŸ™‚ If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!