By Ana Maria 3 years ago.
Like Christine, I consider the Pro Longwear Eyeliner disappointing. I used the `Rich Experience` color, which is a beautiful dark warm brown (matte from my point of view), that puts a nice emphasys on brown eyes, without being as harsh as a black eyeshadow. The pencil glides smoothly, since it's a creamier formula; it's still not very creamy (not the kind that you will put all over the lid), so I can get thinner or thicker lines as I wish. It's not opaque from the first layer on the eyelids, but the opacity can be build.
On the waterline this pencil doesn't last more than 2-3 hours, than disappears. On the lid and under eye it starts fading during the day. This isn't long-lasting at all.
I found this pencil much more easier to sharpen than other MAC eye pencils/liners.