OCC Heroine Lip Tars – Black Dahlia, Lydia, Marion, Psycho, Starling, Sybil Reviews, Photos, Swatches


OCC Fall Lip Tars

OCC Heroine Collection: 6 New Lip Tars

OCC Fall 2012 Lip Tars ($16.00 for 0.33 oz.) sees the launch of six new shades: Black Dahlia (blackened red), Lydia (darkroom plum), Marion (deceitfully dirty rose), Psycho (dripping with blood red), Starling (deeply rusted red), and Sybil (midnight brownout). The six shades are inspired by the brand’s favorite horror movie heroines.

Black Dahlia is a blackened red with a touch of brown-burgundy. It has a very lip stain-like appearance on the lips. It doesn’t quite get opaque without over-applying the product. It’s fairly even, and at a distance, it definitely looks even. This shade wore eight hours and stained for another two. MAC Soulfully Rich is less red. MAC Prince Noir is less red, darker. Chanel Maniac is darker. Milani Black Cherry is lighter. MAC Media is browner, redder, and lighter.

Lydia is a medium-dark pink plum with even, opaque color coverage. I’d say this is the most “wearable” of the six and rather universally flattering. It lasted for seven hours on my lips. MAC Hot Gossip is lighter, pinker. MAC Plumful is pinker, sheerer. MAC Flaunting It is more purple, sheerer. Make Up For Ever is frosty.

Marion is a lightened peach-brown with opaque color coverage. It needed very little product for full, even color. This wore for seven hours. Burberry Heather Rose is darker. CoverGirl Delish is a touch pinker. Guerlain Gracieuse is similar but has shimmer.

Psycho is a bright orange-red–very fiery–with opaque color payoff. It applies evenly and smoothly It lasted for eight hours on my lips.. MAC Sail la Vie is similar. MAC Scarlet Ibis is redder. Giorgio Armani #405 is more orange and has shimmer. Dolce & Gabbana Sheer is glossier.

Starling is a rusted, reddened brown. It yielded full color coverage and went on evenly. This shade wore for seven hours. Cle de Peau Danse de Feu is lighter and has shimmer. Make Up For Ever #20 is a bit redder.

Sybil is a deep, dark chocolate brown with subtle reddish undertones. This shade lasted for eight hours.  It was extremely pigmented and applied opaquely and evenly. MAC Chestnut is not quite as dark/rich. MAC Seeds of Desire is redder. MAC Film Noir is lighter, warmer.

Beginning today, Sephora will be carrying the new six shades, but more noteworthy, is that Lip Tars sold through Sephora will be sold in an eco-friendly vinyl bag along with instructions and a mini precision lip brush–just to help newcomers to all that is Lip Tar learn the ropes a little more easily! Lip Tars are best applied with a brush and with very, very little product. As in a dot or two of product, not a dollop or glob. It’s not a gloss, and it’s way, way more pigmented than the majority of liquid lipsticks on the market. If you over-apply, the product may bleed/feather, and it will easily get onto teeth, too.

Lip Tars are extremely pigmented, long-wearing, and dry down to a satin-matte finish with just a slight sheen.  They’re not drying, and I don’t find that they bleed or feather on me, but very few products do, so take that with a grain of salt.  They are mint-scented and come in small, squeeze tubes but are meant to be applied with a lip brush. Black Dahlia was the only shade that wasn’t opaque, and overall, had a slightly different texture (and definitely a different look) than the majority of OCC’s Lip Tar range.

OCC Heroine Lip Tars – Black Dahlia, Lydia, Marion, Psycho, Starling, Sybil Reviews, Photos, Swatches

A
10
Product
9.5
Pigmentation
10
Texture
10
Longevity
4
Application
97%
Total
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


OCC Fall Lip Tars


Exclusive Sephora Packaging


Exclusive Sephora Packaging

OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar
OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar

OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar
OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar

OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar
OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar

OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar
OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar

OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar
OCC Black Dahlia Lip Tar

OCC Lydia Lip Tar
OCC Lydia Lip Tar

OCC Lydia Lip Tar
OCC Lydia Lip Tar

OCC Lydia Lip Tar
OCC Lydia Lip Tar

OCC Lydia Lip Tar
OCC Lydia Lip Tar

OCC Lydia Lip Tar
OCC Lydia Lip Tar

OCC Marion Lip Tar
OCC Marion Lip Tar

OCC Marion Lip Tar
OCC Marion Lip Tar

OCC Marion Lip Tar
OCC Marion Lip Tar

OCC Marion Lip Tar
OCC Marion Lip Tar

OCC Marion Lip Tar
OCC Marion Lip Tar

OCC Psycho Lip Tar
OCC Psycho Lip Tar

OCC Psycho Lip Tar
OCC Psycho Lip Tar

OCC Psycho Lip Tar
OCC Psycho Lip Tar

OCC Psycho Lip Tar
OCC Psycho Lip Tar

OCC Psycho Lip Tar
OCC Psycho Lip Tar

OCC Starling Lip Tar
OCC Starling Lip Tar

OCC Starling Lip Tar
OCC Starling Lip Tar

OCC Starling Lip Tar
OCC Starling Lip Tar

OCC Starling Lip Tar
OCC Starling Lip Tar

OCC Starling Lip Tar
OCC Starling Lip Tar

OCC Sybil Lip Tar
OCC Sybil Lip Tar

OCC Sybil Lip Tar
OCC Sybil Lip Tar

OCC Sybil Lip Tar
OCC Sybil Lip Tar

OCC Sybil Lip Tar
OCC Sybil Lip Tar

OCC Sybil Lip Tar
OCC Sybil Lip Tar

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

About the Reviewer

Christine has normal-to-dry skin with areas of dryness (cheeks, nose, and under the eyes). She has a light-medium skintone with subtle, warmer yellow undertones. Her best foundation matches include: Tarte Rainforest of the Sea in Light-Medium Neutral (best match), Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup in Desert Beige 2N1, Giorgio Armani Maestro Glow in 4.0, Hourglass Warm Ivory Vanish Seamless Finish, Laura Mercier Candleglow Soft Luminous in Dusk, MAC NC20/NC25, Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Liquid in Y305 (140). (For more information, please check the FAQ.)

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

121 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic.

Please do not ask if/when a review will be posted as we cannot review everything and often change priorities from day-to-day. If you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us. Thank you!

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

I’m interested in trying Marion but I have my eye set on Nars Honolulu Honey. They seem similar, HH not as opaque perhaps. Hmmm. Quite interesting, as usual for occ.

Thanks for the review. I love lip tars and I want OCC Lydia lip tar, but it looks exsctly like Wet n’ Wild Mega Matte 907C “Mauve Outta Here” (which I already own).

Why do these not work with my chemistry? Not only do I love these take no prisoner shades, except Lydia which wouldn’t work with my coloring, but they have brillz names!

Christine, I don’t see these listed on the Sephora website. Do you know if they are only available in store today? I don’t see them on the OCC site either.

You might have to give them a moment since the review went up at 6AM 🙂 I was told by OCC that 9/17 was the launch date, but they didn’t given a specific time!

These are all so, SO gorgeous. I have been following your blog for years now, and I still haven’t made the plunge with OCC. I don’t think I can put it off anymore, especially since you can get these at Sephora now. I’m so excited to swatch these on myself and see how they look on my skintone.

These look really fabulous on you, Christine with the exception of the chocolate brown which doesn’t hit the right chord for me unless you are going for ghoulishly beautiful 🙂 I’m tempted by a couple of these colours and the amazing part of OCC lips tars is how easy it is to mix and match shades to create your own unique look.

Thanks for the review, Christine! They look scrumptious! Black Dahlia looks like MAC Dark Side to me. How do they compare? I love the colour but don’t want to double up if they are too similar!

As these wear off, how do they leave the lips? I mean, you said Black Dahlia stains, but what about the rest? Is it a gradual fade or do they pill or leave you with a colorful (and always attractive) ring-around-the-mouth ? Also, how do they hold up to food/drink? As always, thank you so much for all your hard work! You rock!

P.S. – Lydia looks great on you, so pretty!

The lighter colors didn’t stain, but darker ones do. They don’t pill and gradually fade, and you can eat/drink with these on!

Wow, this is the first time I’ve found the Lip Tars to look like they’d actually be wearable! I really like Starling, Psycho, Lydia, and Marion. The others are not bad, either, but much too dark for my skin tone.

Plum! *happy flails* I’m loathe to buy lip products (er, most products, really) without seeing them in person, so here’s to hoping my Sephora eventually gets the Lip Tars. Lydia is such a gorgeous shade — and (finally!) a violet-undertoned lip colour that isn’t frosty!

(Is it just me, or do they tend to be? Maybe it’s just the ones I’ve stumbled across.)

Sybil on you couldn’t be more perfect. Now I understand wearing it on your wedding day is probably out of the question, but the creative department is voting for Black Dahlia. I myself, being strange and unusual, recommend Lydia. Smashing on you. And thank you so much,

I still do not see the lip tars in the Sephora site.

Have you heard anything about and new lip tar sets? I spoke to a rep and she said that there might be a few exclusive sets for Sephora only. I hope that they will be available on their site soon. It is just a better deal to get the lip tars in a set. I hope that they come out with a primary color set to.

Hey Ericka,

It looks like only “Nylon” is on the website for the moment, but I was able to locate 3 shades (NSFW, Nylon, and Grandma — LOL at the name of that last one) in a brick and mortar location. I think there’s a post on here with the OCC tag that lists which other locations will have these colors on their shelves.

Otherwise, I guess we are stuck buying them online, which is kind of a pity because I hate paying for shipping!

These colors seem oddly…safe maybe? I always like that OCC has really unique shades, even if I haven’t gotten to test out the formula yet, but I think I have lipsticks similar to most of these. But I do love the names, even if “heroine” seems a little odd to describe Marion and Sybil…

Yes, MAC makes a secret out of their Pro products, especially the Lip Mix.
I just bought some of them yesterday but I haven’t had the time to play with them yet.
Thank you anyways!

I have 14 MAC Lipmix colors. I have brown, blue, burgundy, orange, yellow, red, violet, black, white, magenta, fuchsia, crimson, pink, and gloss. Some of the shades I have are discontinued. The MAC brown lipmix looks more like a medium brown compared to OCC Sybil. The OCC Black Dahlia looks like MAC burgundy lipmix. The lipmix tend to have a thicker texture like mixture of a gloss and a paste with a satin finish. The newer shades of lipmix like magenta seems to have a thinner texture compared to the older lipmix. It is really not a major difference. The OCC lip tars seem to have a very thin water like texture. I am not sure which one of these lip products will wear the longest. I will test that out once I get the new lip tars. I get about 6 or more hours of wear with the lipmix. The lipmix does not list an expiration date (I’m guessing that they don’t expire) and this is not a vegan item. The OCC lip tars expire after 12 months and they are vegan. Either way, I’m not really sure that I would finish either one within 12 months. Both tubes do contain the same amount of product.

Thank you for your help! If there’s no major difference I won’t bother to get the Lip Tar; I would have to order online and that means customs, waiting etc. (We live a bit under a rock here in Germany when it comes to make-up… ;))
Thanks again!

The lip tars have a bigger color range and they are vegan but they last 12 months after opening. The lipmix does not expire but they have a smaller color selection and you do have to order them from a pro only store. The textures of the two are a little different but they both do the same thing. I am glad that I was able to help.

Will they bring in any other colors? Having Nylon as the only option sucks. I personally think its atrocious. The other colors, such as the ones here, are gorgeous and I would like them! But Sephora has the Nylon Lip Tar labeled as “online only” sadly. :/ At $21 with shipping, it’s not worth it from Sephora!

I think lip tars are just not for me. I have yet to find a color I’d want to wear. Maybe I’m just too boring with my lip choices? I don’t know.

I want them so bad.

If I could afford it, i’d probably get all of the lip tar shades and mix it together to wear a new colour everyday XD

I personally am not comfortable wearing something so opaque, but wow those are beautiful products! Absolutely worth the price for the amount you get and how long it will last you.

Black Dahlia is beautiful!!! I’m heading to NY in November so I might pick this one (and LOTS of other makeup we can’t get easily in Australia) up from Sephora! yay!

Mietta: occ has a shop in Lower Manhattan. You could go there and try everything! They also make ‘Loose Color Concentrate’, pigments to use almost anywhere, and foundations and concealers. And nail polishes. And more!

Okay, I definitely want to check out Black Dahlia and Marion. I love the names for all of these by the way, and soo happy they’re at Sephora! Much more accessible that way 😉

I found that my local Sephora (small city, not a store that gets anything exclusive) has three shades currently: Anime, NSFW, and Grandma. Even if these aren’t shades you’re interested in, you can test out the formula! According to the employees, all Sephora stores have these three right now. 🙂

I am a HUGE fan of OCC Lip Tars. I’ve owned the Bright & Neutral set from Beauty.com for a while now and I really do love them. They are super long wearing, don’t dry my lips out and my favorite part is that they are easy to mix so I can blend my own custom colors. You only need the tiniest bit to get a full lip application so 1 tube lasts a super long time. I’m really excited about these new colors, and really glad that they are finally available at Sephora.

I have to say Christine you look amazing with all the lip tar colors I have seen you review!! If it wasn’t for you I would’ve never gotten my lovely Femme and Chlorophyll lip tars. Now I want Black Dahlia, Starling, and Sybil added to my collection 🙂

It’s not drying, but it’s not really moisturizing – it’s somewhat, if only because it has to be if it doesn’t leave lips feeling dehydrated after wearing it for 12 hours! It can feather if you apply too much.

I’ve not tried Black Dahlia, but Violet Edition is great. Based on Christine’s photos, I’d say VE is similar, but a little less red, and the finish is obviously glossier, but like all the Glossy Stains, it has great wear time!

I brought Black Dahlia and I LOVE IT only problem is it can tend to bleed a bit. I was wondering if anyone a good lip liner for in a corresponding color.

Personally, I really like the Black Dahlia & Sybil on you 🙂 There’s just something about them on you that I like better than any of the other colors. I also have a question for you. I have fair skin with golden undertones. Colors like olive/moss green, browns, mustard yellow, rust, and there was this shade of blue that would have been similar to the tint of those that I can wear well work on me. Do you think either of those two colors of lip tar would work well on me? Thank you.

Hey Christine, I know this is an old post but do you know any drug store brands that carry a similar lipstick shade to Black Dahlia? I want to try the color on me before I take the $16 plunge. Thank you!

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!