Archived Post
Explore Temptalia
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Compare Any Two
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
99 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
I’m sooo excited for this collection! the msf’s look sooooo pretty!
christine what are those things on the third picture? any good? would you buy it?
I think you’re talking about the shadesticks? They’re pretty much very similar to the paint pots; they’re bases to make eyeshadow colors pop.
Those are the shadesticks :))
The shadesticks? I used to have some, but I prefer pigments for bases myself!
ahhh love!!!
I’m lovin the shadesticks in red velvet & penny, sweet thing lipstick, st. germain lipstick, and lollipop loving lipstick. I also want the dear cupcake eye shadow. I’m not really feeling the shades of the msf’s or lipglosses…
everything is so cute!
I love the shadows
OMG! I can’t wait! =)
I’ll have to pass on this collection, but I WILL take one of those cupcakes…lol.
same! I’d even be happy making the cupcakes
lol i second that!
I want it ALL!
yep I’m definitely passing on this collection. So broke after the HK collection!
This is horrible, I hate when make-up makes me hungry. I think I’ll take a shadestick and a yummy MSF.
LOL I soooo agree 🙂 I saw the picture and am considering walking to the local bakery and buying a cupcake or two…the awful part is I had a big breakfast less than an hour ago….Oh yea and the make-up looks super fab as well.
That would have to be my favourite promo photo ever.
Thanks for the new desktop background 😉
I got my hands on a couple of the shadesticks early, will link you my review video when I do it!
made it my background too 🙂
Not sure if I’m going to get anything from this collection…I guess I’ll have to see it out in stores.
Um I love cupcakes and I love mac. Thank you for the porn!
ugh i want all the shadows and the shade sticks hahaha why me
I may buy a gloss, only if they are sticky and long lasting.
I’m so after the MSFs and the shadesticks!!!! I also want Lollipop Loving and Seasonal Peach nail lacquer!
Oh gosh i cant wait!
Since I don’t use shadesticks I’m not sure this collection is all that appealing to me. Though I will have to get all the eyeshadows especially since I missed Aquavert from a previous collection. And sadly, after BBR I’m so over the MSFs? I have those and I feel like I’m OK without more.
MAN, mac needs to come out with a crappy collection soo we can save some money!
haha i have more LE stuff than the products from the permanent line………
do you think the pro discount will apply to the shade sticks too, since they are in colored package?
im prayin the pro discount applies.. they dont look like any special packaging.. so im prayinggg haha
yeah me too cuz i want like the whole collection(minus the lipglosses they look weird so im only getting one to see if they are any good) im going to mac frirst thing in the am the day of the release!! hehe
This collection looks so yummy; I can’t wait!
I dont know what I want more, the MAC or the cupcakes
Yeah ME TOO…..I would dig into the cupcakes first!!! hA!!!! Then I would check out the makeup. HA!
Yay!! Shadesticks!!!
Makeup and sweets- that is just too much for me to handle. Those are my biggest weakness. M.A.C. has gone too far now. *faints*
ugh i’m so sad. I’m on a no makeup buy for Lent…i’m really wanting those shadesticks and MSFs. poop!
I’m on a no junk food for lent – and there’s photos of cakes everywhere!
OMG! Why did you have to say that? Now I’m gonna feel guilty buying makeup during lent! DAGNABBIT!!!!!!!!!!!….OK I guess I’ll join you in the effort. 🙁
When’s the launch date online? I need to plan my purchase already! LOL.
Oh man.. I just emptied my allowance for makeup on Hello Kitty! Great. I love .. LOVE the collection. Maybe just the MSFs and shadesticks. :/
Seriously, makeup porn rocks.
I am VERY excited about this collection!!
I want 4 out of the 5 lipglosses (not the brown one), 4 out of the 5 shade sticks (not Penny), I already have Club and Creme de Violet, so I will get Aquavert and Cupcake e/s. I don’t care for MSFs. I already have 14 and barely reach for them, so I’ll pass on those. I also want the Peppermint Patti nail polish, Bubbles and Saint-Germain l/s. I still have Lollipop Lovin’ from Heatherette and I really don’t care for it (not the best color on me). I like the #34 lashes but they are perm so I can buy them anytime.
I cannot wait for the shadesticks! The eyeshadows look awesome.
I am really excited to try out the glosses, they look so cool. As for the other items, nothing really too eyecatching, maybe one of the lipsticks or one of the eyeshadows, won’t really know til I swatch them for myself.
Do we know how much the lipglosses are yet? Maybe I’ll get ONE if it’s a decent price. If not, I’m passing on the collection.
It all just reminds me of Easter Sunday, lol. And I’m kind of skeptical about those glosses — they’re just for looks right? Seems really gimmicky. I mean, once you move the brush around those pretty little stacked colors are just going to muddy.
i can’t wait to test the msf’s!!i think i will be getting at least 1 of them need to test them first though
looks like I’ll be passing on this. Maybe a pink lipstick and the purple eyeshadow simply because those are my fave colors.
What is with this promo pic…the model looks HORRIBLE IN THAT MAKEUP!!
I never use shade stick before maybe i’ll try some from this collection. I think I’ll pass on those glosses they look blah.
I still haven’t decided on what I want for this collection, my list changes everyday. I love the cup cake promo pic though. I always collect different kinds of sprinkles and stuff. I love making cakes and cupcakes.
I just got Saint Germain l/s as a back2mac yesterday (as it is a perm in Europe) and I Love it !!
I so want one of those msf but the shadesticks (except for red velvet) are kinda boring (I already have penny so …)
and I just don’t know what to think of the glosses, I’m not sure the three layer thing is very nice looking (messy when you use them I bet !) … but the e/s why not LOL
and am I the only one to find the model absolutely granny looking with the hair and the makeup and all ?!
I’ll be getting Bubbles l/s, Aquavert e/s, Peppermint Patti n/l, Perfect Topping MSF, and all the shadesticks minus Penny.
I’m no too sure on the l/g, I’ll probably get one to try out, but the look as though they’ll be extremely sheer…
Also, I hate MAC’s product photos. They are so off, color wise. How hard must it be to make them look like the actual product???
Ooohhhh!!! I’m laughing so hard!
The Dazzleglasses are modeled on those Jello and Cool Whip parfait things that looked so hypnotic to kids back in the days when TV was all perfect families (white families) and perhaps that explains the model shot.
Because-
Minstrel make up isn’t nice, even in MAC pinks. And the model shot is the maid/ cook and the black girls are furious! They should be. I’m horrified and wondering if I’ll completely boycott this collection. Probably so. Maid uniform cut to the clothes, the modern mammy wig, I called and read the riot act and apparently MAC was hearing about it all over. The pastry shots are new.
I’m white and grew up on a plantation in the Deep South in the Sixties. And live in a mixed neighborhood in New Orleans. The huge painted mouth pushes it too far. There’s some specific meanings to all of the clothes and makeup and hair. Ugly ones.
There’s no reason to drag out Amos and Andy. There’s so many Granny ladies who cook and are beautiful in their own way- why not just feature an old lady instead of winding up with a caricature made of a young woman? Hundreds of older black women can cook those cupcakes and actually have that wig and get it crooked. It could have been done with such love instead of dragging out symbols of a brutal past.
Jeez, even without the giant pink lips it wouldn’t be so bad but that’s just too stereotypical for words. Offensive!
You may be over reaching. It’s an ugly photo IMO, but I’m pretty sure that wasn’t what they subconciously were going for. I’ve seen versions of that wig on plenty of people, white and black, and although she would have been better served with a different lip color it’s not like she’s skinnin and grinnin all in the photo. I could be wrong though.
The pic is just horrid! I’m sorry, even if its MAC, they simply goofed. The young lady is sooooo pretty for them to make a parody out of her face!
How is it negative!? I believe your perception is way off. I see a beautiful black woman in pajamas. MAC is known for doing extreme, out of the ordinary makeup. Don’t look at the negative so much. This is an editorial shot about makeup, it’s not to insult anyone, it gives a theme of slumber parties and cupcakes, all things girlie in my point of view!
I can totally see where the previous comment is coming from – the image is very Mammy/Minstrel show and, especially in the south, it can be an issue. If this is meant to be forward or edgy it has missed the mark by a long shot. Do a google image search of mammy or minstrel show to understand the meaning behind it and why some folks may be offended.
I think you have a bit too much time on your hands or a little too much skepticism in your heart.
They are a makeup company. They aren’t trying to bring back black oppression.
This pic may be ugly, but it isn’t racist. Wow.
LOL nice try.
You know what a racist company MAC is, of course.
What’s their motto? “Only white straight women”, right?
LOL.
what I find sad about this is that I thought the same thing when I first saw this photo, but told myself I was looking too far into it — yet that was my intuition, not something I saw after I studied the picture. It seems to be attempting to be sarcastic, but it does so poorly, and comes off offensive instead. quite out of character for M-A-C.
a lot of people are going to say you read way too much into this line, but i think that that was a really brilliant analysis of the elements of it. clever girl! i also think that contrary to the rest of the people that the contrasting colors on the models face look great! very modern!
i am definitely getting lollipop loving lipstick and at least one of the msfs. i might get one of the lip glosses, but ill have to see them in stores, they look like they could be really good
I still have my old lollipop loving and the st. germain looks very like the a lilac dust I have, plus the Lavendar whip, and another lavendar lippie from Versace (YES, more expensive but the color payoff is fabulous). I got these Versace’s in Europe last year — 6 different colors, and they are all being channelled by MAC (I realize production is a year back). Then again, I tend to look at the business end of the makeup industry:)
Nay.
Definitely getting those MSFs and probably the two purple/pink lipsticks. Lovely pictures. 🙂
Maybe…it is a pretty cute collection.
I didn’t get mammy/maid from her outfit – it looked very 60s Mary Tyler Moore to me…but what do I know. I got fun, mod, candy-colored frosting. *licks screen*
I thought it looked like a oompa loompa. *shrugs*
lol, I thought it was pyjamas
I get the impression that maybe she works in the “sweet shop” even.
I don’t know what a maid has to do with cupcakes and sweets.
The shadesticks look great 🙂
I love it ALL. I think this is going to be my favourite collection 🙂
How much for the lipgloss and MSF????? I LOVE this collection! Thank God Sunday is my birthday….birthday money let’s take a trip to MAC!! Woo-Hoo! 🙂
pink blue blue gloss looks interesting…
i’ve never used a shadestick (because everyone says paint pots are better), but i’m tempted to get at least one from this collection simply because the new packaging looks pretty. i don’t have any pink bases anyway, so i might just pick one of these up.
OMG I am DYING over these and especially the pics of the cupcakes with makeup. I am a cupcake junkie, soooo cute. That green polish looks awesome!
Ha! I think the picture is more cartoonish than minstrelsy, but I like that people are watching for things like that. Way to keep MAC on their toes!
Pastels are something I haven’t quite figured out how to pull off, so it’s easy for me to say I won’t be getting much from the collection. We’ll see what the swatches look like, though.
I want the Perfect Topping MFS.
(:
I’m so lovin’ this collection. Must save up money!! lol
I’m hungry just even looking at the model! The green hair! Doesn’t it look like the sugary thing you’d see in the fair? and the cupcakes! the cupcakes!!!
ahhhhh! so cute ^___^
cant wait for swatches!
the MSF’s look so pretty specially one on the right
i cannot wait till this collection comes out! i gotta start saving up again!
these are gorgeous! i haven’t been this excited about a new mac collection in a long long time.
this whole collection is friggin amazingg! (:
Not too keen on lipglosses, they dont seem to pigmented
But in love with the msfs and the shadows. (:
This is one collection I’m super excited about! Everything looks sooo yummy… 😉
when does this come out?
Something about this collection messes with my head…..it may be those glosses. *scratching head*
I’ll pass!
oooh i want the eyeshadow the purple one!!
i dont think its a race offence ,the lipstick and wig is just retated on her but other then that she looks great .mac has made some goofy pictures with women of the opposit race and they looked goofy so i wont get offended by this.note that i was when i first say this
0h my GOD when is this comin` out?
I wanna eat them, edible? hehe c(=
March 19th!
Can you post up how much they will be?
Thanks much , this website is such a GREAT help [:
i’m definitely buying the lipglosses and the shadows! MAC is such an addiction
W0W already? :[ I`m still broke from the HK collection. L0L
What is up with that silver lipstick. Ewww…….I do like the MSF’s though. Everything else is blah.
Liking the collection, but not the girl with green hair. It just doesn’t look pleasing to me.
I really want a cupcake right now lol
Haha, me too!
The Promo image looks amazing!