Hit List: Best Coral Lipstick

What’s the Best Coral Lipstick that you’ve tried?

Share your pick!  And don’t forget to share why 🙂

I’m loving Estee Lauder’s Defiant Coral lately!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

84 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.

Just so you know, MAC’s Mineralize Rich lipstick in Lady At Play looks exactly the same on me as Toying Around, and I actually think the formula is more forgiving for how it looks on the lips and seems to be a little longer lasting than Toying Around.

the best COLOR is mac vegas volt…however, it is nowhere near the best formula. i can make it work for a few hours by putting a ton of lip balm on, lightly applying, blotting, powdering through a tissue, and then reapplying. definitely not ideal. i actually returned this because i hated the formula and then bought it again because i couldn’t find anything else with a close enough color.

it sinks into my lip lines a bit. if feels kind of creamy, but it turns a little flakey (especially towards the inner lip so it looks like a have a bunch of gunk on my lips). it also makes my lips feel dry, so i can’t explain why powdering helped, but it did. i don’t get a long with mac lipsticks in general (not nearly as bad as nars though). if you don’t have a problem with their lipsticks, it might be fine for you.

No, I’m not the biggest fan of MAC lipsticks either. They catch on every flake so I need to exfoliate before. The inner lip gunk only happens with my lip crayons though. Bourjois’ peach on the beach and Revlon’s mischievous. It makes the product such high maintenance.

Mac sea sheer because it has right amount of color with warm undertones which makes it wearable for me without any effort 🙂

I love the Lipstick Queen Endless Summer lipstick in Stoked! Normally I like bold, opaque lipsticks, but this one is a nice semi-sheer wash of coral with SPF and a glossy finish. My perfect summer lip.

Guerlain Gipsy Rouge G is amazing and I’m totally loving it this summer. I also really like Bite Beauty Cin Cin, it’s not as bright and in your face since it leans more red on my lips.

Chantecaille Lip Chic in Sunrise is till my standard go to coral. I have been wearing Dior Fluid Line in Rieuse,( which is a great coral) lately quite a bit also!

Coral lipsticks are among my favorite shades to wear. Right now I am loving “Classic Coral” by Southern Magnolia Minerals. It is hydrating, opaque, not too bright and only semi matte. It is a great color for summer.

Maybelline Shocking Coral is a favorite. Also Silk Naturals B-52 is a lovely juicy coral and Jane is a more floral coral. Both are bright without being overpowering and the formula is lovely.

I’m in the same boat. Not really sure if it’s considered a coral, but MAC Peach Blossom is a favorite. Also, someone mentioned MAC Flamingo. I’ll have to check that one out

Great question. I’ll keep checking any recommendations. Any I’ve tried look hideous on me, simply hideous. So far I’ve only been able to go with a light peach.

I like Maybelline’s Shocking Coral if you like the very bright shades, but my NW10 skin definitely pulls the pink tone to the forefront. I feel your pain, though – I love coral, and it is just not NW friendly. ;-;

I have over 50 coral lipsticks alone so I have a ton of favs lol. MAC Vegas Volt is one of my favorites, but I think my #1 would be YSL Peach Passion. I’m looking to find YSL Rose Paris too because the color is absolutely GOOOORGEOUS. But I can’t find it anywhere…same with MAC Betty Bright!

I live on the pink side of coral, but my favorites are Guerlain Attrape-Coeur for a pop of color and Dior Addict Charmante for just a wash of pinky-coral.

golden rose velvet matte lipstick 6
not very common brand but my oh my those matte lipsticks are the best i’ve ever tried and #6 is gorggg. look it up online and on ebay.

I don’t particularly love coral lip products, but I do like Revlon’s Smoked Peach (wearable) or MAC Sushi Kiss (fun)!

So many to choose from! For summer, I’ll go with Mac Costa Chic. It’s a frost – rubbed into the skin, it is not visibly frosty and an inoffensive but bright coral. If applied full on, it’s gorgeous, frost in a good way and very bright pink-coral, medium dark. Amazing with a tan!

I’m loving Estée Lauder’s Defiant Coral too Christine. It’s so pretty and it’s the first Estée Lauder lippie I’ve bought in years. I also love how the magnetic bullet snaps back together when you close it (lol).

Been dying to get this one but I moved away from the Sephora I used to go to all the time. (sorta better for my wallet, at least in the cosmetics regard!) Next time I go, I’m definitely grabbing it. That and Stila Liquid Lip Colors in Carina and Tesora!

The only one so far that has worked with my cool toned fair skin is MAC Flamingo. It’s a light milky coral that isn’t too orange for my skin.

I wish the Estée Lauder Pure Colour line had worked for me, I had heard so many good things about the formula but when I tested several colours, including defiant coral, they were patchy on me. 🙁 Been loving YSL #33 – Rose Neilia.

YSL Rouge Pur Contour-Coral Poetique orange pink coral with satin finishes. I love many coral lipsticks but this YSL never make my lip dry 😉 it’s super moisturizing and the color stays for so long

MAC Vegas Volt or Sushi Kiss.
I like Maybelline Shocking Coral but it pulls almost neon pink on my skin tone which is pretty tan.

I like this for all the good suggestions. I enjoy Coral 🙂

Ohhhhh, Mac Ablaze is the same EXACT color as Watch Me Simmer but it’s a Matte finish so I’m love that one a little more….

OH and for all of you in Australia… Kit Cosmetics Lipstick in Freedom Fighter. It goes on coral orange, then stains coral-pink, and is hydrating to boot… I URGE all Aussie girls to check it out!!

How to choose?! I’m obsessed with coral lipstick. I love the wearability of MAC See Sheer and Bobbi Brown Carnation. For texture it goes to Givenchy Rose Dressing. My favorite brights are MAC Vegas Volt and Bobbi Brown Cabo Coral. See, I can’t pick just one.

Coral is a color I love but don’t wear extensively due to the fact that my undertones don’t let it stay coral. I generally only wear it in the summer months, and in my collection, I really only have two – Bobbi Brown Party Alice and Maybelline Shocking Coral. The former is great for a more muted coral and it’s just warm enough to avoid going pink. The latter is just fun and bright, though it definitely pulls pink on me.

My all time favorite has been MAC Crosswires, but recently I’ve discovered MAC Vegas Volt and Milani Flamingo Pose. Now, i can’t choose only one of them.

I’m a true NC42, I have medium dark/tan with golden-olive undertone and I loooovvvee… Dolce & Gabbana Cosmopolitan for true coral or Charlotte Tilbury Coachella Coral for pinker coral!

The best by far is for me Lip Stick Queen’s Stoked from the Endless Summer collection – sheer but still with absolutely visible color payoff, perfect non-drying texturen and SPF. But yes, the color is just plain amazing and suits my pale winterskin as well as my summery golden tan.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!