Archived Post

Do you stick to one brand or prefer variety?


Do you stick to one brand or prefer variety? Maybe just a couple? Or do you have something from nearly every brand?

Lots and lots of variety!  I have found that–after being a long-time MAC user–variety is important.  It helps you learn what you should expect in products, what really works, what doesn’t, and what’s worth it.  I don’t have something from nearly every brand, but there is definitely diversity in the products I have.

Thanks to Emily for today’s question!

Got a question idea? Submit yours here.

29 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Ice Queen Avatar

I like variety. I have favourites, of course but I am not in the least brand loyal. I use what I like and what works. Skincare, hair care, makeup, nail polish… I mix and match to suit my own needs. 🙂

divinem (Melissa) Avatar

I used to stick to one brand until I happened along YOU! 😉 Now I have 5-6 favs . . .

MAC
MUFE
Dior
Estee Lauder
Zoya
Givenchy
Stila

I use and love them all. 🙂

Emily O. Avatar

Variety! It drives the market to create more interesting and high performing products ( the new Armani dream-like powder comes
to mind) Plus I love trying unique products, particularly when they have an interesting concept/color story, like
Illamasqua’s Toxic Nature. Three cheers for a varied and diverse cosmetic gene
pool!

Adee Avatar

I’m really brand loyal. Once I find something that works, I stick with it pretty much exclusively. Until it disappoints me, that is. So far I have been collecting MAC for over 6 years and have yet to be disappointed in any product I’ve gotten from them!

Nadia A. Avatar

Variety is the spice of life! I prefer trying products from different brands because I have yet to find one brand that has perfect products.

Tammie Avatar

I wish I could stick to one brand so I didn’t want so many things. But as it is I like a bunch of brands and go for the quality items no matter what brand.

Rosanna Avatar

I fall in love with quality. MAC is great but I’ve fallen for other brands’ quality. I definitely like to branch out but not too many at a time!

I prefer to focus on a few choice brands at a time. I’m currently in love with NARS. =)

Mariella Avatar

Variety, for sure. High end and low end and lots of variety both in skin care (I don’t buy that old line about how the products work better if you use everything from one line) to makeup. When it comes to colour cosmetics, variety really is the spice of life!

Karen Ogle Avatar

With my makeup, I use Avon exclusively because I’m a rep. With other products I try different things all the time. Like with nail polish I use several of the nail lacquers which are better than Avon polishes.

ann Avatar

Definitely variety. I’m the type of person who will go through what she’s wearing that day and the brands. Kind of weird, but it’s just have a habit I have. I don’t like to wear much of the same brand. Besides, no one brand has the best products! Each company has their strengths / weaknesses.
But if I find something that works, I’ll stick to it. I might stray once in a while, but in the end, I’ll always go back!

One thing about brands I’m a bit confused about is when makeup brands make skincare. I don’t know, maybe it’s just me, but I’m wary of trying skincare from brands like Nars and Bobbi Brown, but I’m not afraid of trying makeup from brands like Clinique! Weird thinking…

Natalie Avatar

I do generally stick to MAC for many things, but am totally willing to branch out. Some of my favorite, best-working products are from NARS, Dior, Chanel, Guerlain, MUFE, UD, and Too Faced. I really like experimenting with new brands since you never know where a favorite new hidden gem is lurking!

meme Avatar

I try lots of different brands. In skin care, I can be a bit more brand clinging only when I find a line that 2 or 3 products really work best together – otherwise it’s a free for all there too.

meme Avatar

Forgot to add, I am pretty loyal to my hair products. Once I find things that work there, I rarely switch until the brand changes something.

Laurel Avatar

I tend to use a variety of brands. If I could afford it, I would sure love to be brand loyal to Chanel or another high end brand. I can still find products I like at all brands and price points, thankfully.

Brie Avatar

I tend to keep my collection limited to less than 10 brands…As I am pretty much OCD about how my products look (both when worn and when stored!), I like to keep things pretty uniform. My favorites include:

Chanel (eyeshadow palettes/lip color/glosses)
Urban Decay (eyeshadow palettes)
MAC (eyeshadows and MSFs)
Benefit (blushes and brows)
Bobbi Brown (concealer and gel liner)
Laura Mercier (mineral foundation and tinted moisturizer)

Other than that, I do have a couple of random lower-priced brands:

Ulta (automatic eyeliners)
Milani (baked eyeshadows)
Express (lipglosses–surprisingly great)

Finally, I don’t keep anything as a “loner” (only having one product from a brand)…I have to have at least 2! And yes, I know I’m obsessed 😛

Vicky Avatar

Hmm, some variety, but not that much, I guess. It can get overwhelming.

Currently using some national brands and: Chanel, Dior, Lancôme, MAC, Guerlain, Clinique.

For skincare, I use mostly La Roche Posay.

Lyza Rae Avatar

I’m very loyal to Urban Decay, I have hundreds of dollars invested in them.
The only other high-end company I’ve ever bought from is Benefit, and I was satisfied.
But I’ll buy UD products online, sight unseen & completely confident.
Anything from another brand, I have to test instore before I buy.
I am open to trying new brands, they just really have to impress me in person.

Becca Avatar

well, I like to say taht I like diverstity (I do, I swear!)
but I actually tend to stick to MAC because they’re a cheeper high end brand and cuz of all the collections. I’m new to makeup (just stareted in September) so MAC is an easy place to start. Plus, I feel comfortable when I go to the store, I do a TON of research on m products and everything, so I always know what I’m looking for, whereas with Sephora or other department stores (not that Sephora is a department store, but you get the idea!) there are so many brands and collections and new releases that it’s easy to get overwhelmed.

Ayr Avatar

I have OCD, and it’s really important to me that I stick with one brand so all of the packaging matches. I go with Mac because they have great variety and it’s all I can afford as a teen. But I use different airbrush foundation so that is my only exception.

Shalimar Avatar

I am a variety kind of girl because I noticed that each brand knows how to do a product right, for example NARS is one of the best blushes that I have tried but I am willing to branch out. I wished I picked up some Rock and Republic blushes when I had the chance but I was oblivious to the line until it is too late. Their eyeshadows are pretty good so it wasn’t a total wash.

Alison Avatar

Brand isn’t something I consider (Unless the customer service is bad or the company practices animal testing/has a bad rep), just how effective the product is.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!