Archived Post

Do you mix shades together?


Do you mix shades together? Like two eyeshadows or mixing two lipsticks to get a different shade? What are your favorite combos?

I love lipstick and gloss together, because it’s always interesting to see how you can alter the underlying lipstick. I will also mix for brow shades often – like a slightly darker or super shimmery shade mixed with something more matte.

Thanks to Carla for today’s question! Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

25 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Xero Avatar

Sometimes I layer eyeshadows together, like when I want more golden shimmer in an eyeshadow; or layering powder eyeshadows over cream eyeshadow or eyeshadow over liner and things like that.

I seem to have a mental block on layering lipsticks though…I’ve done it before and I logically understand that if I mixed shades I could make every color I ever wanted–and yet I don’t. I’d rather buy a new lipstick than mix shades I already have, even though that’s totally unreasonable.

Jan Avatar

All the time. Eyeshadows, blushes, llpsticks/glosses/frosts
It’s how I can create shades that suit my skin tone.
Not to mention it’s a lot of fun!

KaseyCannuck Avatar

I have a couple of light frosty lipsticks that look like death on their own that I keep around just to add a highlight to the middle of my lips or a bit of shimmer to a matte finish. I layer eyeshadows all the time, especially over a cream eyeshadow base.

Wwendalynne Avatar

I am going to use the word layering instead of mixing for me. I’m not a huge fan of actually mixing products as I think it tends to just muddy the colours. So, definitely, I like to feel all mad scientist and I layer products frequently. Sometimes it works magic and others..not so much.. but that is the fun of it.

JJ Avatar

Yes! I find that I do that a lot with my lipsticks. I see them online, when I get it and try it on, it’s usually a completely different look on me. And I tend to mix different shades to get that look. Sometimes it’s a hit, and sometimes it’s a miss. But that’s the beauty of makeup! Trial and error and see what works for you. Just yesterday I had on Maybelline’s ColorSensational in Vivid Rose and felt I needed a more of a “pow”. I layered the Lip Tar “Hoochie” and they’re gorgeous together.

Geneva Avatar

I used to mix foundation shades until I found Chanel Perfection Lumiere and then went back to MAC and was put into an NC instead of NW. I sometimes line my lips with a color a little darker than my lipstick to create an ombre look, then add lip gloss in a lighter shade than the lipstick. It looks really pretty, IMO.

Haley Avatar

I like to layer MAC’s Up The Amp and MAC’s Speed Dial. I always use MAC’s Brule all over my eyelid whenever I do my makeup and then layer the other shades on top. I’ll mix shades for my crease, often I use both Naked and Buck from the Naked palette and layer them

Laia Avatar

I mix different shades of foundation because of my everchanging skin tone, going fairer as time goes by (got to admit that living in a country which has rain/clouds 90% of the time does its thing) and I am becoming a master of getting as many suitable shades as possible, depends on if I got sunkissed, if I spent 3 months without any sun at all, etc. Same goes for correctors.
Sometimes I also layer different eyeshadows, but it happens basically when I am going to a fancy party. For the rest, I like to keep it pure and simple!

doroffee Avatar

I do. Especially when I have limited possibilities (I only have a make-up bag of products on holiday). I usually do mixing when I want to tone down the warmness or the coolness of a certain shade.

Anne-Laure Avatar

Every day for foundation: I’m too dark for HD#115, too fair for HD#130, and too neutral for every shade in between, si I just mix’em up all year round, adding more and more #130 as I tan. It allows me to always have the perfect tone, any season with only 2 products!
I also layer lipstick to get my perfect coral, all the shades I purchased look awful on my complexion, but some combos bring them from wearable to perfect.

Kelsey Avatar

I love using glosses to just slightly change the colour of a lipstick… I used MAC’s “Feel My Pulse” from the temperature rising collection and pinked it up a bit using “Splashing” lipglass from the “To The Beach” collection… turned out just right with my light blue eyeshadow… a hard mark to hit without looking like Barbie hit the streets when that Doctor gig didn’t quite work out.

Erica Avatar

I mix shades almost regularly. I like making my own “customized” makeup. My current favorite is mixing MUFE Rouge Artist Intense Lipsticks #16 (bronze) and #17 (gold). So pretty together. I mix lipsticks, blend my eyeshadows, layer blushes together, layer nail polishes on top of each other , etc. It’s fun.

Natasha Avatar

I love mixing lip colours! My fave combo right now is mixing two Revlon Lip Butters – Cherry Tart and Gumdrop. Red mixed with lavender, you get the most beautiful shade of plummy-pink.

Claudia Avatar

I like to mix a light medium brown lippy with a deep red one, I’ve always liked mixing the two, they make such an interesting colour, obviously the red overpowers the brown but the brown brings it down a notch.

Mallory Avatar

I will layer eyeshadows but not really mix them, and occasionally I mix blushes together to give a more realistic blush or just to see what gorgeous shades can be created. but hands down my favorite thing to do is mix lipsticks. I layer lipsticks all the time and have found some incredibly stunning combinations and a way to finally use my Saint Germain. It might be too bright for me on it’s own but it is amazing mixed with other colors.

Jessica Avatar

I love to use any mac matte lipstick as a base and lay any lipstick shade over it. I also love the color I get from mixing mac’s da bling with coppering.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!