Devinah Cosmetics Matte & Pressed Pigment Shadow Swatches x53

1 of 4
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  
Devinah Cosmetics Pressed Pigment  

Last November (yes, November), I bought just over 50 eyeshadows from Devinah Cosmetics across their Matte Shadows and Pressed Pigment formulas. (Apparently, one set I purchased is only available as a bundle, oops!) After seeing regular readers across the blog and my social media channels mention this brand frequently, I decided to try them out. I have tested about 25% of the shades and have definitely found some of the concerning shades (when swatched) do apply better in practice. They have a more powdery/loosely-pressed and/or drier formula (and my arms are pretty dry, so that type of texture doesn’t adhere as well as a result), particularly the mattes and more sparkly shades (metallics are smoother, denser).

Devinah Cosmetics Shadows

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Explore Temptalia

We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!

Here are some useful resources for you:

Compare Any Two

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Psyched! I’m pleasantly surprised that you’re reviewing these. I’ve bought a few things from Devinah (two pre-made palettes and one palette I put together of purple shadows) and I really like their eye shadows. You are right in that they apply better than they swatch but I’ve been pleased with my purchases and won’t hesitate to purchase form Devinah again.

I have the Wizard of Oz set and a few other singles. The quality is nice. I don’t use them enough b/c they’re in a z-palette and I just don’t reach for singles for some reason.

Awesome! Devinah eyeshadows are the only ones I can use because they don’t have substances I am allergic too. They are pigment, super soft, blend beautifully without getting muddy. My collection only grows. Good bye mainstream brands.

Wow! I spy a few very unique shades that I’ll be super interested in seeing how they do in your reviews. One that I absolutely love at first sight, is Zane. I doubt that I either have a dupe or have ever seen anything that looks just like it!

I’ve never heard of this brand but those colors are great. A lot of them seem like unique takes on the usual colors. I especially love the purples.

I have quite a few Devinah single shadows. Like you, I had seen the name across social media and was intrigued. The shades that I have are very nice. I am anxious to see your reviews.

All of the shades that I have are pressed pigments. I was surprised by that when I went and looked! Anyway, I counted and I have 12 shades. The one’s that I like and use more frequently are: Willow, Starlit, Stunned, Reseda, Ladylove, Martini, Mermaid, Entice and Elicit. The other three are shades that I just didn’t love on me personally. Some of these are powdery but not any more so than say, ABH. I like the looks of several of the shades you are going to review so looking forward to it.

Thank you so much for this!! I’ve almost ordered from them a dozen times but in the end can’t settle on what to get and bail. This will help me for that first order for sure. If you do decide to get more of them, can you pick up some of the reds and highlighters, please?

I feel ya!!! There’s SOOO many to choose from it’s seriously overwhelming!!! I haven’t actually gotten to the point of placing an order yet, either, although I really really have been dying to try them!!! Especially some of those duochromes….I live and breath for duochromes!!!

I have about 6 shades including pretty light blue. They are powdery, bad quality and blend into nothing. Worse than morphe if that’s possible. Save your money and go for makeup geek or colourpop.

I had the same experience with this brand. They don’t build and blend into nothing. I tried putting them on over a cream base and that worked. My eyelids are oily so it is impractical. I bought the pink icing bundle and some singles.

I have a bunch of their shadows!!! So happy you’re doing this! I’ve found the exact same thing. They swatch badly on the arm (dry-feeling shimmers, powdery and hard to build-up mattes BUT!!! They apply beautifully to the eyelid and I don’t even use primer. I’ve made some beautiful sunset looks with their red, orange and yellow mattes that were effortless to blend.

Mumma Mia – these look fantastic! What beautiful shades and I love the shimmery finishes. I have never really heard of this brand before, so like Sydney Grace, I am very interested.

Oh glad you are reviewing Devinah shadows! I have a number of them (purples, blues, greens, reds), the matte pastel blues were weak (no surprise) but the rest were very good/good/decent. I have oily lids, so I always use primer. Huge selection of colors (including tons of mattes!!) , unique colors/finishes, comes in range of sizes/prices, very affordable. Their singles are a great way to fill in gaps in your stash. I also have a couple of their Dirty Beautiful Duo Chrome shadows and they’re stunning!

I’ve never heard of this brand. It’ll be very interesting to read the reviews.
There are some of these I really like a lot, so I look forward to the dupe lists, if I don’t have dupes for a few of the colours I’ll probably order the ones I like the most.

Wow, another epic undertaking. And right after the SG catalog! These have been on my radar for a while. Rachel and Michele Binxcat are fans, iirc. Of course, need more eyeshadow like I need more dog hair…. Came close to getting the Devinah version of the Tarte AF…once a joke, now a reality….but wound up getting the SG. One rabbit hole ought to be enough for this Alice, but……

There is never enough dog hair.. says the owner of a Bernese… My little LH dachshund, Digger, passed away recently with acute pancreatitis brought on by tumour. He was 14 and had an amazing life, but he was my beloved and heart and soul, and I miss him dearly. I have a new puppy, a Pembroke Welsh Corgi named Henry (or HenHen, or Henny Penny, or Bunny Henry, or little f*%ker). He has brought some much needed levity and merriment.. he’s a little terror bursting with personality..just the kind I love.

I bought the Secret Diaries bundle so I only know how the mattes perform but I’ve found mixed results. I know that some of these shades can be tricky in a matte formula. However, I do agree with your initial reaction some of these don’t blend well. It can be tricky when trying to lay down a dark shadow in the crease or applying it the the outer corner. I am wondering if the other finishes would be better from this brand. I am anxious to hear your reviews.

So glad you are getting into Devinah, Christine. I got the recent green bundle which I don’t think was available in November. It really filled a gap in my collection. Although at first glance, the shades look similar, because a number of them fall into that warm and murky range, I like the nuances though it only has a few cools. I skipped the Colour Pop green palette, Smoke Sessions, and Safari Raine because Devinah had the shades I liked covered. If people really love the cool greens, the CP and Melt may be better. I’ve worn it a lot, have no issues, wear all eye shadows with primer. I also think it pairs well with CP Good Sport which has some light and bright accent metallics in yellow and green.

I’ve been terribly curious about this brand since someone mentioned them here a couple weeks ago. Thanks for this!

I’m glad you swatched and are testing these! I have the Wizard of Oz set and a few other shimmer shadows, and they’re beautiful. I haven’t tried any of their mattes yet, so I’m curious to see how good they are. If good, Zane would go on my buy list.

Devinah’s highlighters are excellent, too. I own about a half dozen.

This decision was made last November, Hannah – I am only getting around to posting now as I was working on the Sydney Grace eyeshadows first but took the photos/swatches in the same timeframe. Hope that clarifies!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!