What color of eyeliner do you wear the most?

What color of eyeliner do you wear the most? Share!

I’m sure you could guess it, but teal!

Thanks to reader Melinda for today’s question idea Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

I like black mainly for my upper lashline. But to line my waterline and smudge out, I go for a warm brown. Crazy, I know. I do like to wear the occasional bright eyeshadow as liner though.

Black. I’m not really a fan of coloured eyeliner. I only really use black, grey and brown. I prefer to wear a pop of bright eyeshadow rather than bright liner.

I’d say it’s pretty even between black (UD Perversion pencil is my favorite) and purple. I have 25-30 different purple eyeliners. Purple makes the green in my hazel eyes really pop.

Matte Brown. I have dozens of colored eyeliners and I love black ones, but at the end I mostly gravitate to brown. It’s more natural and wearable for me. My favorite one is MAC Coffee.

Have you tried Dolce & Gabanna in Peacock? It’s a beautiful, medium teal color that can be built up to a darker teal. It goes on like a dream and, on me, it doesn’t fade or smudge all day. Definitely one of my favorites!

SNAP! πŸ˜€ Go teal!

Technically it’s tied with bark brown, as I almost always have Demolition on my waterlines even if I have another shade on my lash line. πŸ˜‰

Christine, I was just thinking about this question (or, more rightly, your answer – which I knew would be “teal’) and I was wondering….in an average week, how often do you get to wear the makeup YOU want to wear rather than products you’re testing? Would it be 1 day a week? One day every two weeks? I realize it must change depending on which huge collections have come out, etc., but I just wondered “on average” how often you can do this. I’d bet others are curious too.

Hey Mariella!

Like full makeup? Maybe once a month – usually just in the evening so I’ll test something during the day for 8-10 hours, then remove and redo for dinner out or something like that. Mostly for special occasions like anniversary dinner!

Building on that question, is there a time limit on how long you’ll keep reviewed makeup in storage before tossing it? (I just found some eye and lip liners from my days in cosmetology school that are four years older than my oldest daughter, and she’s 22! LOL)

It just depends – I usually do a major sift through every six months, and any time a brand reformulates, I toss the original formula (I might keep one or two more unique shades for posterity).

Apart from black, anything golden or generally warm, because it makes my eyes look slightly bluer. Or purple if I want to bring out the green πŸ™‚ I stay away from blues and teals, unless I’m recreating a look.
(sorry for bad English)

It would have to be dark matte brown – specifically Covergirl Liquiline Blast in Brown Blaze. Complete workhorse for me! Black would be a close second, though since I bought MAC Undercurrent I have worn it a LOT!!

I don’t really wear any… I have been enjoying the Nars Night Series, just to do something different, but normally I don’t as I feel they only make my eyes look smaller. I guess. I have been wearing taupe-y or khakis, as well. I am a neutral gal for sure.

Grey – Marc Jacobs (Stone)Fox is a staple and the shimmer is a nice twist on a traditional shade. UD Smoke, Chantecaille Hematite, and Laura Mercier Slate are also favorites.

Bronze-y browns are a close second with Marc Jacobs Brown(out) being my favorite at the moment.

When I want something totally different, I grab Clinique Quickliner in Intense Aubergine, which is a deep, inky plum that makes my blue-grey eyes pop.

i used to only wear black, but now I find that a dark,cool, matte brown is a softer look and more flattering to my older eyes. Sometimes I will pull out the black again. I am partial to the Kat VD eyeliner pen because I can get a really fine line with it.

I’m with you on teal! Also blackened green or interesting greens like MAC Undercurrent. Black for most of the professional occasions. I recently fall in love with soft brown with shimmers and purples.

The new Hourglass Mechanical Gel Eye Liner (Obsidian/Black) has been my go-to lately. I love how close I can get to the lashline with it. I know some people had smudging issues with it, but it’s worked great for me. I am hoping it will come out in more colors.

I mostly wear black winged eyeliner and I love the boobi brown gel eyeliner in black ink with the mac 266 brush πŸ™‚ when I wear something on the waterline (other than nude)its a dark purple because it makes my dark brown eyes pop xx

I wear black more than anything these days because I frequently just line my upper waterline these days. So boring of me! I used to wear a bright turquoise or teal.

PLUM, for sure!
I have green eyes and NW15 skin, so a deep plum liner plays up my eye color and adds definition without looking harsh. My “go-to” is Trish McEvoy Eye Definer in Deep Aubergine. I also occasionally wear dark brown or black, applied very close to my top lash lines. Since recently turning 50, I’ve become paranoid about my makeup looking harsh.

I like fluffing around with all sorts of colours: if I’m not wearing any eyeshadow then I’ll wear black, brown, blue, green and purple liquid eyeliners on my upper lash line. If I am wearing eyeshadow then I’ll wear black or brown mainly with a green or violet pencil on my lower waterline(unless I’m going out somewhere fancy schmancy at night when I’ll wear black on my lower waterline for a bit of drama !)

I switch it up a lot, but no matter what color wing I’m going for, I usually throw a thin black wing under it, tightline (at least the top lashes) in black – or toss a flesh color on the bottom waterline. Solo-colorwise it’s probably blood red or burgundy.

Mac RIch Ground fluidline. The coppery color matches my hair so it looks very natural and gives my eyes definition without looking harsh. Even most browns look to harsh on me and the copper color makes my eyes look bluer. I do wear black but only for night time looks when I don’t care about looking natural.

On my upper lash line, black and navy are used about equally. On the lower lash line, it varies by season but mostly teal or purple.

Black is my staple eyeliner color obviously, but my favorite colored or more interesting colored eyeliner is purple or an olive, deeper green. It really makes my brown eyes pop.

Just black if I’m doing a winged liner. Since my eyes are hooded, I often go big or go home with winged liner since smaller wings look odd and misshapen on me. Sometimes I’ll wear a deep purple liner on my lower lash line like Urban Decay Empire pencil.

Urban Decay Bourbon. It is just a perfect brown for me. It makes my eyes look really green, and it wears really well and long. I have a few other 24/7 eyeliners, but this color seems to be the one I use the most. I just love it.

Coppery browns and warm, redder rather than blue plums. Really bring out the green and blue in my hazel eyes. It’s very difficult to find good warm plums. any suggestions?

I love Clinique intense peacock. Which is teal. My other go to colors are intense ebony, chocolate, ivy and amethyst all clinique intense. Stay on all day with no tugging.

I have black lashes and so I always use black to tightline my upper lashes. For actual eyeliner, I use dark shades of eyeshadow smudged along my lower and upper lashes with my preference being for blackened colors. When I worked, black, grey, and brown were my go-to liners. Now that I’m retired, I have a bit more fun with subtle color.

I wear colored gel liner every day. I try to coordinate with whatever I’m wearing. My favorite formula is NARS Eye Paints – used to be YSL cream liners, but they’ve apparently discontinued the product. Too bad. Black Bronze was a favorite – I bought backups!

Now my favorite NARS are Snake Eyes and Ubangi. Bal Bek is a great neutral – sort of like YSL’s Black Bronze

Clinique Cake Eyeliner in Black and often in Brown. I like that I can get it closer to my lash line than I can with pencil liners, and I have more control of the shade depth than I get with creams or pencils.

Black on the upper lashline and if I thightline, just about any colour on the lower lashline. Quite often a neutral or an almost white on the waterline.

I usually wear a very dark brown eyeshadow as eyeliner. L’Oreal Lush Raven applied with an angled brush and I wet the brush when I want a more dramatic look

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! πŸ™‚ If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!